CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Crazy Bacon Legs]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

When did this happen?

You had him on a list of like 10 other people (those who voted for all town) but you never campaigned for him individually until he had a lot of votes.

unvote
Vote: Crazy Bacon Legs

Point me to your posts of lynching starseed before he had a ton of votes and I'll reconsider but right now it looks like you're just trying to take credit for a mafia kill that you tagged along on.

Wow, really? Read post 1314 again and you'll see where I said he was highest on my list. I voted for him, a bunch of people backed out, and I stuck to my guns. And I voted for him after 5 other people did. I don't have my measuring device handy, but I'm pretty sure 5 isn't a "ton of votes".

Once again, you have a REALLY weird obsession with me and you have from the start of the game. Did you not read my recent large post where I just specifically mentioned who I think are mafia?

Are you trying to protect Baxter Renegade? It's odd that you jump on flameswin and then ignore the blatantly suspicious voting patterns and posts by Baxter.

[ineedanother]

I think the best course of action is to lynch someone else for today's vote. We can always look at the reveal after tonight, as we would have more information. Right now the only info we have is Baxter's reveal and Kermit, Rathji and CBL immediately accusing him of lying. I think we should look at lynching flameswin, CBL or Lego Man as they all seem like better targets right now, as mall should give us more info.

[Oling_Roachinen]

I say keep Baxter around. Let the mafia deal with him during a night phase.

If he is a doctor they need to target him or else as we get less players his odds of protecting increase and he'll actually start saving us. They have their own dilemma now, if he is doctor and both target they waste a kill, if they both don't they risk him saving others down the line.

If he is mafia, the other mafias goal is to eliminate each other. At least one group has incentive to kill him just as much as we do. So doctor or mafia, he's a target to them.

I do trust him though, I also like his list. Kermitology posted that contradictory reason for voting and unvoting agulati. Lego Man has that Completely stuff and Crazy Bacon Legs is Crazy Bacon Legs.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Crazy Bacon Legs

Wow, really? Read post 1314 again and you'll see where I said he was highest on my list. I voted for him, a bunch of people backed out, and I stuck to my guns.

There was HalifaxDrunk, Baxter Renegade, myself, flameswin, Rathji, strombad, Street Pharmacist and undercoverbrother who had voted for starseed before you made your vote. Wasn't a small amount and you hadn't been pushing for him the days before at all except listing him in a group of a lot of posters.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

I do trust him though, I also like his list. Kermitology posted that contradictory reason for voting and unvoting agulati. Lego Man has that Completely stuff and Crazy Bacon Legs is Crazy Bacon Legs.

Not to mention he managed to swing the votes from Lego (who recently said the most incriminating things this thread has seen) to me, then accuses me of lying about being the Dr, then tells the "real Dr" not to reveal himself... I mean c'mon. If I was lying, and the real Dr saw my posts, do you really think anyone over the age of 5 would exclaim "Hey, I'm the Dr! You can't be!". CBL says this to subtly attempt to show false affiliation with Town.

I can't stress this enough:

LEGO
CBL
KERMIT

My flip NEEDS to push this list!

[Crazy Bacon Legs]

You people are seriously falling for Baxter's "I'm the Doctor" schtick?

Please go back and read his posts and look at his voting pattern.

ineedanother: of course I accused Baxter Renegade of lying about being the doctor. It's because he's mafia, ergo is lying. What else am I supposed to do but accuse him of lying when he is?

[Crazy Bacon Legs]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Not to mention he managed to swing the votes from Lego (who recently said the most incriminating things this thread has seen) to me, then accuses me of lying about being the Dr, then tells the "real Dr" not to reveal himself... I mean c'mon. If I was lying, and the real Dr saw my posts, do you really think anyone over the age of 5 would exclaim "Hey, I'm the Dr! You can't be!". CBL says this to subtly attempt to show false affiliation with Town.

I can't stress this enough:

LEGO
CBL
KERMIT

My flip NEEDS to push this list!

Yeah, we heard this whole "my flip will reveal the true culprits!" stuff from starseed as well.

And he totally wasn't mafia, was he?

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Crazy Bacon Legs

You people are seriously falling for Baxter's "I'm the Doctor" schtick?

Please go back and read his posts and look at his voting pattern.

ineedanother: of course I accused Baxter Renegade of lying about being the doctor. It's because he's mafia, ergo is lying. What else am I supposed to do but accuse him of lying when he is?

C'mon... Only Mafia would play your game. Here's why:

Mafia though process:

Even if I am lying, a mafia member would know I'm not in their group. Lynching me means they either lynch the Dr, a townie, or a rival gang member. They can then go ahead and win this lynch while killing another person at night. Win Win.

Town thought process:

Even if the town believes I'm lying and a part of the mafia, my revelation all but guarantees I'm killed at night by one or both groups. Lynching me means killing the Dr, killing a fellow townie, or killing a mafia member and leaving both night kills to occurr. Why the heck would the town lynch me when I'm doomed anyways at night? Since I am in fact the Dr, saving me from lynch allows a possible townie save tonight, while I'm certainly blown away a few minutes later...


There is no grey area here guys, only black and white. My actions are a final attempt to help this town. It's the only thing a Dr who is about to get lynched could possibly do to help us win.

[kermitology]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

I do trust him though, I also like his list. Kermitology posted that contradictory reason for voting and unvoting agulati. Lego Man has that Completely stuff and Crazy Bacon Legs is Crazy Bacon Legs.

What contradictory reason? I voted initially for agulati because he seemed desperate to recover from what seemed like a stupid slip. When Mazrim posted the vote totals and I saw 21-0 I realized it didn't make sense. I also realized that I posted that after your post, but specifically it was the posting of the vote totals that set me on edge about agulati.

I then followed that up with my Unvote and said it was just him squirming because he couldn't think of a better way to explain himself. It was just stupidity (sorry agulati) not mafia.

Think whatever you want. I'm not afraid to die. If my death draws attention to my accusers, I've been voting for Baxter for a while, I don't trust him in the slightest.

That being said, I'm happy to see him night killed for trying to convince us he's the doctor, which I don't believe.

[B]unvote[\B]

[kermitology]

I hate posting from tapatalk [B]unvote[\B]

[kermitology]

Jesus.. Unvote

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by kermitology

What contradictory reason?

Originally Posted by kermitology

Too much squirming

Vote: agulati

Originally Posted by kermitology

I'm not convinced agulati is mafia. He squirmed a lot. It just doesn't feel right.

Unvote

Those ones.

[kermitology]

You conveniently leave out the explanations in the middle.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by kermitology

You conveniently leave out the explanations in the middle.

You asked "what contradictory reason?" You knew you voted for him because he was squirming and then unvoted for him because he was squirming, you shouldn't have asked that question but expanded on your reasoning to show why you don't believe it was.

[kermitology]

I did, and I reference it in my post above.

Vote: Oling_Roachinen

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by kermitology

I did, and I reference it in my post above.

You still asked the question. Not sure why you would.

If I said:

I hate the colour green

And then fives hour said:

I love the colour green

And someone asked why I was contradicting myself, I wouldn't be "What contradiction?" I would have been like "Oh, let me explain...."

There's 0 room to be left wondering why someone thought you're voting was contradictory with your posts like that.

[kermitology]

You stated that I contradicted myself, I provided my reasoning for CHANGING MY MIND about how to interpret agulati's posts. That's not a contradiction, that's a change to my thoughts based on new evidence.

[Rathji]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

C'mon... Only Mafia would play your game. Here's why:

Mafia though process:

Even if I am lying, a mafia member would know I'm not in their group. Lynching me means they either lynch the Dr, a townie, or a rival gang member. They can then go ahead and win this lynch while killing another person at night. Win Win.

Town thought process:

Even if the town believes I'm lying and a part of the mafia, my revelation all but guarantees I'm killed at night by one or both groups. Lynching me means killing the Dr, killing a fellow townie, or killing a mafia member and leaving both night kills to occurr. Why the heck would the town lynch me when I'm doomed anyways at night? Since I am in fact the Dr, saving me from lynch allows a possible townie save tonight, while I'm certainly blown away a few minutes later...


There is no grey area here guys, only black and white. My actions are a final attempt to help this town. It's the only thing a Dr who is about to get lynched could possibly do to help us win.

Ok that earns an unvote

Solid logic. I was considering it before this post to be honest, but I had to drive to Ft McLeod last night after my batch of posts, so my only checking this thread was at the Claresholme 7-11. Not really a good place to form a solid opinion.

Now so we have to figure out where to go from here.

If the top of my head, CC, CBL and CoR are likely targets.

CBL for his run on Baxter, CoR and CC because they are trying to put focus on me when from the rest of the posts, no one else is even considering me an option due to my posting history.

Honestly, I think this means I would end up a mafia target tonight because they will realize that they can't lynch me at this point. If course the Baxter situation means I might have an extra days grace.

I suspect we are at the point now where mafia will need to be a bit more brazen to force the issue.

Going to

vote captaincrunch

for now, because until I am convinced otherwise, that's my default position.

[CaptainCrunch]

I'm not going to convince you otherwise, even though everything I've done has been to target mafia or suspected mafia who give pretty compelling arguments that they are mafia.

You on the other hand have consistently voted with a mafia member To me where as that is suspicious as hell, I'm still convinced that Lego is mafia and the fact that the focus has moved away from him is utterly baffling, but I'm going to stick with him on that vote for now.

[dissentowner]

Christ...unvote