2023/2024 Trade Rumors and Speculation Thread

[Icon]

Originally Posted by Sec214

Wonder which college players we're getting back in trades.

[Sec214]

Originally Posted by Heavy Jack

Hopefully you didn’t get wrist slapped… and I don’t think you were.

This is all by design and all the GMs are playing directly into Conman’s hands!

Not at all. I haven't been taking the time out of my childadulthood life to share with CP.

[Monahammer]

It is interesting. I wonder what the top value of Tanev is on his own? I would ask Holloway and 1st from Edmonton. They probably wouldnt go that far.

But in relation to trading him to Dallas, for example, are we potentially leaving value on the table by adding him to Hanifin?
I.e. if we think Hanifin is worth a 1st + top prospect + (if he resigns, more)
and if we think Tanev = 2nd + prospect or 1st

We'd have to be careful not to get sucked in by really wanting a certain player and leaving too much value on the table. Stankoven alone isn't going to cut it to balance that type of package out, especially if we're retaining. But how much more could we reasonably ask for then one of the top prospects in the league?

[Bonded]

Originally Posted by Sec214

Not at all. I haven't been taking the time out of my childadulthood life to share with CP.

[Bingo]

Originally Posted by cam_calderon

I'm curious why people prefer a guessing game to straight up reporting. You don't see LeBrun or Friedman posting cryptic gifs on twitter regarding potential trades.

Just not going to let this go huh?

[Heavy Jack]

Edmonton would be fools not to accept Tanev for a 1st and Holloway. Their window is closing and rapidly now all why they still have glaring need at D and goaltending, which is either red hot or ice cold, they have no stabilizing presence. From the flame’s perspective helping out a bitter, bitter rival with their exact need has to come a larger cost than a non rival.

[Bonded]

Originally Posted by Monahammer

It is interesting. I wonder what the top value of Tanev is on his own? I would ask Holloway and 1st from Edmonton. They probably wouldnt go that far.

But in relation to trading him to Dallas, for example, are we potentially leaving value on the table by adding him to Hanifin?
I.e. if we think Hanifin is worth a 1st + top prospect + (if he resigns, more)
and if we think Tanev = 2nd + prospect or 1st

We'd have to be careful not to get sucked in by really wanting a certain player and leaving too much value on the table. Stankoven alone isn't going to cut it to balance that type of package out, especially if we're retaining. But how much more could we reasonably ask for then one of the top prospects in the league?

I think Dallas will have to put together a really strong package to get them both. Conroy didn't minimize Tanev's value in the Lindholm trade. Don't think he will do it now.

[Bingo]

Originally Posted by cam_calderon

I'd be surprised if Craig Conroy is feeding Sec information. But I'd be completely shocked if he even knows of this website's existence.

Cool.

Lets hammer me too!

[Bingo]

Originally Posted by Reign of Fire

I am in support of Sec posting his GIFs. I want insights into what's going on behind the scenes. You are quick with the moron comment...I don't even know how you can take my comment and think I am taking a shot at Sec. I know things can change. Sec is not the one making the trades.

I thought Hackey made the Seklund comment.

[cam_calderon]

Originally Posted by Bingo

Cool.

Lets hammer me too!

It's not a shot at this website. I have navigated here every day for the past 11 or so years since I first discovered it. I was only pointing out that the GM of a hockey club does not take stock in the opinions of fans on the internet. As they relate to on-ice matters, at least.

[kukkudo]

Originally Posted by Heavy Jack

Edmonton would be fools not to accept Tanev for a 1st and Holloway. Their window is closing and rapidly now all why they still have glaring need at D and goaltending, which is either red hot or ice cold, they have no stabilizing presence. From the flame’s perspective helping out a bitter, bitter rival with their exact need has to come a larger cost than a non rival.

Of all teams Edmonton should be overpaying big, that team will be a dumpster fire in two years (I see the poster boys leaving).

[V1nnyTh3Flam35Fan]

Trade Tanev (50% RS) to Dallas for Joel Hanley, George Fegaras, 1st round pick 2024

Trade Noah Hanifin to Detroit for Simon Edvinsson, Jared McIsaac, conditional 1st round pick 2024, and 2nd round pick 2025
Condition: ->depending on which 2024 1st round pick Detroit sends to Ottawa (their own or Boston’s), they will send the other 2024 1st round pick to Calgary

Defence after trades:
Weegar/Andersson
Kylington/Pachal
Edvinsson/Hanley
Oesterle or Gilbert

[D as in David]

Originally Posted by Bingo

Cool.

Lets hammer me too!

[D as in David]

Originally Posted by kukkudo

Of all teams Edmonton should be overpaying big, that team will be a dumpster fire in two years (I see the poster boys leaving).

Make it an unprotected 2026 1st coming back for Tanev.

[Hack&Lube]

Originally Posted by cam_calderon

It's a way for people to communicate on social media and in group chats. I'd like to think the level of discourse is higher here on CP. Maybe I'm just reaching for the stars.

Have you ever a single post-game thread? GIFs are a way of life here.

[topfiverecords]

Originally Posted by Icon

Wonder which college players we're getting back in trades.

Think which best players not in the NCAA (high schoolers) we're getting back in trades!

[DionTheDman]

Originally Posted by Heavy Jack

they have no stabilizing presence.

I thought Ekholm was supposed to be that for them...

[Bingo]

Originally Posted by cam_calderon

It's not a shot at this website. I have navigated here every day for the past 11 or so years since I first discovered it. I was only pointing out that the GM of a hockey club does not take stock in the opinions of fans on the internet. As they relate to on-ice matters, at least.

Years ago Ken King reached out to discuss Calgarypuck and the importance of it to the organization.

He said it's amazing feedback for free for every department in our organization.

Would never suggest Conroy is ready CP for advice, but I would guess he's heard of it.

[Jiggy_12]

Yeah I don't know why the GM of a team wouldn't be aware of the largest gathering of their fan's opinions. It's an odd shot to take

[cam_calderon]

Originally Posted by Bingo

Years ago Ken King reached out to discuss Calgarypuck and the importance of it to the organization.

He said it's amazing feedback for free for every department in our organization.

Would never suggest Conroy is ready CP for advice, but I would guess he's heard of it.

I'd never heard that, that is high praise indeed. Sorry for any offence caused.