Calgarypuck Mafia Game Thread

[DropIt]

So Basically, HG and I are accusing each other of the same thing, yeah? But somehow it is more believable that:

I'd kill off my own guy day 1, leave GGG alone when he was basically on the hot seat and ripe for killing, and then quietly play/investigate the next 2 days and arguably being one of the first to mistakenly get the SebC train rolling.

Instead of, HG not voting off his own guy day 1, then jumping on GGG immediately after the Bonded kill when he was on the hot seat, after getting the GGG kill he then is part of the Crazy vote the next day.

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by WinnipegFan

Alright if the town is voting DropIt I can live with that he is one of the two I suspected. Mrk has been better at explaining his actions but he is still on my watch list.

What else can I explain for you? Questions/queries welcome.

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by WinnipegFan

I would vote now but don't want to hammer if people want to wait. I will give it another hour then vote if people are ok with it.

Why would you do this? I'm clearly leading in the votes and can do nothing but either sit here and wait or continue answering questions and potentially uncovering things for if (when) I do flip Flames Fan.

If you play this again I'd seriously consider thinking out your voting habits as I would be 2 poorly timed votes on your part.

Or maybe you're just antsy to live another day?

[mrkajz44]

Glad to see things move off me, but not overly happy to see things on DropIt. Would much rather see things on Winnipeg - not sure there is time/enough players on right now to make that happen though

Sent from my EML-L09 using Tapatalk

[DropIt]

Ar the risk of sounding desperate, which I suppose I am, there seems to be alot of empty content and posting while saying absolutely nothing from devo.

He dips his toes into

Originally Posted by devo22

after reading back a bit, I see Scorns point about DropIt and am willing to make the jump as well.

Originally Posted by devo22

my vote on mrkajz is not set in stone. I really only have the voting history on him, and the more I think about it the less it convinces me.

Originally Posted by devo22

the only one in there that still kind of irks me is WinnipegFan, who voted after the Fuzz reveal and set up GGGs suicide. But that can easily be a town vote by a new player too.

Originally Posted by devo22

might as well throw a vote out there at this point. I'll go mrkajz44 for now, primarily based on voting history and gut feeling.

And that's all quite shortly after this post:

Originally Posted by devo22

yeah it's frustrating. I hoped there'd be more discussion today, but only a handful posts after I went to bed yesterday is disappointing.

Looking back at all the votes, I just don't think any of the Bonded voters are Oilers. It was a close vote, and none of them just piled on but were key votes. Puxlut was the fourth vote, DropIt the fifth and Scornfire the sixth and deciding vote. If they were Oilers, they could have easily voted for agulati or, in Pux and DropIts case, for Scornfire without a lot of ramifications. Day 1 is a crapshoot and a Flames cardflip wouldn't just make them suspicious. Voting for an Oiler in such a vote makes no sense, so I'm thinking those three are probably Flames. As for the GGG voters, Hockeyguy went hard at him multiple times and was adamant on the lynch. Gives me a strong town feel as well.

So that leaves WinnipegFan and mrkajz44 for me. WF did vote for GGG, but the timing of him setting up hammer a.k.a. GGGs suicide doesn't sit well with me (in addition to his playing style). I still think he's town, but maybe his style is by design. As an Oiler, it wouldn't be the worst strategy to carry on like early in the game. He's not lynched because he's assumed town (only SebC argued for his lynch despite this) and we're not surprised he isn't nightkilled. So if he is an Oiler, it's decent play at this point. I still have him on my radar.

So you are really flip flopping on any general position you claim to have. In 24 hours I went from safe to you voting for me with pretty much no input yourself.

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by mrkajz44

Glad to see things move off me, but not overly happy to see things on DropIt. Would much rather see things on Winnipeg - not sure there is time/enough players on right now to make that happen though

Sent from my EML-L09 using Tapatalk

As much as I dont want to deplete town numbers by another 2 today, I have come to terms with being axed as unfortunate as it may be.

But this is twice now that WPG has potentially ruined the hammer process. Officially once and a second time would be hammering me for no reason when I'm active and trying to provide some form of input

[WinnipegFan]

Originally Posted by DropIt

Why would you do this? I'm clearly leading in the votes and can do nothing but either sit here and wait or continue answering questions and potentially uncovering things for if (when) I do flip Flames Fan.

If you play this again I'd seriously consider thinking out your voting habits as I would be 2 poorly timed votes on your part.

Or maybe you're just antsy to live another day?

I asked for the town to let me know to avoid this exact thing. I didn’t just vote away. So this is a moot argument.

[WinnipegFan]

Originally Posted by DropIt

As much as I dont want to deplete town numbers by another 2 today, I have come to terms with being axed as unfortunate as it may be.

But this is twice now that WPG has potentially ruined the hammer process. Officially once and a second time would be hammering me for no reason when I'm active and trying to provide some form of input

Again not doing so unless we all agree. I understand the hammer and made sure I didn’t do it this time without people’s support. However, I wanted my vote opinion know. These are some desperate attempts to move the target off of you.

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by WinnipegFan

Again not doing so unless we all agree. I understand the hammer and made sure I didn’t do it this time without people’s support. However, I wanted my vote opinion know. These are some desperate attempts to move the target off of you.

You said you'd give it another hour, then vote if people were ok with it. You could have voted since there were no objections for all we know.

It would be just as easy to claim to be voting me out, but not at hammer. Many have done the same already. There is absolutely no reason to vote me out if you believe I'm Mafia.

I'm hoping your terrible voting habits get you some more attention in future days

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by WinnipegFan

Again not doing so unless we all agree. I understand the hammer and made sure I didn’t do it this time without people’s support. However, I wanted my vote opinion know. These are some desperate attempts to move the target off of you.

Absolutely they are, and I would hope so from any other Townie on the block. If there is even a stitch of information I can bring to light or make known either to save myself and narrow the numbers down to actual mafia, or to help garner some conversation to side the townies for the next day the better.

Unfortunately the level of activity here makes me doubt either of these scenarios play out

[WinnipegFan]

So I’m reviewing this all right now and am wondering about Pux.... she has flown very much under the radar here as well. I can’t piece anything together but does anyone have a strong opinion here? I am starting to doubt our DropIt vote. I feel like we are missing something. So far it feels like townies pointing at each other and defending while an Oiler watches and Pux really stays mute most of the day and points randomly, even an attempt at Scornfire. Thoughts?

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by WinnipegFan

So I’m reviewing this all right now and am wondering about Pux.... she has flown very much under the radar here as well. I can’t piece anything together but does anyone have a strong opinion here? I am starting to doubt our DropIt vote. I feel like we are missing something. So far it feels like townies pointing at each other and defending while an Oiler watches and Pux really stays mute most of the day and points randomly, even an attempt at Scornfire. Thoughts?

Honestly, it is pretty obvious I'm on board with just about anyone else but myself since I know where I stand, obviously.

As far as I'm concerned, I expected to be under investigation at some point and when it came I welcomed the questions and backed myself up as best I knew how and thought I could deem myself safe when it came time.

Pux and devo to me are both too quiet and only got quieter when each day passed, as mafia members declined. Only really poking their heads out to defend themselves.

My ONLY real defense against Pux is how much GGG wanted her looked at before the Bonded lynch, which would be peculiar but at the same time, if that happened and she flipped Oiler ot would put Bonded and GGG in a good light amongst remaining Flame fans

[DropIt]

That being said I also am cautious about voting out someone, them flipping Flames and then becoming the target again afterwards. That would be a 4 straight Flames fans loss and leave only 3 left at 1 day. If we were to potentially flip votes last minute, and I would become public enemy #1 If that went wrong id rather you just kill me off now and gain a day of non-tunnel visioned voting

Originally Posted by DropIt

My ONLY real defense against Pux is how much GGG wanted her looked at before the Bonded lynch, which would be peculiar but at the same time, if that happened and she flipped Oiler ot would put Bonded and GGG in a good light amongst remaining Flame fans

Of course he would want be looked at. Because I'm a wasted investigation. MOD finds me as town and the coilers carry on their merry way killing us off (and killing ourselves off).

I'm not a fan of the Drop it vote. I would be into a mrk, Scorn or even WF for throwing a "GGG-like finger point" post at me most recently.

Sorry, that should say "he would want me to be looked at"

[DropIt]

Based on general activity and latest suspicion, I'm going to throw a vote out for Devo as he has become my #1 target and maybe it catches on.

Otherwise, as I mentioned before, if I am going to be the #1 target come next day and everyone grows blinders then just kill me off, take the 2 player loss and move on with no second guesses.

Right now it's 3 votes Drop it, 1 vote mrk, 1 vote HG... Is that correct?

Remove vote: mrkajz44

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

Of course he would want be looked at. Because I'm a wasted investigation. MOD finds me as town and the coilers carry on their merry way killing us off (and killing ourselves off).

I'm not a fan of the Drop it vote. I would be into a mrk, Scorn or even WF for throwing a "GGG-like finger point" post at me most recently.

If I remember correctly it wasnt that he wanted you looked at, it was the fact that he was making a case to change votes from Bonded to you last minute.

Originally Posted by GGG

Is anyone up for a Pux lynch if we had 5 and some from all three trains together we could move but probably not worth the risk of a no lynch.

I'm not sure if that absolves you, or while we discuss some self voting/killing of mafia members unto themselves if that makes you a top target, as GGG looking at you so close to hammer time maybe was a last second parting gift before his death

[DropIt]

Vote: Devo22