Quote:
Originally Posted by polak
Ummm that's exactly what could happen.
Plus how do you think a regular womens team will compete with a womans team with two or more biological males playing on it cause they identify as women? Imagine if that's a championship game and all of the sudden the best girl on the other team is better defended against cause she's up against a biological man and boom. Bye Bye scholarship.
Men and Women should be separated in sports. Jesus. Why does everything have to so inclusive these days.
|
the above is important.
Thiis whole post may probably be wrong and I should just keep my big mouth shut.
I'm not talking about intramural teams, or phys'd classes or anything like that. I'm talking about the for competitive teams.
We've seen a lot of girls pushing up to the higher levels in hockey and football for example. Two of the more physical games. It used to be in hockey that it was rare to see a girl play on a men's competitive team and they were usually done and playing girls hockey by the time they hit 14 or 15 and body types became a dis-advantage. With less emphasis on hitting in these games they tend to go a little further before they hit the glass ceiling.
On football, you see lots of girls playing at the atom level, a few push through to Bantam, and there are a rare few that get to highschool.
I've known two girls that have played high school ball, one was an 0-lineman and one was a defensive back. The defensive back didn't get a lot of playing time at the high school level, because she was a couple of steps behind in terms of speed, and strength, but she had the aggression and worked the technique. But because of the first two, she really only saw field time when a game was out of reach. the other girl is an offensive lineman, and she gets regular snaps, she tends to be technique strong, because without that she would get murdered.
But chances are you're never going to see a girl at higher levels unless its in a kicking role.
Now on the other side, and lets use this as a hypothetical even though it could be and might not be.
But you have a woman's football league, its girls from 18 to whatever. One team has a trans female at QB. Her playbook is basically two pages long, take the ball and roll and run or throw it 40 yards downfield. Basically no one can touch her speed wise, or throwing wise. She a massive unfair advantage to her team because she is stronger, faster and more durable then anything else on the field by a wide margin.
Now lets say as the coach of that team, you realize that speed and strength advantage so you play her two ways, at QB and at linebacker, two way play isn't illegal in this league because most teams are short rostered, because recruiting woman athletes to a new sport is tough. Now you have a linebacker that is x degrees faster, more agile, and hits like a bus.
Now lets go back to the competitive sports where competition matters, lets look at track and field. You're competing in the discus throw, there are scouts or whatever from various college teams all holding a scholar ship. There is a trans girl competing and out throws every one by 20 yards. because as much as we think that hormone treatments will reduce the competitive disadvantage threes nothing enforcing it.
