CP Mafia 4 - The Unknown Host - Game Over!

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

If this is correct then we better figure out who the hell we are lynching soon. I know we now have an extra day but if we don't get a lynch again we are truly screwed, that can't happen.

Honest question: Do people think it's better or worse for the town when we have this many candidates? If anybody voting for PE (including myself) moved their vote to Oling, we'd have 6 people with two votes each. Does this not make it tough for the hosts to control or encourage the action away from themselves if they start becoming in danger? Obviously we want to come to a decision where someone is lynched, but I think we are in a much better position with multiple candidates than we were with half of us on each side of two candidates (mrk and starseed). I feel reasons have to be stronger now, then if you are just the 6th person on or are voting so there isn't a tie.

[Hockeyguy15]

It's ridiculous how mrkajz has escaped 2 lynches in a row and now isn't really in play anymore.

If we lynch him and he flips town we have a lot to go on because he has been in play for a while now, and his theories of votes moving onto him could have some merit. If he flips host we have 2 lynches of votes moving off of him to look at, so making connections to him would probably be easier.

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Honest question: Do people think it's better or worse for the town when we have this many candidates? If anybody voting for PE (including myself) moved their vote to Oling, we'd have 6 people with two votes each. Does this not make it tough for the hosts to control or encourage the action away from themselves if they start becoming in danger? Obviously we want to come to a decision where someone is lynched, but I think we are in a much better position with multiple candidates than we were with half of us on each side of two candidates (mrk and starseed). I feel reasons have to be stronger now, then if you are just the 6th person on or are voting so there isn't a tie.

I think it's better for the town, as long as we decide before deadline. The more voting momentum bandwagons that get started the more chances we have to see how people have voted and draw conclusions.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

It's ridiculous how mrkajz has escaped 2 lynches in a row and now isn't really in play anymore.

If we lynch him and he flips town we have a lot to go on because he has been in play for a while now, and his theories of votes moving onto him could have some merit. If he flips host we have 2 lynches of votes moving off of him to look at, so making connections to him would probably be easier.

That makes sense and I can be on board with that.

Unvote
Vote:mrkajz44

[mrkajz44]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

It's ridiculous how mrkajz has escaped 2 lynches in a row and now isn't really in play anymore.

If we lynch him and he flips town we have a lot to go on because he has been in play for a while now, and his theories of votes moving onto him could have some merit. If he flips host we have 2 lynches of votes moving off of him to look at, so making connections to him would probably be easier.

Interesting how you wait until the heat is off Starseed to make this comment. I don't really think "escaping 2 lynches" is accurate either. I did narrowly miss getting lynched on day 4, but there were 3 people where the votes bounced around on day 3 - I'd hardly call that "escaping" when HG, ECF, and I were all people with votes on them through-out the day.

This type of post is exactly why I think you have a specific agenda - Starseed just avoided a lynch himself yesterday (and arguably today too with one vote from hammer!), yet you claim I'm the one escaping lynches. No focus on Starseed at all.

[Hockeyguy15]

I don't care about starseed, his position in votes against has nothing to do with me thinking that you are a host.

My agenda is to try and lynch hosts and in my eyes you are my biggest suspect, so yes my post does have an agenda and it's to lynch you.

[Hockeyguy15]

Also mrkajz do you know what is really interesting/funny right now? My top 4 (in no specific order) are you, Diss, Devo, and PE and all of them currently have a vote on you.

[Hockeyguy15]

I liked it better when the deadline was today and people were actually posting.

[squiggs96]

It takes 8 votes to hammer, 5 to deadline lynch

Hasn't Voted (1): Timbo

mrkajz44 (4): Hockeyguy15, Party Elephant, devo22, dissentowner
Party Elephant (3): bizaro86, GGG, squiggs96
devo22 (2): Oling_Roachinen, starseed
squiggs96 (2): SebC, Puxlut
starseed (1): mrkajz44

I'm not sure how much people are going to be around on the weekend, as they are usually pretty quiet in this thread. It's also tougher to get everyone to ignore their families on a Saturday night to ensure a vote goes through. I'd rather wrap this up sooner than later.

[Hockeyguy15]

Puxlut who did you think was mirroring you?

[GGG]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Honest question: Do people think it's better or worse for the town when we have this many candidates? If anybody voting for PE (including myself) moved their vote to Oling, we'd have 6 people with two votes each. Does this not make it tough for the hosts to control or encourage the action away from themselves if they start becoming in danger? Obviously we want to come to a decision where someone is lynched, but I think we are in a much better position with multiple candidates than we were with half of us on each side of two candidates (mrk and starseed). I feel reasons have to be stronger now, then if you are just the 6th person on or are voting so there isn't a tie.

So people believe that host oling did the following

Day 0 spore passed and successful turn (not oling)
Night 1 pass to girly by turned
Day 2 oling claims to pass the spore to girly when it was really the turned occupying the investigation for the night
Night 2 spore goes back to captain
Night 3 pass from captain to other host as can't risk a player not getting turned as oling would die
Night 4 pass to a townie unknown if turned yet.

Max 2 turned for sure 1 turned. This is the same scenario as the oling is town scenario.

Essentially scum gives up one spore pass to try to embed one of their guys in the town. I'd consider lynching oling when I think we think we are at lynch or lose and not before.

If he were scum I don't think he'd be as concerned about not being investigated. Let the investigation happen and he maintains town cred.

[GGG]

For those not voting Party Elephant what makes you think he is town

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by GGG

For those not voting Party Elephant what makes you think he is town

I'm leaning to host, but I don't think PE would be the one making the plans in the host thread. I also think it's more likely Mrkajz is a host, so that's why my vote is on him.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I'm leaning to host, but I don't think PE would be the one making the plans in the host thread. I also think it's more likely Mrkajz is a host, so that's why my vote is on him.

You think on the day 1 vote that 2 of 5 votes on girly were done buy hosts?

[Timbo]

Vote mrkajz44
Nice to see the deadline extended I guess
Back from shooting and we decided to go fishing, it was an awesome day.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by GGG

You think on the day 1 vote that 2 of 5 votes on girly were done buy hosts?

Quite possibly, if you look at day 1 and day 2 the only person who voted girly still was Lego and Seb who did the quick vote/unvote.

Sorry guys. Just spent 7 hours driving back and forth to Edmonton today just to get presented with a pretty little certificate. Waste of a day, but at least I got to represent City of Calgary.

As for the "mirror" with out looking (so take with a grain of salt, I'll look back and double check) I want to say GGG, diss and mrkookoo.

I didn't just switch my vote because I'm defensive. You've done some weird things in the past couple of days. I just wanted to see if anyone agreed with me.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

You've done some weird things in the past couple of days. I just wanted to see if anyone agreed with me.

I agree you are weird.

Add Timbo to the "mirror" list.

[GGG]

Is there anyone who hasn't tried to get a person lynched? I mean being the driving force behind votes or really working cases. The thought being scum wants to blend in and be a reasonable townie.

Going from memory
I don't think peanut has
Starseed hasn't
Devo hasn't
Seb hasn't
Pux Hasn't
Timbo has seemed quiet but have to reread



Party went after HG
HG went after girly
Olings gone after Squiggs but that isn't indicitive for him.
I went after Party

Have to go back and read Diss, Bizaro, squiggs, mrkajz