CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[Drury18]

Diss being un-lychable adds up to why he told me not to use my power on him. It didn't make sense at the time why he told me not to save him, but he did say he had a Guardian power that would help the town.

I don't think Diss is lying about what he got.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Drury18

Diss being un-lychable adds up to why he told me not to use my power on him. It didn't make sense at the time why he told me not to save him, but he did say he had a Guardian power that would help the town.

I don't think Diss is lying about what he got.

But that would also hold true if he had the Governor and ended up using it.

[Timbo]

I offered your left nut to the powers for a kill but it seemed they were not interested.
What's the matter with your left nut?

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Timbo

I offered your left nut to the powers for a kill but it seemed they were not interested.
What's the matter with your left nut?

Uni-ball?

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

What was your guardian power you had before me?

You were offered something, not sure if it was disclosed and you let it expire.

I was offered a kill, I let it expire.

Rathji was offered a kill from Eternals.

Then Rathji was offered a kill from Guardians and accepted.

I did say I was offered a kill at the time, I believe, but I realize that still makes it my word vs Diss.

First invite from Guardians was a Watcher ability.

Second invite from the Guardians was them "saving" me from the Eternals curse. No power was offered.

Eternals offered me a Ninja kill.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Uni-ball?

A double Yolker ....ewww

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

But that would also hold true if he had the Governor and ended up using it.

It would have to be one that specifically states self use. The third invite from the guardians never specified if it was self use.

My game Governor power is not self use.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

If I unvote Diss I am dead.

Other than Girly and Aeneas trying to so obviously have him lynched why do you guys think he is town?

So no one has anything to add to this?

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Drury18

It would have to be one that specifically states self use. The third invite from the guardians never specified if it was self use.

My game Governor power is not self use.

http://forum.calgarypuck.com/showpos...postcount=2210

Here's my post about when I got the kill that eventually Rathji was offered next. My word might not hold much value to you, but this would be an incredibly elaborate set up at this point. So I do know that at least once the Guardians offered a power back-to-back.

As for the Governor, you knew it was not self-used based on your own ability. If you read the instructions of the invite, would Diss realize that?

It just makes a lot more sense that he was hear 1 minute after the deadline if he had to be hear to perform an action (not really sure when you submit it to Mazrim of it it's just a thread power) than if he was just unlynchable.


Also interesting that Hockeyguy15 and Dissentowner both received unlynchable. 1 said it was anti-town to take it and the other said it was pro-town to take it.

[Oling_Roachinen]

I like that I used hear twice instead of here. Hate no edit :P

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

So no one has anything to add to this?

Other than I stated earlier I will keep my mind open to lobbying from all sides. And continue to seek inconsistencies

[Timbo]

You know if Diss lived here we could all settle this by going out for beers
But I bet Drury and I would get stuck with the tab lol.

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by Timbo

You know if Diss lived here we could all settle this by going out for beers
But I bet Drury and I would get stuck with the tab lol.

Diss and Oling never show up. HG15 would pop in 2 minutes before bar close, chug the pitcher and then leave to go play hockey.

Timbo and Drury get screwed again. Timbo probably gets shot.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Drury18

Diss and Oling never show up. HG15 would pop in 2 minutes before bar close, chug the pitcher and then leave to go play hockey.

Timbo and Drury get screwed again. Timbo probably gets shot.

Depends what day we do it. Could be a chance that I'd make the reservations sit there by myself talking to myself and then right as the bar closes find out the people hiding behind the jukebox are out to kill me.

[Hockeyguy15]

Diss from what I can tell is only thought of as town because of Girly and Aeneas wanting to lynch him so openly, which is weird for 2 Mafia to be so transparent about wanting someone dead. Now he is apparently unlynchable and his plan on why he accepted it doesn't make much sense, but he says he just didn't undrstand how the power worked.

Not sure what I should do with my vote now, if I move it I'm dead.

[Drury18]

Well Timbo, which way you feeling more here?

Guy who is quiet and shows up at a really bad time or the guy who makes alot of noise but disappears after making a suggestion he thinks will get the votes to come off him?

I'm not sure Diss is worth the vote. If he's lynch-proof, we get nothing. No info, no flip, we go into the night losing probably either me or you and the living one has to wade through the crap that's been left.

[Timbo]

Damned if we do damned if we don't

[Drury18]

Only one thing is certain: Keep your bucket to yourself when night hits!

[Drury18]

If I'm going to be blunt, and why the hell not at this point, I'd rather take out Oling. He's either left us a path to follow (I think) or we cut his bull#### out to go into Day 11 and find his buddy.

I think he has the potential to be more harmful going into Day 11 then helpful. I mean look what he's posted this day with all these theories and flip flopping on whose town and scum. Just a ton of confusion. If he's mafia, he's going to play whichever one of us is living and badger the crap out of us until we do what he wants. We aren't going to hunt, we are going to wade through a ton of his posts and confusion and probably replay this mess again on Day 11.

With Diss and HG, it might be easier to wade through everything.

Plus, I still don't trust him. How many of our townies have gone down screaming his name?

[Timbo]

Ya I retired it to risky