CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

lol, these are your arguments! You told the town you would be back on by 9:30.

No, I said I would try.

Originally Posted by dissentowner

We have been over the puxlut thing so stop beating a dead horse there and there was zero benefit to myself to show up after the deadline, none! The good thing that came out of it is we absolutely 100% know you are scum now.

We have been over the Puxlut thing, doesn't make it any less true. You visit her the night she died. The first time someone tracks you and you're caught killing a townie..or sorry, giving extra votes to the townie.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Did you disclose this before today at anytime?

post #4843.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Ok, well given my absolutely crappy record with powers in this game I am just taking the follow along route and I will get off Rathji's back. Maybe do the opposite of what I suggest? lol. This game has thrown me for a loop. Anyhow I will listen to others and shut my mouth.

Unvote

How come you thought being lynchproof would make the other person be lynched? Didn't you remember what happened the 2 times GGG was lynched?

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

No, I said I would try.


We have been over the Puxlut thing, doesn't make it any less true. You visit her the night she died. The first time someone tracks you and you're caught killing a townie..or sorry, giving extra votes to the townie.

I thought you tracked me when I gave GGG the doctor?

[Oling_Roachinen]

I'll consider, and only consider, hammering hockeyguy15 only under the condition that if he shows up town under no circumstances can anyone not vote dissentowner tomorrow. I don't want to kill the 1 townie who isn't trying to kill me and you guys still kill me tomorrow to lose the game for town. That is if we don't just lose when I kill hockeyguy15.

If he's town, he's not saving me because we both are mafia. If he's mafia, well I realize how it looks but I'm still town and I'll have to do my best to prove it tomorrow.

I've been opposed to a tie since the beginning of the day when I said we needed to take powers. That's the only reason I would kill hockeyguy15 over dissentowner after catching him killing puxlut.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

How come you thought being lynchproof would make the other person be lynched? Didn't you remember what happened the 2 times GGG was lynched?

GGG was not tied with anyone. I knew I was not dying, I wanted to know if I could not be lynched but the other person could, would it be their lynch? It made sense to me.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

I thought you tracked me when I gave GGG the doctor?

No. I have never, not once, said this. Try and find any post at all that states this.

I tracked Starseed that night.

You said you used your doctor on GGG.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

post #4843.

Don't be obtuse, I knew you said it after confronted why you didn't use both powers.

Have you at any time said it before today, as in Day 10.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

No. I have never, not once, said this. Try and find any post at all that states this.

I tracked Starseed that night.

You said you used your doctor on GGG.

Ok, that is why I asked.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Don't be obtuse, I knew you said it after confronted why you didn't use both powers.

Have you at any time said it before today, as in Day 10.

No, why would I??

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

No, why would I??

Why wouldn't you either?

It's just convenient, again, that you caught doing only 1 action yesterday when it would have been smart to use both abilities. Of course you say you can only use 1 ability at a time after the fact.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Why wouldn't you either?

It's just convenient, again, that you caught doing only 1 action yesterday when it would have been smart to use both abilities. Of course you say you can only use 1 ability at a time after the fact.

Isn't that pretty inconvenient no matter what?? How would holding onto that power no matter what side I was on be beneficial going into the most crucial day Oling? Think about it.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Isn't that pretty inconvenient no matter what?? How would holding onto that power no matter what side I was on be beneficial going into the most crucial day Oling? Think about it.

I don't think you have that power. Period.

You revealed it when Girlysports revealed she was the princess, how did that work out?

You're the only who hasn't proved your ability and there never would have been a chance to. "Oh I target Puxlut the night she died, can't show that ability because of bad luck" (or lying about how investigator powers work in this case). Tomorrow when I track you killing Drury18/Timbo it will be "oh chucks, I target Drury18/Timbo with my power and now I can't prove they are unlynchable"

[Oling_Roachinen]

Drury18, you were offered the Governor power by the Guardians, right?

You declined and Diss got an invite. What are the odds the power was the same and not unlychable like he is now claiming?

What are the chances Diss was waiting there right at the hammer, it would explain why he was okay with sending his vote over to hockeyguy15 and almost 'hammering' himself. He was banking on the power working. If I show up and hammer hockeyguy15, he does the power and no one dies (assuming for some reason this power worked).

If I don't show up, and you guys don't get your votes in fast enough and he gets lynched, he shows up and does the power a and no one dies.

[Oling_Roachinen]

I just asked Mazrim for clarification on when the tie will result in a non-lynch and it is game day, not real life day. So we have until Tuesday.

[Hockeyguy15]

If I unvote Diss I am dead.

Other than Girly and Aeneas trying to so obviously have him lynched why do you guys think he is town?

[Timbo]

I am not so sure anymore.

[Timbo]

Olling/HG15/Diss/ you all have done things lately to cause me to lose trust.

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Drury18, you were offered the Governor power by the Guardians, right?

You declined and Diss got an invite. What are the odds the power was the same and not unlychable like he is now claiming?
.

Unlikely. Eternals were the ones who said if I didn't accept the offer, they would find someone who would. Guardians seem to offer new ones every time, neither of my invites were worded that if I didn't accept, they would offer the same power to the next one.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Drury18

Unlikely. Eternals were the ones who said if I didn't accept the offer, they would find someone who would. Guardians seem to offer new ones every time, neither of my invites were worded that if I didn't accept, they would offer the same power to the next one.

What was your guardian power you had before me?

You were offered something, not sure if it was disclosed and you let it expire.

I was offered a kill, I let it expire.

Rathji was offered a kill from Eternals.

Then Rathji was offered a kill from Guardians and accepted.

I did say I was offered a kill at the time, I believe, but I realize that still makes it my word vs Diss.