CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

It just seems weird for me, if you're town you win regardless if you survive or not so getting upset seems pointless. Not only that but you didn't even write your own post, you just altered someone else's speech and that is pretty much no help to the town as it isn't even your words.

If you're pika-chu is connected to keeping your power and you can't talk about it why did you say Drury was talking like a pirate for no reason?

To me it doesn't seem like a win if I'm not part of it. Yes, I understand that's basically the premise of the game, but do you think RatherDashing cares whether the town or scum wins at this point? Pika doesn't think the reward for killing a scum should be that he is the next lynch. I think using the power I got, in the way I did, should let me continue to keep playing. Of course this is selfish, but I'd like to finish the scum off. Chu isn't the type that's fine being on the sidelines. I'd like to be part of the team that defeats the scum.

Many people here have said the eternal powers are useless. I questioned that if people thought they were useless, then why would Drury be scared to talk in his regular voice? Pika was questioning why someone be would scared of something that was harmless. Also, what Drury is doing with pirate talk is only applicable because of the eternals. That has nothing to do with my night action that I've been given since the game started that was my chu power.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

This is the post I was talking about, as someone who can't talk about the way you post being connected to your power it's weird you would call out Drury for his reason for speaking pirate.

As stated in my previous post, these are completely different things for pika nd Drury.

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

To me it doesn't seem like a win if I'm not part of it. Yes, I understand that's basically the premise of the game, but do you think RatherDashing cares whether the town or scum wins at this point?

Thar be a scurvy dog remark if I 'er heard one.

'tis a crew game, nah a one scallywag army.

Except in yer case, I reckon ye might be a one scallywag army. 'n th' way ye seem t' be baitin' me, I reckon ye might be leadin' th' Eternals.

Originally Posted by Squiggs96

Many people here have said the eternal powers are useless. I questioned that if people thought they were useless, then why would Drury be scared to talk in his regular voice? Pika was questioning why someone be would scared of something that was harmless. Also, what Drury is doing with pirate talk is only applicable because of the eternals. That has nothing to do with my night action that I've been given since the game started that was my chu power.

I fear naught. I hide naught. I gain naught. I play fer th' crew o' town, nah me owns self preservation. If I die afore th' end, I shall die helpin' th' town scuttle every last scurvy dog out thar.

I got an invite from th' Eternals aft I became a pirate. I saw wha' they said, I know how th' powers work now. I also know they be scurvy dog powers. They be only t' scuttle 'n scuttle by surprise. 'tis nah town beneficial.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

To me it doesn't seem like a win if I'm not part of it. Yes, I understand that's basically the premise of the game, but do you think RatherDashing cares whether the town or scum wins at this point? Pika doesn't think the reward for killing a scum should be that he is the next lynch. I think using the power I got, in the way I did, should let me continue to keep playing. Of course this is selfish, but I'd like to finish the scum off. Chu isn't the type that's fine being on the sidelines. I'd like to be part of the team that defeats the scum.

As much as I think a reveal of one of puxlut/starseed is the better option as we can either confirm another town or practically win the game if they are scum, this post almost makes me want to change my vote. I suspect squiggs is town but damn do I hate non team players!

[dissentowner]

So the only feedback I had was negative toward accepting the Guardian offer so I rejected it.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by starseed

If it is Squiggs/Dissent, then we have one miss available. If it is is Pux and I, then same thing. If it is Timbo/Oling/HG, then we have no room for error. I am thinking about a switch to Timbo.

There were 5 mafia in the first game. Can you guy explain why there is no possibility of 5 mafia again? I did not understand what you guys were saying.

If there were 5 they would have won the game in the 6 hrs we were one vote away from lynching diss, or switched in unison when we had one vote on a variety of people of which at least one was scum.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

I have a really good idea who wrote the invite I received, and I'm almost positive it was sent specifically to make me look terrible in front of everyone. Pika would have done the same if I was that guy, but the one thing he didn't consider, was that I would actually make a good use of it. That's why I think I haven't been contacted by them since. Again, I could be wrong, and I might only get one message. Pika tried bargaining with them and was told no.

Who do you believe sent you the power. Why not just tell us what you think instead of having all these ideas that you keep inside your head.

You are also playing a selfish anti town game lying about things. You answer questions with a lot of ambiguity.

Pika's day kill proves they do.

Note you still don't say I used my power given to me by the eternals to kill girly. All you say is pikas day kill proves they work. This is from someone who has used precise English as a reason that you couldn't have written the game day messages.

Pika also likes the element of surprise.

Girly also had this idea that surprising the mafia was how to win.
You lied about dire consequences.
You continue to be evasive and not share what you know or believe with the town.

I am back voting for Squiggs as number 1.

[starseed]

OK, if it were 5, Squiggs would have been hammered. So I will also be moving back to Squiggs.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by starseed

OK, if it were 5, Squiggs would have been hammered. So I will also be moving back to Squiggs.

Squiggs or Diss.

Aeneas and girly were pushing pux and r athji to lynch diss so diss is likely town and if town and 5 scum

Squiggs also sat near lynch for a while. Not sure that implicates squiggs as scum as if there are only 4 scum scum couldn't have quick lynched safely.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by GGG

Squiggs or Diss.

Aeneas and girly were pushing pux and r athji to lynch diss so diss is likely town and if town and 5 scum

Squiggs also sat near lynch for a while. Not sure that implicates squiggs as scum as if there are only 4 scum scum couldn't have quick lynched safely.

I think Girly was trying to set up Pux and Rathji with that comment. She was trying to plant the seed by saying that they were hesitating to vote for Dissent. When Dissent flipped scum, she could point the town to those two.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by GirlySports

It wasn't manipulation, I was just asking why if you and Pux were certain that Diss was mafia why you were afraid to hammer. Pux makes sense now, she was indecisive and now her vote has gone to Oling. You on the other hand waited til the vote went down to 4 so it was safe. So you voted for him finally. And now you've unvoted again.

You're protecting diss, trying not to associate with him. I think everyone can see this.

Even now Diss is suddenly ok with rathji. That whole argument was a charade.

Also, she tried again to link Rathji to Dissent. I think Dissent was complicit when he stated that he was backing off Rathji... part of a plan to link their fates.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by GirlySports

If they said you were townie and that was their reason for not voting for you that's fine. I wouldn't have mentioned it. But they are waffling. GGG already voted for you and withdrew. Rathji went on a rampage and called you everything but won't vote. Puxlut says she will hammer if we say so.. why does she need permission. She's not a supporting actress, she's equal to everyone else.

They all think you're mafia but won't pull the trigger, it makes them more suspicious.

I think you're mafia so my vote is there. You think Starseed is mafia so your vote is there. I haven't been right all game either, none of us have. You are no longer in lynch position, let's see where everyone stands.

And she would use this one to later state that she was suspicious of Dissent the whole time.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by starseed

I think Girly was trying to set up Pux and Rathji with that comment. She was trying to plant the seed by saying that they were hesitating to vote for Dissent. When Dissent flipped scum, she could point the town to those two.

I think she was trying to get anyone to hammer at that time. They already had two (now) confirmed mafia on him, and there was already suspicion of Aeneas and Girly. If anyone had hammered, Pika wouldn't have had the opportunity to kill Girly, and thus both her and Aeneas would still be alive.

[GGG]

Squiggs

What instructions did you follow in order to make your power work when others have failed.

Also again you bring up that ecf and forms power didn't work because of something about me. I will reiterate i am just lynchproof.

So why did yours work while pux's didn't.

You implied tgat you followed some very specific instructions that others missed. What were they and how did you follow them.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by GGG

Oling, why did you track Rathji when you did vs Aeneas or Girlysports.

The exact same reason I didn't want a rewind at the time. I didn't trust Rathji.

Rathji didn't like East Coast Flame being labeled a confirmed townie earlier in the game. I was suspicious that he took an invite after Drury18 and myself rejected one. Especially since 1 invite expired and he got the next one with the same power. It's why I was so adamant that I thought Wood should be the one to pick his kill. I said as much at the time.

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

I think I'm leaning towards no rewind simply because I don't know if I trust him with another bullet. The side effects might not be worth it just to kill a townie.

If we do rewind, I would prefer that we already have a suspect lined up for Rathji to shoot his/her head off of as opposed to giving him "complete control."

With that said, I'll stay out of the decision on who to kill. I'll let a formulate lynch prove my story first.

So I tracked him that night. When he didn't visit anyone I became much less suspicious because my thinking was mafia, with their very likely multiple powers, would each be visiting someone at night time.

However, I couldn't come right out and say that at the time because I thought the cop was still hiding and I didn't want to tell the mafia that Rathji didn't track anyone (one less hiding spot for the cop) but I wanted to let the town know I didn't think he was mafia either.

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

By the way I tracked Rathji. Wont reveal anything, but have no reason to believe he is mafia at this point.

[dissentowner]

Look how bad starseed is trying to get a lynch on me because I have pointed out how bad the MOT lead us to town after town death. Why would I turn down that Guardian offer if I was scum? Why would I have protected GGG with my doctor? Better yet why are you so against one of you or Puxlut being lynched so we can confirm the other as town?

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

The exact same reason I didn't want a rewind at the time. I didn't trust Rathji.

Rathji didn't like East Coast Flame being labeled a confirmed townie earlier in the game. I was suspicious that he took an invite after Drury18 and myself rejected one. Especially since 1 invite expired and he got the next one with the same power. It's why I was so adamant that I thought Wood should be the one to pick his kill. I said as much at the time.

Why rathji over girly and Aeneas. To be tracking r athji is much like going after the cop than going after scum. After the form day the cop was pretty much Rathji and Mr Kacjz

[Aeneas]

------DEATH POST------

Almost forgot my death post! I had not planned anything specific since bloodless victory was the goal. Thought to stick with good old Shakespeare, a little "once more into the breach dear mafia" or "tis not as wide as a church door nor as deep as a well, but tis enough will serve." but I decided I would just let you in on one of my last conversations with Girly fore the fall...

Girly: Aeneas wake up! they're going to lynch you
Aeneas: Nonsense, all is well
Girly: You will be dead, what are you going to do?
Aeneas: Hmm, become a monk I suppose devote the rest of my time to good works and prayer
Girly: Aeneas! They are going to lynch you today! What will you do today?
Aeneas: Ah! Today I will get drunk and go whoring

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by GGG

Why rathji over girly and Aeneas. To be tracking r athji is much like going after the cop than going after scum. After the form day the cop was pretty much Rathji and Mr Kacjz

I understand what you're saying, but I can only speak to why I investigated Rathji which is because he was on the top of my mafia list. The list was narrowing down at the time of people undeclared and unconfirmed, so while I didn't get a mafia on Rathji I was able to remove him from my potential list before his power was revealed if people trusted me.

Opposite to your insinuation is that I checked Squiggs96, a declared person, the next chance I got despite there still being Dissentowner, Girylsports and Aeneas around.

The logic was simple, if he had target Drury18, Rathji, you, Starseed, Hockeyguy15 or possibly even Timbo we could know instantly if he was mafia. Puxlut was a bit of a wildcard, her natural power was useless but the Eternal power made some sense to use the power on (except that Squiggs96 had already said we confirmed Eternal powers to be fake which tilted my decision) before somehow he's able to prove them capable. The other three could have made an excuse why they target someone, and I wouldn't be certain.

Squiggs96 power, if truthful (which the mafia would know), wouldn't have been very useful to check when they still didn't know what Diss' power was or if Timbo had bucket one of them.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by GGG

Squiggs

What instructions did you follow in order to make your power work when others have failed.

Also again you bring up that ecf and forms power didn't work because of something about me. I will reiterate i am just lynchproof.

So why did yours work while pux's didn't.

You implied tgat you followed some very specific instructions that others missed. What were they and how did you follow them.

vote squiggs96

To many unanswered questions
Not a team player
Eternals powers don't work.

Everyone should get their vote on the board today as deadline is tomorrow.