CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Mafia isn't going to support each other everytime. Voting against each other is a good strategy.

Girlysports vote only happened after your plan of looking at the Guardians failed. And given her power, it makes sense the mafia were okay with killing her.

Still, you haven't revealed your night actions? Why not? Let us know who you target, and preferably the reasons why.

And do you or do you not have to post as pikachu?

Pika is wondering if you have a learning disability. This has all been discussed and revealed. Go read if you are actually interested. Pika still thinks we should look at guardians. That hasn't changed. If you manage to rally the troops and lynch me, then congrats to the mafia, as you've managed to convince the town to vote out another townie.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika is wondering if you have a learning disability. This has all been discussed and revealed. Go read if you are actually interested. Pika still thinks we should look at guardians. That hasn't changed. If you manage to rally the troops and lynch me, then congrats to the mafia, as you've managed to convince the town to vote out another townie.

No it hasn't. And no need for insults.

[Oling_Roachinen]

And if it has been answered, I don't see the problem wasting 30 seconds and reposting it.

What were your night actions, why, and do you have to post as pikachu?

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

No it hasn't. And no need for insults.

Yes it has. Since many people think Pika doesn't post ever, it shouldn't be hard to find. I'm not doing your work for you.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Yes it has. Since many people think Pika doesn't post ever, it shouldn't be hard to find. I'm not doing your work for you.

I will unvote for you if you just show me where.

What were your night actions and do you have to post as pikachu? Show me the post, I will unvote you. If you're town, the 10 seconds it takes to make the post this will give town a chance.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika is wondering if you have a learning disability. This has all been discussed and revealed. Go read if you are actually interested. Pika still thinks we should look at guardians. That hasn't changed. If you manage to rally the troops and lynch me, then congrats to the mafia, as you've managed to convince the town to vote out another townie.

Which guardian should we look at and why?

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by GGG

Which guardian should we look at and why?

I'd most likely look at starseed, being mot1, or Timbo for having multiple people wanting to lynch him. I know Drury saved Timbo, but pika wishes we could have seen this result.

[squiggs96]

For as many times as Puxlut has called me out for it, she has been in this thread a few times tonight and hasn't said anything. She hasn't said who she tried to arson. Pika thinks it could be himself, but wouldn't mind hearing the answer.

[squiggs96]

Pika's off to bed. Will pick up tomorrow.

Now that my beloved Peach is gone, I wouldn't mind having a peek at you...

Get it? Peek at you? Pikachu?
I've been watching the thread... just haven't really seen anything that pops out. One person says somethings that makes me think "Yah! That dude is totally guilty!" But then they come up with a reasonable retort. I have a couple of people that my gut says that there's something weird about them, but other than that... it's like watching a tennis match... back and forth.
I don't think SS has been around... we haven't chatted in a couple of days.
I'm not going to say who I tried to douse yet. But I will say; it wasn't Pika.

[Drury18]

Bowser, you scare the hell out of me.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Alright, my last post on the subject. I went through a bunch of Squiggs96 posts giving him the benefit of the doubt (as much I could) and I'm now more sure of my vote.

First, despite the claim that he has revealed all his actions, I don't think he said who he used his power on night 3:

Night 1 - Used on Drury18
Night 2 - Used on ECF
Night 3 - Used his doctor on Wood, as far as I saw never revealed who he used his power on
Night 4 - Used on me
Night 6 - Used on Puxlut

That can easily be refuted with a simple post showing he did.

There's a pretty damning post here with what we know now:

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika would be willing to switch my vote to hmmm if ECF was going to use her night kill on GP.

He'd be willing to switch his vote from one townie, our doctor, to another, if the first townie uses a power to kill another townie. And when that power doesn't work, he uses it as an excuse to try and have us lynch our doctor.

Originally Posted by squiggs96

What would be the point of accepting for power, as I thought the powers they offered didn't work. Mazrim stated the gifts of powers were a contrived deceit. This was confirmed by ECF, as Pika ensured his power would have gone through, unless someone can also block my power.

Here he acknowledges that the Eternal powers were confirmed by ECF to be fake. So I'm back to the question on why he visited Puxlut yesterday.

And then there's:

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika has quaralled with diss, multiple times. I'm not sure we like each other. I led the charge on Girly and only stopped when her reveal came out. Pika even asked if it was a contrived deceit. Diss has voted for me multiple times, and has tried leading it as well. He's got his vote on me as we speak. You can leave it

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika unvoted just in case, but here's a wild theory. Is the Girly/diss back and forth a contrived deceit to take heat off of both of them? It's worked, and it's a really power play. If Pika doesn't believe them and is wrong, then we could lose a day, meaning we lose three townies (Girly lynch, two consecutive night kills). That's a huge risk I don't think I'm willing to call in order to see if she (they) are bluffing. If we don't believe them and are right, there are two mafia members exposed.

Seriously, who uses the phrase contrived deceit? Oh yeah:

Originally Posted by Mazrim

Hello Townsfolk! The gift of Eternal powers are a contrived deceit.

[starseed]

Wow. That is a lot to catch up on.

Unless I missed it, the night protections of me and Pux are still not claimed by anyone? And the extra vote on Timbo is still unexplained?

I think my vote is going to be based on the fact that Pika visited the people who received an extra vote the next day, and that Pika didn't save the doctor when he had the chance.

Vote: squiggs96

[GGG]

Just did a search for contrived deceit. Squiggs is the only person who used that phrase outside of Maz. Everyone else just quoted the whole line. Squiggs is also the only person who has given blanket credibility to those statements. He uses the phrase Mazrim stated for the Eternals powers as posted above and the following for the guardian powers

Pika sees the new note that says there is scum among the guardians, meaning one of the following is scum:
starseed
Rathji
Timbo
GGG

I am sold on lynching Squiggs.


I wouldn't take Squiggs post on wanting the doctor dead if GP Matt was killed as too strong of indicator as I think I took the same position that day.

[Rathji]

Unvote
Vote squiggs96

I have been convinced for a couple days that the messages are coming from mafia. With the pushing the same agenda as squiggs and the same language, that's enough for me to switch from Diss.

Still pretty convinced that diss is mafia though. Right now, my list is:

Squiggs96
Dissentowner
Girlysports
Aeneas
Timbo

Don't believe GS claim as it sets off off a lot more red flags as someone who is just trying to make us pause at lynching her when the numbers are close.

Aeneas posting style seems normal for him. This was an issue for him the last mafia game as well, and I am pretty sure he turned out town (not going to try and find it on my phone.)

Not really sold on Timbo, as the hider power is normally town, but he hasn't played it like town would to maximize it's utility. It's a hard role to play though, so I find it hard to blame him.

[GirlySports]

How many votes is that?

[GGG]

I have oling, GGG, diss, Starseed, Rathji for 5 votes.

But check to see if I missed any because 7 is hammer.

[Hockeyguy15]

I find it interesting that Diss was pretty quick to drop his crusade on Rathji and jump on the squiggs vote.

If he was so sure Rathji was scum wouldn't he take more convincing to switch? I'm wondering if he is scum and was going after Rathji knowing no one would vote for him at this point. He goes after Rathji to keep the heat off his buddies, then when the lynch swings away from them he jumps on the vote early, to help pick up momentum.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by GGG

I have oling, GGG, diss, Starseed, Rathji for 5 votes.

But check to see if I missed any because 7 is hammer.

I also get 5.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I find it interesting that Diss was pretty quick to drop his crusade on Rathji and jump on the squiggs vote.

If he was so sure Rathji was scum wouldn't he take more convincing to switch? I'm wondering if he is scum and was going after Rathji knowing no one would vote for him at this point. He goes after Rathji to keep the heat off his buddies, then when the lynch swings away from them he jumps on the vote early, to help pick up momentum.

No, I went off of Rathji because Squiggs seemed the better bet and nobody seemed to agree with me that he sounds scummy at times or that his power does not clear him as town so I dropped it for now. You were the one earlier who said you can't see anyway Rathji is not town and now from the way I read it you think him and I are scum buddies? That us pretty farfetched and laughable.