CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win! - Page 153 - Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community

Oling_Roachinen · 10-17-2014, 04:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wood

I think we kill either Aeneas or Girly.

Sounds good to me, I would prefer you made the choice though. Timbo knows cop and can stop Rathji if needed. Leaving some ambiguity for Rathji to chose between the two might not be the best decision if he does end up mafia.

mrkajz44 · 10-17-2014, 04:33 PM

Vote: Formulate

I can't get a read on squiggs because of the low level of posting. I'd lean more on Aeneas or Girly, but probably Aeneas if I had to make a top pick.

Wood · 10-17-2014, 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Timbo

The most under the radar player IMO is Aeneas
Does not seem to hunts never starts a theory against another player and is always available to vote with little or no reason.

Timbo did say this, so I figure Aeneas is not the cop. It's a coin flip in my mind really, we're down to a short list of suspects and no one stands out too much

GGG · 10-17-2014, 04:42 PM

Did anything bad happen?

Wood · 10-17-2014, 04:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aeneas

Lastly, as I hate the really long posts and tend to skim alot. (to my disadvantage I am sure)

Which one of you messed with me last night?

Someone played some power on me, however it wasn't bad at all. In fact the longer I have thought about it, the more likely I believe it is that a townsperon must have done it. Not mafia. It was something fairly benign and helpful to me, informatin wise. I did not ask for it, was not able to direct it per se, but I got the info.

So, if the author of this action would post telling me it was them, and could with a few short words or even one word tell me what they did...then I would have, in my own mind, a confirmed townie.

Just hoping someone can prove to me they did it. Then I might trust you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aeneas

To be clear I have my own power, and I used it last night. As far as I know it worked. Nothing powerful, I am poor little villager after all. Whatever that is.

If everyone goes all crazy with reveals, I am willing to let everyone know what I have learned. It is not much, I think I must have showed up late when Mazrim was handing out powers.

This was something extra.

What was it that happened to you Aeneas? Also what did you learn from your power? Anything to help or prove you're town?

GirlySports · 10-17-2014, 04:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mrkajz44

Vote: Formulate

I can't get a read on squiggs because of the low level of posting. I'd lean more on Aeneas or Girly, but probably Aeneas if I had to make a top pick.

Low level of posting should be a read in itself. I don't know if I get a say or not but I'd chose squiggs.

Low level of posting (due to holidays and work, ok i'll buy that)
Ensuring spells go through but they failed
One-shot doctor protected Wood instead of the real doctor (ECF died)
- that's a very questionable read for a townie.

dissentowner · 10-17-2014, 04:51 PM

Just FYI I am on duty until midnight and have no idea how to bold using tapatalk so I can't vote until then. Midnight here means 10pm there.

Wood · 10-17-2014, 04:52 PM

Dissentowner who would be your main targets for rathjis one shot?

dissentowner · 10-17-2014, 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wood

Dissentowner who would be your main targets for rathjis one shot?

I am not sure. I have been suspicious of squiggs since day 1 but not sure after the Matt fiasco I get the best reads this game. This game has been way harder then the other two I played. Him or girlysports. I was thinking starseed and Puxlut used MOT to kill the town but now I am in doubt of that too. I honestly don't know

Wood · 10-17-2014, 05:01 PM

I feel the same way this game, I've been wrong on everything other than formulate finally

I'm just waiting for Aeneas to reply

GGG · 10-17-2014, 05:06 PM

Timbo can you explain without revealing who it is how your magic bucket power allowed you to know who the cop is?

Say you magic bucketed me, I got investigated, doesn't the cop just get an extra report on you? Or do you see who fills your bucket?

GGG · 10-17-2014, 05:12 PM

If we kill Aeneas or girly we lose one more hiding spot for the cop. If Aneas discloses his ability we lose one more spot for the cop.

Based on this I think Squiggs is a good target. He flips town one of Timbo or Oling is likely scum. And it puts suspicion on Diss. He flips mafia it lends credibility to Timbo, drury, oling and diss. That is more than we get out of a girly flip or a Aeneas flip.

Aeneas · 10-17-2014, 05:24 PM

Man, go to play street hockey for a couple hours with the kids and suddenly I am in trouble.

Well, I have been called out many times for low post count. Not much I can do about that.

Starseed it took me forever to read the main thread, it was 89 pages or so when I joined.

I could disclose some info I have gained during the night. But what is the point, I either paint a big target on me for night kill, or I die here by Rathji gunfire.

I will spill if you think thats best.

Wood · 10-17-2014, 05:24 PM

There's only so many suspects at this point

Possible suspect mrkajzs target list in order is Dissentowner, Aeneas, squiggs, Girly
Possible suspect Girly would prefer to kill squiggs
Possible suspect Dissentowner thinks Squiggs or Girly
Possible suspect squiggs has only really gone after Dissentowner
Aeneas hasn't targeted anyone other than GGG as far as I know

I'm choosing Squiggs as the target to use the one shot on. Doesn't reveal any new abilities, if he's mafia it makes Diss look good. Of the possible suspects left, there's at least a few mafia in there. Who they mentioned they'd like to target could be revealing

Aeneas · 10-17-2014, 05:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wood

There's only so many suspects at this point

Possible suspect mrkajzs target list in order is Dissentowner, Aeneas, squiggs, Girly
Possible suspect Girly would prefer to kill squiggs
Possible suspect Dissentowner thinks Squiggs or Girly
Possible suspect squiggs has only really gone after Dissentowner
Aeneas hasn't targeted anyone other than GGG as far as I know

I'm choosing Squiggs as the target to use the one shot on. Doesn't reveal any new abilities, if he's mafia it makes Diss look good. Of the possible suspects left, there's at least a few mafia in there. Who they mentioned they'd like to target could be revealing

I have suspected, in order (maybe, dont have noted)... GGG, Starseed, Timbo, Oling, and darn, have to look it up.

Aeneas · 10-17-2014, 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aeneas

I have suspected, in order (maybe, dont have noted)... GGG, Starseed, Timbo, Oling, and darn, have to look it up.

Notes, not noted.

GGG · 10-17-2014, 05:35 PM

Before rathji kills squiggs i would like to here his full power description as well as who he targeted each night.

Hockeyguy15 · 10-17-2014, 05:45 PM

So nothing bad happened?

Vote: formulate

Hockeyguy15 · 10-17-2014, 05:50 PM

So we have decided on squiggs then? I am fine with that, I still don't know why he would "protect" wood and not ECF.

squiggs96 · 10-17-2014, 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wood

Reverse the day, use the kill on any of girly, Aeneas or squiggs I think, and then we Lynch formulate

If Oling is right about formulate this should work

That's cold. I use my one shot doctor item on you, and before a thank you is let out, you are already in favour of voting me out. Pika wishes he had used it on ECF, both in terms of what was revealed by ECF's flip, and this turn of events.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wood

I think its a good idea to rewind. I'd use the one shot on either squiggs, girly or Aeneas

There are other posts just like this from you. You really don't want me around. This makes Pika sad.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GGG

Did anything bad happen?

Yes! The villagers are ganging up on Pika.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GirlySports

Low level of posting should be a read in itself. I don't know if I get a say or not but I'd chose squiggs.

Low level of posting (due to holidays and work, ok i'll buy that)
Ensuring spells go through but they failed
One-shot doctor protected Wood instead of the real doctor (ECF died)
- that's a very questionable read for a townie.

Of course you choose Pika, but I don't blame you since your name is also on the block. It's not my fault the spell went through, as I performed my action as I was instructed to. Hindsight is 20/20, but how many people were 100% sure ECF was the doctor? As stated, Pika wishes he had saved ECF. This would mean the doctor was still alive, no one would have died at night meaning my power could be confirmed, and my status as a townie would be basically 100% guaranteed to all. I'd likely die during the night, but I'd take that over being lynched/day killed by my own townies.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GGG

If we kill Aeneas or girly we lose one more hiding spot for the cop. If Aneas discloses his ability we lose one more spot for the cop.

Based on this I think Squiggs is a good target. He flips town one of Timbo or Oling is likely scum. And it puts suspicion on Diss. He flips mafia it lends credibility to Timbo, drury, oling and diss. That is more than we get out of a girly flip or a Aeneas flip.

Pika doesn't mind the first part of your analysis, as I can buy that. Since I know I'm town, when I flip it, one of Timbo or Oling is likely scum per your analysis. Why not use the kill on one of them? I'd pick Oling out of that, since Drury used the intervention to save Timbo.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

So we have decided on squiggs then? I am fine with that, I still don't know why he would "protect" wood and not ECF.

Pika's explained this multiple times. Since people keep pointing out I don't post a lot, it should be too hard to find. I wanted to keep as many townies as possible, and there wasn't anyone here who was 100% ECF was town, never mind 100% the doctor.

To me the thing that can hint to me being town, is no one is protecting Pika right now.