CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Drury18

My power was day to but only after a hammer or deadline.

The day doesn't technically end until we go into night. We have twilight which is in between.

I'd get Mazrim to clarify for you if you can use it in twilight.

Drury did you ask if you could use your power in twilight

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

Nope.

That's why I'm so confused. With all the redirects/bounce backs it's hard to see and keep track or make sense of everything. What's the point of everyone having a power if it's just going to get screwed with?

As a town in a few days we all disclose all of our abilities and night actions. This forces the mafia to try to reveal their roles and actions without slipping up.

I prefer last games open set up where we knew everything up front.

[mrkajz44]

Originally Posted by GGG

You were the second person on Starseed, switch off to be the second vote on Timbo.

Your above reasoning for the switch is just parroting what others had already said in the thread.

Originally Posted by Timbo

Ya in one of my mega posts I called him a heel nipper.

One of those mutts that don't do anything until the big dog attacks.
(nothing personal)

Yes - I was the second person on each - I posed the lists with full transparency, knowing full well where I sat on both. I don't disagree that I was not the first to think that Timbo's posting change was odd, but to me votes speak a lot louder than anything else. I was one of the first to show my trust in starseed and true suspicion on Timbo by moving my vote.

Starseed was one vote away from hammer as I recall when I decided to move my vote to Timbo. I'm not sure how that makes me the follower. When it's 9 or 10 votes to hammer, the followers are votes 4-8, but that's my view.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

So is anyone opposed to Rathji using his kill on formulate, if he agrees, when he gets back?

Formulate's good with me.

We don't need hg here to do the kill as long as we don't lynch anyone until he can use the power.

Also eternals inviter can you hand out your day kill for today?

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by GGG

Drury did you ask if you could use your power in twilight

No. My instructions stated it must be done after the hammer is dropped or a deadline is reached.

The reason I asked HG15 is because he was saying "day" which made me think there might be wriggle room on it. If he didn't have clear instructions on its use, perhaps it had a little more flexibility.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by mrkajz44

Yes - I was the second person on each - I posed the lists with full transparency, knowing full well where I sat on both. I don't disagree that I was not the first to think that Timbo's posting change was odd, but to me votes speak a lot louder than anything else. I was one of the first to show my trust in starseed and true suspicion on Timbo by moving my vote.

Starseed was one vote away from hammer as I recall when I decided to move my vote to Timbo. I'm not sure how that makes me the follower. When it's 9 or 10 votes to hammer, the followers are votes 4-8, but that's my view.

Day 1 you did the same thing 2nd on Bizaro, train got full, you switched off to be the second person on Squiggs.

[GGG]

Also drury and I posted those lists you repeated the list which it seems most of your posts do. Parrot others thoughts and vote where it won't be suspicious.

[mrkajz44]

Well, take it as you see it, I'm just trying to provide more information for the town to use on voting patterns. Again, not sure how voting second often makes me a follower when a lot of players here have not been first or second on a large vote.

As for formulate, we should wait for Rathji to weigh in and hear his thoughts and maybe have a quick discussion after that. It is his kill after all and he has a lot of catching up to do.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by GGG

Formulate's good with me.

We don't need hg here to do the kill as long as we don't lynch anyone until he can use the power.

Also eternals inviter can you hand out your day kill for today?

GGG, you didn't die despite Squiggs96's boost and a confirmed town (our doctor) using his poison on you.

There's only 3 options:
1) Eternal Powers don't work as intended.
2) Squiggs96 lied about his power.
3) You can't be nightkilled.

If it's 1, I think that's a good reason to just stay away from Eternal invites, less confusion, less distractions. If it's 2, I guess we found another mafia member, but if it's 3 I don't see any other option but to lynch you.

So what's your thinking on accepting Eternal invites?

[Oling_Roachinen]

Also since we are back on the cults, can anyone confirm that the invites overlapped?

At first we thought it was day for Eternals, night for Guardians, then later we thought Eternals ended when me and Drury18 were hanging onto our invites. Rathji gets an Eternal invite, it expires and he gets a Guardian one (with the same power) very nearly after.

We might be able to come up with a timeline that refutes this but to me it seems like these invites come from the same person.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

GGG, you didn't die despite Squiggs96's boost and a confirmed town (our doctor) using his poison on you.

There's only 3 options:
1) Eternal Powers don't work as intended.
2) Squiggs96 lied about his power.
3) You can't be nightkilled.

If it's 1, I think that's a good reason to just stay away from Eternal invites, less confusion, less distractions. If it's 2, I guess we found another mafia member, but if it's 3 I don't see any other option but to lynch you.

So what's your thinking on accepting Eternal invites?

1) we have no verification on the eternal powers right now. With lots of abilities floating out there we don't know if the poison was stopped by a power or not so it would be good to test this. The best time to test this is when if it doesn't work we can undue it and reset the day. So if the eternals can invite someone right now and the powers work we learn something.

2) I have been thinking about this. Wood was protected by ECF, we only had one death that day, a double kill on a bodyguard usually allows the second kill through, star seeds power implies more than 1 faction, so that means a kill was stopped which means ECFs power likely got through. So the only explanation I can think of is the power not working

3) I can be night killed, I also can be day killed (confirmed this with Maz today), I cannot be lynched. If the town wants to test this I can be lynched but it costs us a day though gains us a townie. Not a bad plan once we get the sk.

I think we need to verify if eternal powers work, I think if the eternals offer a day kill someone should accept it and use it along with Rathji's today.

[dissentowner]

Well it is late here, going to bed, back to work tmrw but I will be on here as much as possible.

[Rathji]

Well, I dont know how my day will be tomorrow, and dont want to have any further delay.

Kill: formulate

[Rathji]

I thought of waiting for a discussion, but I had a thought that the guardian 'leader' if there was such a thing, might not want this plan to go ahead and end up offering formulate a position in the guardians.

So I verified that he had not accepted such an offer by checking the first post, and killed.

[Oling_Roachinen]

wont be here for all the good stuff probably.work sucks.

[Hockeyguy15]

And now we wait for Mazrim.

(insert Tom Petty here)

[GGG]

So ertenals inviter this is your chance to prove your powers work to gain recruits. Guardians to if you have another daytime power. Probably don't have much time now

[Hockeyguy15]

I think anyone who gets the invite should disclose it before they accept it. I am still weary of the cults, and we probably don't want too many people joining them.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I think anyone who gets the invite should disclose it before they accept it. I am still weary of the cults, and we probably don't want too many people joining them.

I am assuming that membership will be undone when you reset the day.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by GGG

I am assuming that membership will be undone when you reset the day.

I assume so to, I just mean on a go-forward basis.