CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[DropIt]

Well, assuming that Diss is actually the cop, which there isnt any reason he wouldnt be, that changes my target from Legoman... I was convinced he was mafia.

The other person I had on my radar was HD... He seemed to really get into it with Delgar before he was nightkilled. Got into it with Bizaro, Bizaro died.

[jayswin]

So basically if that's our strategy, we just go to town (lol) on this list and see what happens.

Saillias (Kermit)
Hockeyguy15
flameswin
HalifaxDrunk
undercoverbrother
CaptainCrunch
Completely
DropIt

If I had to pick three that have been suspicious, it would be..

completely
captain crunch, as I already mentioned

and then Halifax Drunk. Runs ins with two townies who were both night killed.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

But really though if we lynch the last Parker mafia don't waste an investigation on me, I would rather you investigate someone else and lynch me the next day.

If we're gonna lynch you the next day, we might as well investigate you... Make sure. If you turn up town, no reason to lynch you...

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

So, regarding the final Parker Scum... Does anyone think this has any traction?

My vote already is for saillias, too many red flags. Then again, the two guys I have night actioned that I thought were mafia were both town so what do I know?

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

So, regarding the final Parker Scum... Does anyone think this has any traction?

It's possible but I want to go back and look at day 1/2 and see if I can find anything else.

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

It's possible but I want to go back and look at day 1/2 and see if I can find anything else.

If you're doing the leg work, which you always seem to be down for lol. Let's really look hard at HalifaxDrunk and get everything out there.

When's the last time he even posted, anyways?

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by flameswin

So basically if that's our strategy, we just go to town (lol) on this list and see what happens.

Saillias (Kermit)
Hockeyguy15
flameswin
HalifaxDrunk
undercoverbrother
CaptainCrunch
Completely
DropIt

If I had to pick three that have been suspicious, it would be..

completely
captain crunch, as I already mentioned

and then Halifax Drunk. Runs ins with two townies who were both night killed.

I agree with all of this, I already said I think the Lego voters were mob. HD and CC for sure. Not as sure about completely.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

If we're gonna lynch you the next day, we might as well investigate you... Make sure. If you turn up town, no reason to lynch you...

I disagree because that's an extra night of not investigating mafia so it's a waste.

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by HalifaxDrunk

I didn't sway my vote from Lego Man and still feel strongest that he is Mafia (others are closing in on him though).

Time to lose the little plastic person.

Vote: Lego Man

I'll answer my own question. One post since May 16th, and this is it. Very interesting, considering what we now know (provided diss is telling the truth). Downright damning, actually.

Combine that with his two arguments with townies that resulted in their deaths and I think I've got my new CrazyBaconLegs!

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I disagree because that's an extra night of not investigating mafia so it's a waste.

I agree with HG15, I think we lynch one of CC, HD, or saillias and we pick another one to investigate. Maybe completely as well. Those are our best targets I feel.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I disagree because that's an extra night of not investigating mafia so it's a waste.

But then we'll lynch a townie? (you)???

[jayswin]

Holy crap diss, your post just reminded me of my first theory, quoted below. Maybe replace BR with completely and it was actually accurate???

Originally Posted by flameswin

So I guess my crazy theory in an easy to read chart would be like this

Scapegoat: Legoman

potential mafia group 1: HalifaxDrunk, captaincrunch, BaxterRenegade



Scapegoat: flameswin

potential mafia group 2: CrazyBaconLegs, Olingroachinen






Did I just figure the game out, or am I just wrong again in a relatively poorly played game on my part?

My second mfia group prediction turned out to be bunk, though.

Originally Posted by dissentowner

I agree with all of this, I already said I think the Lego voters were mob. HD and CC for sure. Not as sure about completely.

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

I agree with HG15, I think we lynch one of CC, HD, or saillias and we pick another one to investigate. Maybe completely as well. Those are our best targets I feel.

I'd say lynch HalifaxDrunk, investigate CaptainCrunch and we might be pretty close to winning this thing.

[dissentowner]

Well both CC and HD have been high suspects for awhile. Neither posts a bunch yet fall through the cracks. I would be on board with either one if we want to hold off on saillias.

[jayswin]

K, let's out some pressure and see what happens.

Vote: HalifaxDrunk

[jayswin]

*put

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

But then we'll lynch a townie? (you)???

Yes, it will be worth it to get a mafia kill.

Investigate me, I am town...we lynch someone else who may also be town. Or investigate someone else who flips mafia, lynch me. It's 1 town death vs 2 and you get a mafia lead.

[saillias]

Originally Posted by flameswin

I'll answer my own question. One post since May 16th, and this is it. Very interesting, considering what we now know (provided diss is telling the truth). Downright damning, actually.

Combine that with his two arguments with townies that resulted in their deaths and I think I've got my new CrazyBaconLegs!

and I was 100% convinced HD was the cop. I was confident following his lead to vote legoman

[dissentowner]

I am down with flameswin's plan.
Unvote
Vote: HalifaxDrunk

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by HalifaxDrunk

Ok first off, I'm now sorry for pointing at Delgar. I really thought he was scum, turns out just a bad neighbour.

Would I really engage in that back and forth banter for nothing if I thought he was anything but Mafia? I was the only vote for him, how could I convince other Mafia members to then vote with me? I was the only one after him when there was a clear target in hmmhmmcamo, I could have blended in with the vote. Now his death puts me at the top of most suspicion lists. This is 100% a Mafia setup for the town to take out another of their own.

On Friday I agreed to a version of Delgar’s bet calling him to accept. He said that he would post later that night then disappeared for the weekend. I totally figured I had caught a Mafia member when he didn’t accept the bet. I am 100% town and wouldn’t have been dumb enough to weaken a Mafia with such a stupid bet.

If/when I do die, kill take a look at the people who called me out since the night kill, there are defiantly Mafia members who know I am not with them so I’m now an easy target:

• HG15
• agulati (has me on two top 3 suspect lists)
• starseed
• bizaro86
• CofR (three times he tried to throw suspicion on me today)
  
• Kermet – semi-suspect to me as he posted my Delgar feud history

My vote is for his suspicion of me along with his posting slip:
Vote: Agulati

Woah look at this list from HD. I don't think he is Parker, no way he would call out his 3 buddies.