CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Of that list i think earlier kermit raised some flags, people think I am suspicious, HD had a couple run-ins with town that got night killed, CC is on some peoples radar, and completely and Dropit haven't really done much to help.

I don't really have much on Flameswin and UCB.

My biggest flaw is my track record. I just don't have it this game, so far.

[Hockeyguy15]

Join the club, I outed the cop. Only think I have been right about so far is CofR.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Join the club, I outed the cop. Only think I have been right about so far is CofR.

Indeed... BARROW SCUM!!!

[Baxter Renegade]

Does Kermit quit if he's Barrow? not a chance... They're doing too well. Does he quit if he's a townie? Probably not... But maybe.

Oling was wasted night 5... The only vote Oling had for lynch was by Kermit... Kermit and CofR made the call to kill Oling and assumed Barrow would kill me. Come the morn of day 6, with me still alive and his buddy killed by a lucky bullet, he snapped and passed his role to Saillias.

We lynch Saillias which defeats Parker, then I think Diss investigates HG.

[Hockeyguy15]

It will be a waste to investigate me, I would rather we investigate completely or Dropit, an if neither of them are mafia I can be lynched.

[jayswin]

I think completely would be the best investigation. The only thing that's weird to me;

Baxter says "I'm the doctor!"

dissentowner says "I'm the cop!" and lists things he and transplant did

...and now we're all like "awesome, now we know the doctor and cop!".

[saillias]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

You want a reason? Do you really want a reason? You got it. I am the cop.
Night 1 T99 scanned SP, he was obviously not mafia and was killed later on.
Night 2 he did not even bother to do an action
Night 3 he checked strombad, he is not mafia either
Night 4 I checked Rathji, he is not mafia
Night 5 I checked Lego because I was certain he was mafia but he isn't. I was trying to say I might be down with voting for him but in reality I said I would rather vote your way because I have no idea what you are and when the votes to lynch him started coming I had to try and dissuade that vote. So there it is, you know who is town now and seeing how I am suspicious that BR is not the doctor I m probably dead anyhow. So be it. Is that good enough to second guess?

Oh, just saw this. So yeah I think we're done. At what point do the winning mafia members come out and just admit who they are and just openly post in this thread? That would make me sick. Kill me first.

[Hockeyguy15]

We aren't done, we have a 50/50 chance of bagging mafia.

[Hockeyguy15]

I last question dissentowner. If you knew that Lego was town, then when ineedanother brought up me, Lego and rathji why did you say you were ok voting for lego or me but not rathji? Why didn't you just say me?

Just for my sanity, because there is still a tiny chance this is all an act.

[saillias]

Unvote

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Out of those 3 I would be most comfortable with voting Hockeyguy15 or Lego. I have wrecked my brain reading through this thread, lol. I really don't think Rathji is mob, between gut feeling and his posts I am least suspicious out of that list. Lego is confusing as hell, sometimes I think he is mob and other times I am not so sure. Hockeyguy15 seems like he might be hiding the most so if we want to go that route I am down but I still think saillias is mob.

Ahhh... good catch HockeyGuy...

Diss?!?!?! What up with that? You should have known Lego was Town.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I last question dissentowner. If you knew that Lego was town, then when ineedanother brought up me, Lego and rathji why did you say you were ok voting for lego or me but not rathji? Why didn't you just say me?

Just for my sanity, because there is still a tiny chance this is all an act.

I had just scanned Lego the night before and really felt he would turn up mafia. When he didn't I didn't want to just come out and say right away that he was not mafia after believing he was because that would look suspicious. So instead I tried to say I would be comfortable voting either of you but moreso you and try and sway the votes that way because I have not night actioned you. Then once the votes started piling on for Lego I had to push a bit harder that he was town. I probably didn'r play it the best but I did not want to expose my role at this time either if I didn't have to. Then as we got into our little argument I got caught up in it and had to take a step back. After I did that I unvoted for you because something in my gut was telling me you were town and just were misreading me. So now I was faced with finding a way to get you off of me without leading a counter charge against you because I felt my vote was better used on one of the guys I suspected. That is why I was trying to get you to stop digging at me, not that I blame you really but then others were getting suspicious of me, Lego was a still a target so I felt it was time to reveal.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Ahhh... good catch HockeyGuy...

Diss?!?!?! What up with that? You should have known Lego was Town.

I did know but the night before I was on Lego pretty good and when starseed went I made the deep doodoo comment. How would it look if I just came out and said "I changed my mind, Lego is a town guy"? As soon as his vote count hit 4 that is what I did though which just caused more suspicion. This is a hard role to have.

[saillias]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

I think Kermit quit due to the pressure of being the final guy in his mob... Didn't feel he could play well enough to save it for his team and gave up his spot to saillias?

Believe me I wish he was.

[dissentowner]

I also tried to lead people to think Lego was the cop when he asked if maybe the cop should come forward. I thought if I could convince the town Lego was hinting he was the cop that the votes for him would be unvoted and he would be safe that way.

[Hockeyguy15]

Fair enough, I can live with that.

[jayswin]

Pretty convincing reasoning I guess. I don't know, do we just go with dissentowner's claim as gospel for one day and see what comes of it?

No matter what happens, we're going to have some very significant information by the start of day 7, at this rate. Only problem is, hopefully it's not too late.

[Baxter Renegade]

^^^ I believe Diss

[Hockeyguy15]

But really though if we lynch the last Parker mafia don't waste an investigation on me, I would rather you investigate someone else and lynch me the next day.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Does Kermit quit if he's Barrow? not a chance... They're doing too well. Does he quit if he's a townie? Probably not... But maybe.

Oling was wasted night 5... The only vote Oling had for lynch was by Kermit... Kermit and CofR made the call to kill Oling and assumed Barrow would kill me. Come the morn of day 6, with me still alive and his buddy killed by a lucky bullet, he snapped and passed his role to Saillias.

We lynch Saillias which defeats Parker, then I think Diss investigates HG.

So, regarding the final Parker Scum... Does anyone think this has any traction?