CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[GGG]

In case I die tonight here is my complete set of logic based on my multitudes of posts.
Mafia 1 – Focused on One Thing
Strombad - Singular focus, Death pact
Legoman – Singular Focus, Inactive during Vig
UCB – lower suspicion then the other two but he also fits the singular focus. He focuses on eliminating the lowest posters without really attacking anyone else (until legoman today). The problem with the low post strategy is that everyone who was experienced would be aware that inactivity was a tell last game. Inactive during Vig. Jumped on the unvote Bandwagon along with Dsal and Kermit
Starseed- originally I had him leaning player as I though he posted follow the leader before ineed made his list. Ineeds list had gpmatt on it, myself and someone else. Since then he has continually focused on this being the best strategy even after it failed twice
Mafia 2 Try to sneak by while not appearing inactive
Activestick Strombads suspicion, lack of posting, inactive during vig
Baxter Renegade – was inactive, called out, became active
Crazy Bacon Legs – Inactive during VIG, Posts aren’t entertaining but not useful
My final person in here is a pretty weak suspicion but if I am dead I want to look good if I am right. DSav, experienced player, inactive during key event and jumped on the unvote bandwagon. This one is the weakest of my suspicions and really a pure guess but Dsav offered much more last game.
I won’t be back until after 10, hopefully we get the unvotes in time.

[Oling_Roachinen]

I'm voting for Crazy Bacon Legs. I had my original reasoning as I was afraid he would not be posting "seriously" but he's done a decent job in that regard.

I am, however, suspicious of his recent actions. I was making a post when he dropped the hammer. Obviously he might not have known but it wasn't the greatest of timing as there was a couple posters in the thread at the time as shown by the several posts after the hammer was dropped.

He only has 5 posts of substance.
1. He defends himself, can't blame him for that. But some of the logic doesn't quite add up (like saying if I am mafia I know for sure he is townsperson, "forgetting" about the 2 sides)
2. Here he once again emphasizes he didn't think of that while making sure we know he is new.
3. Here he again emphasizes he doesn't know, as though somehow the rest of have figured this out? At the same time makes it known that those who take charge and are wrong should have suspicions cast on them. Trying to scare people away from leading?
4. Casts hammer while stating he is just going with the group deflecting responsibility. Does note his suspicion of transplant
5. Here he makes note of his suspicions of transplant again and says if agulati ends up townsperson we need to go after those who first went after him.

While I've said I don't think agulati is mafia, I don't believe those who jumped on him for the "slip" are necessarily mafia either. I feel that the mafia will be trying to skirt the middle. Crazy Bacon Legs' suggestions of going after those who are leading would make sense if his mafia group have decided to not try and lead. Let the townsperson (or other mafia section) take out each other then go after those who made the initial suggestion while they hide in the middle. At the same time he's being very diligent in making sure we know he "doesn't know anything."

[Oling_Roachinen]

Vote: Crazy Bacon Legs
I guess to make it official

[Oling_Roachinen]

Ah crap, 2 and 3 link to same post. 3 should link to this one:
http://forum.calgarypuck.com/showthr...86#post4750886

[Aeneas]

I agree with flameswin, something fishy with kermitology.
However I still see agulati as the best bet. Maybe it was an honest mistake, but what other solid things do we have to go on?

[Hockeyguy15]

I really think not voting for agulati will come back to bite us.

[dsavillian]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I really think not voting for agulati will come back to bite us.

we can get him tomorrow.

[starseed]

I initially voted agulati just to apply pressure to see cracks. His defense was not very effective, but that is not why I decided to maintain my vote. I think his flipping mafia could help us in more ways than just getting rid of one mafia. A mafia flip could also put his potential allies in the spotlight because of acting when seeing that CC bailed. If it isn't then hopefully people will start to proof their posts a little more.

[Rathji]

As a town, we need to be voting for someone to give us the most info possible.

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by dsavillian

we can get him tomorrow.

Wo knows what new information we get between now and then. We should lynch our best mafia bet now, not give it up for a bunch of non consensus choices.

If we get a bunch of great info post flip, then we will have to choose between that suspect and agulati.

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by Rathji

As a town, we need to be voting for someone to give us the most info possible.

With most of today's focus being agulati focused, his flip will give us the most info, IMO. Plus, if he flips mafia, only a few people didn't vote for him, which would give us a short list of potentials.

[kermitology]

Guys, read my previous post, I've been struggling all day with agulati. I'm bothered by the lopsided vote on him. I really don't think he's mafia.

[DropIt]

I am really undecided. I see it as both Legoman and Agulati may have mis-spoken and revealed something... but every time I read what Agulati wrote, I just can't help but think he meant for that message to be read by a different crowd.

I am willing to keep my vote open, but we dont gain much more from one being voted out to the other do we? Until convinced otherwise, Agulati's a bit more damning this day than anyone else and will retain my vote.

[jayswin]

So what are we gonna do here? Under an hour til the hammer drops. Ride it out with Agulati and see what happens, or try and go for someone else?

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by flameswin

So what are we gonna do here? Under an hour til the hammer drops. Ride it out with Agulati and see what happens, or try and go for someone else?

I can't see changing my vote from agulati unless something big happens.

[dsavillian]

pure hypothetical here

if you were mafia, would you rather go after the other mafia gang or players at this point in the game?

[dsavillian]

you being the general you, not any one person in particular

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dsavillian

you being the general you, not any one person in particular

I assume they only know who is in their faction, they won't know the difference between town and the other faction.

[kermitology]

Yeah, that's my understanding as well. If you're mafia, you know your 4 guys, everyone else is your targets.

[strombad]

Nothing like waking up to some last minute drama!