CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by devo22

so the day won't end for another 32 hours anyway.

So . . . . anyone read any good books lately?

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

So . . . . anyone read any good books lately?

[devo22]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

So . . . . anyone read any good books lately?

out next week:

[Rathji]

Originally Posted by agulati

So we now know that ineedanother is definitely town, but his target so far has been unfortunately on townsfolk.

I will personally be vary of his recommendations for now.

As for mafia, I am concerned with Rathji. He unvoted after all the votes had been cast. It almost seems like he did that, so at a future date that claim can be made, that he did not end up voting for ineedanother. This might be because he is playing for the first time, and I am off completely though.

I haven't read the entire thread after the night kills, but I started the post well before the last few votes, not even realizing that they had happened when I hit submit. The reason is agonized about what I wanted to include in it, making quite a few revisions and even debating if it was worth it to even unvote as the momentum was going to kill him anyway.

I know I can't prove any of that, and the timing of the post looks like I intentionally made my unvote not count, but there is almost no way that he wouldn't have been lynched anyway.

I will make a post about my other thoughts after I have read the rest of this thread.

[HalifaxDrunk]

Ok first off, I'm now sorry for pointing at Delgar. I really thought he was scum, turns out just a bad neighbour.

Would I really engage in that back and forth banter for nothing if I thought he was anything but Mafia? I was the only vote for him, how could I convince other Mafia members to then vote with me? I was the only one after him when there was a clear target in hmmhmmcamo, I could have blended in with the vote. Now his death puts me at the top of most suspicion lists. This is 100% a Mafia setup for the town to take out another of their own.

On Friday I agreed to a version of Delgar’s bet calling him to accept. He said that he would post later that night then disappeared for the weekend. I totally figured I had caught a Mafia member when he didn’t accept the bet. I am 100% town and wouldn’t have been dumb enough to weaken a Mafia with such a stupid bet.

If/when I do die, kill take a look at the people who called me out since the night kill, there are defiantly Mafia members who know I am not with them so I’m now an easy target:

• HG15
• agulati (has me on two top 3 suspect lists)
• starseed
• bizaro86
• CofR (three times he tried to throw suspicion on me today)
  
• Kermet – semi-suspect to me as he posted my Delgar feud history

My vote is for his suspicion of me along with his posting slip:
Vote: Agulati

[Baxter Renegade]

I find myself very suspicious of Agulati, Rathji, Street Pharmacist and CaptainCrunch.

For now, Ill join the status quo:
VOTE: AGULATI

I'm going to look back into this thread regarding the night kills that occurred and see if anything spikes my spidey sense.

[Rathji]

ok, seems that some attention is coming my way, and with how things went with ineedanother, I am not really surprised. My gut instinct turned into a huge clusterf&*( that might cost us the game.

Nothing I can say about it really, I guess, so I won't. However, I welcome any questions that anyone has about why I did something at a particular stage of that fiasco.

My thoughts about mafia at the current time:

I was convinced GP_Matt was mafia, based almost entirely off his suggestion to reveal cop and doctor. Don't know if I am glad to be wrong again, but I think it is very good experience that a gut instinct isn't worth much in the game, in case I needed another reminder after ineedanother.

transplant99: Inactivity is a curse that will haunt him here I think. He was going to be my primary vote if night actions didn't turn up anything that helped, which I don't think they did.

agulati: Something is strange about that post that triggered this whole flurry of votes. Unless he comes up with a good solution, he has to be the front runner for my vote. We have a long time for him to defend himself here, so I am not at all concerned about pushing him over beforehand.

Vote: agulati

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by HalifaxDrunk

Ok first off, I'm now sorry for pointing at Delgar. I really thought he was scum, turns out just a bad neighbour.

Would I really engage in that back and forth banter for nothing if I thought he was anything but Mafia? I was the only vote for him, how could I convince other Mafia members to then vote with me? I was the only one after him when there was a clear target in hmmhmmcamo, I could have blended in with the vote. Now his death puts me at the top of most suspicion lists. This is 100% a Mafia setup for the town to take out another of their own.

On Friday I agreed to a version of Delgar’s bet calling him to accept. He said that he would post later that night then disappeared for the weekend. I totally figured I had caught a Mafia member when he didn’t accept the bet. I am 100% town and wouldn’t have been dumb enough to weaken a Mafia with such a stupid bet.


If/when I do die, kill take a look at the people who called me out since the night kill, there are defiantly Mafia members who know I am not with them so I’m now an easy target:

• HG15
• agulati (has me on two top 3 suspect lists)
• starseed
• bizaro86
• CofR (three times he tried to throw suspicion on me today)
  
• Kermet – semi-suspect to me as he posted my Delgar feud history

My vote is for his suspicion of me along with his posting slip:
Vote: Agulati

The reason so many people called you out is that it seems really suspicious that you feuded with Delgar then he gets offed. He called you out, so you night killing him makes sense. Maybe its a fiendish mafia plot to frame you, but I don't think its unreasonable that we're discussing you as a suspect.

Anyway, I think Agulati still makes sense right now based on his slip-up. If the mafia was trying to frame you, they did a bad job, since I don't think you even got any votes. If they were trying a frame they probably would have followed it up with votes, imo.

[kermitology]

HD: I didn't post your feud history, I only posted a history of Delgar's posts in this thread. Interesting conclusion you drew from that.

[CaptainCrunch]

Yeah, that's really the main reason for the suspicion on you. Argument and a throat cutting.

Would you be a bigger target if Agulati didn't step on what could either be a monstrous blunder or hilarious land mind will be interesting.

[kermitology]

Specifically, I only referenced that he was trying to draw attention to you.

[Completely]

So, after having like 600 posts in day one and still having a ton of trouble picking someone. our day 2 is pretty much an instant lynch. Love this game so far.

I just think that Even if Agulati is town, he pretty much just acted as a mafia meat sheild. People causing confusion doesn't help our progress at all.

Vote: Agulati

[activeStick]

We really need to look at who voted for hmmmcamo for lynching. agulati is definitely a good candidate for this round but when I get a chance after work I'll post my view from the hmmmcamo lynch to see who might be Mafia in there...

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by activeStick

We really need to look at who voted for hmmmcamo for lynching. agulati is definitely a good candidate for this round but when I get a chance after work I'll post my view from the hmmmcamo lynch to see who might be Mafia in there...

Your search should start with ineedanother, he seems very suspicious.

/sarcasm.

[Crazy Bacon Legs]

So I'm still suspicious of transplant99, as I said when I voted last round. I would be willing to carry on with going after him, but it looks like the wind has blown in a different direction. The problem is we still have such limited information.

Here's the thing: I am also really wary of Agulanti now. There are one of two possibilities here:

1) He worded something awkwardly, is a townsperson, and is being jumped on by mafia members who know they can kill another townsperson. Others are naturally piling on.

2) It was a genuine Freudian slip, or a mis-post and he is mafia, being jumped on heroically by members of the town. The mafia members are gnashing their teeth in frustration at their foolish compatriot.

I see this going one of two ways. If we vote for Agulati and he turns out to be a townsperson, we pretty much have to go after the guys who started jumping on him, mainly because it's all we have. If he turns out to be mafia, then he really has trouble with typing skills.

I'll hold off for now on voting and reserve judgment. I was too hasty last round and ended up casting the hammer vote for an innocent person.

[HalifaxDrunk]

Originally Posted by kermitology

HD: I didn't post your feud history, I only posted a history of Delgar's posts in this thread. Interesting conclusion you drew from that.

Originally Posted by kermitology

Yeah, a bunch of posts trying to draw attention to HD

http://forum.calgarypuck.com/search....archid=6096548

Your link didn't work and from what you said how could I not get to that conclusion?

[GGG]

Originally Posted by agulati

Day 1 reveal, wow.

I agree, it might be better to hold up till a later day, to use the day kill when we have a better guess as to the townies vs mafia

Above is Agulati's only post during the Vig reveal to Vig Kill timeframe. This is right after the reveal and then he goes silent. As I stated yesterday I believe that people who were inactive or didn't post about the vig are more likely mafia as they just sat back and watched the chaos. Agulati wasn't on my initial list of 8 names as he did post right at the reveal but he does fit the criteria.

So independent of the slip up there is some evidence against him.

[kermitology]

Originally Posted by HalifaxDrunk

Your link didn't work and from what you said how could I not get to that conclusion?

Ahh, sorry, I had tried to paste a link I did that searched the thread for all posts by Delgar. Forum didn't work the way my mind was.

[strombad]

I'm going to the other side of the continent in a few hours, so it's unlikely I'll have even a moment to check back in before tomorrow evening. That said, I'll go with the group since pretty much everyone is doing it and I just want to be cool.

Vote: Agulati

One day you'll all do what I wanna do. One day.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by strombad

I'm going to the other side of the continent in a few hours.

What for? Whack a guy? Off a guy? Whack off a guy?