CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Baxter Renegade]

UNVOTE
VOTE: hmmhmmcamo

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by kermitology

Let me be clear, I'm mostly interested on having the game move along. We need some card flips to get a better idea of who is what.

You seem very rushed to have him lynched.

[kermitology]

I want to game to move forward. That's all. Doesn't matter to me who. We could all flip to transplant and I'd be just as happy

[Hockeyguy15]

And what's the harm of waiting even a few hours? We will get more info that could help us down the road.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

I believe that's hammer. No more posts

Hmmm, seems like you're trying to save your mafia buddy hmmhmmcamo by trying to pass off a certain number of votes as a different, lower, more mafia-friendly number of votes... very peculiar...and damning...DAMNING!

[strombad]

What info would we get exactly? People revealed valuable information before they were axed all of (zero) times last game.

[kermitology]

You seem just as eager to defend him. Why is that? Seriously, I don't care, I'm fine with waiting. To be honest I was thinking we had until tonight before the deadline. I didn't realize it was tomorrow night.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by strombad

What info would we get exactly? People revealed valuable information before they were axed all of (zero) times last game.

Originally Posted by kermitology

You seem just as eager to defend him. Why is that? Seriously, I don't care, I'm fine with waiting. To be honest I was thinking we had until tonight before the deadline. I didn't realize it was tomorrow night.

Strombad, the vigilante was just outed. What if on the off chance hmmhmmcamo has a role? That would be something I want to know.

Kermit I'm not defending him. I'm saying slow up the vole pile on in case he has something important to say, then lynch. You were suspicious to me before and you aren't helping your cause now.

[strombad]

If he's the doctor or cop and reveals it, you know the mafia are just going to take him down anyway.

Plus, there's absolutely zero way to prove that either of those claims are true. With the vigilante there was at least tangible proof available.

[devo22]

why not give him the chance to have his final words? There's no harm in waiting for another hour. Maybe he can offer some thoughts that can help us going forward, especially if he flips as town.

[Street Pharmacist]

Originally Posted by devo22

why not give him the chance to have his final words? There's no harm in waiting for another hour. Maybe he can offer some thoughts that can help us going forward, especially if he flips as town.

If he's town, what can he offer?

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by strombad

If he's the doctor or cop and reveals it, you know the mafia are just going to take him down anyway.

Plus, there's absolutely zero way to prove that either of those claims are true. With the vigilante there was at least tangible proof available.

There may be no way to prove it like that vigilante, but if it's a lie it's an easy one to figure out.

[devo22]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

If he's town, what can he offer?

suspicions, observations, whatever. It's likely that he can't offer a lot since on day 1 we don't have much to rely on, but it's worth a shot. At this point, there's nothing to save him anyway, as we have enough votes to have him deadline lynched ... might as well give him a last chance to share his views.

[Hockeyguy15]

I'm not sure what the issue is for some people. Either he flips town and maybe he gives us something to go on, maybe he doesn't. Or he flips mafia and we don't have to worry about anything he said. Either way he is going home, and we move to day 2.

[strombad]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

There may be no way to prove it like that vigilante, but if it's a lie it's an easy one to figure out.

Is it? In what scenario is them claiming cop/doctor easy to figure out?

[hmmhmmcamo]

Just got in the door. I'll have some thoughts up in a few minutes.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by strombad

Is it? In what scenario is them claiming cop/doctor easy to figure out?

Well call me crazy but I'm pretty sure the real cop or doctor would know it's a lie. So then you have 2 people claiming to have the role, one of which is guaranteed mafia.

[Kjesse]

I haven't been on board because I think there are better choices. But it seems to have been decided.

[Street Pharmacist]

Originally Posted by Delgar

I haven't been on board because I think there are better choices. But it seems to have been decided.

Who are better choices? I'm not sure there's much to go on here. I'm all for a quick pitchfork on day 1

[GP_Matt]

Originally Posted by flameswin

I'm good with Activestick (lol strombad), transplant, Baxter Renegade, or hmmhmmcamo, as those seem to be the front runners. Well, not Activestick, but strombad's soooo sure about him!.

Actually I'm good with almost anyone as it doesn't seem like we have any surefire guys right now, anyways, so let's just makes sure we're on the same page and not waste a day.

That's the thing. This round is almost completely random. I don't think anyone has given themselves away so going with ineed's random choice is better than going with anyone else's random choice as we know that he isn't manipulating us.

Tomorrow we will have three new card flips and then we can start evaluating what the dead people have said. If nothing is clear tomorrow then I am in favour of following ineedanother for a second day. He hasn't shown himself as making great decisions so far so I don't want to blindly follow him once we have some actual information but until then, his random pick is better than anyone else's.
Our own individual pick is of course better than ineed's but only if we are townies and not lying which no one else can know yet.