CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Mazrim]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Baxter Renegade has posted nothing since the 29th.

As a side note, after Day 1 I will be going after the inactives to post more.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

I couldn't think of a reason why people would want to follow ineedanother's lead after the botched role reveal and the Timbo mistake, but your post makes some sense. He's the only player right now that the Town knows isn't trying to deceive them.

But I'm worried that blindly following ineedanother is a mistake and will allow the Mafia to pile on and blend in. Obviously I'm biased as I have some votes for me, but my thoughts would be the same even if it was someone else being voted for by ineedanother.

Right now I'm leaning towards voting for the least active players as well. Either we find a hiding Mafia, or we get rid of a non contributing player that the Mafia can hide amongst.

The inactive posters are like camoflage for the scum. It gives them something to hide in.

[bizaro86]

Hmmhmmcamo demonstrated poor judgement saying to kill ineedanother instead of waiting when he said he was the vig. Plus we know ineedanother is town, which makes him a good person to follow.

Flameswin is right about not assuming everyone who follows ineedanother is town, but that doesn't mean following him isn't the best play for the town right now.

vote hmmhmmcamo

[jayswin]

Okay, so let's post the most inactive guys right now and publicly call them out to explain themselves and see if anything seems off.

[Street Pharmacist]

Originally Posted by flameswin

Okay, so let's post the most inactive guys right now and publicly call them out to explain themselves and see if anything seems off.

I'm good with that

[jayswin]

Not sure how to search for least to most posts in a thread, so can someone else throw the names up?

[hmmhmmcamo]

Players with less than 10 posts:

Baxter Renegade 2
Transplant99 2
Oling_Roachinen 3
activeStick 5
CofR 6
agulati 6
Aeneas 8

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by flameswin

Okay, so let's post the most inactive guys right now and publicly call them out to explain themselves and see if anything seems off.

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

I'm good with that

Originally Posted by flameswin

Not sure how to search for least to most posts in a thread, so can someone else throw the names up?

Hockeyguy15
57
CaptainCrunch
33
kermitology
32
GGG
26
HalifaxDrunk
25
Street Pharmacist
25
starseed
24
Timbo
24
strombad
23
Delgar
23
ineedanother
23
undercoverbrother
22
GP_Matt
21
Rathji
20
bizaro86
17
devo22
15
dsavillian
13
flameswin
12
DropIt
12
Lego Man
12
hmmhmmcamo
11
Mazrim
10
Completely
10
Aeneas
8
agulati
6
CofR
6
activeStick
5
Crazy Bacon Legs
4
Oling_Roachinen
3
transplant99
2
Baxter Renegade
2

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

Players with less than 10 posts:

Baxter Renegade 2
Transplant99 2
Oling_Roachinen 3
activeStick 5
CofR 6
agulati 6
Aeneas 8

Interesting you picked 10 as the cut off.......

[hmmhmmcamo]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Hey y'all!

Nice friggin' day today, I tell ya what.

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

It was. Im suspicious; worried even... Anyone wanna grab a brew? Thirsty Tuesday!

This is Baxter Renegades contribution so far.

[CofR]

I'll defend myself... Still trying to figure the whole game out, kind of sat on the sideline to start. Yesterday afternoon was golfing and then busy all evening. Was busy this morning so not able to post a whole lot in the immediate aftermath of the vig power being used... I'm trying to be more active this afternoon.

Found it kind of odd that hmmhmmcamo said to kill ineedanother, even after ineedanother stated he was the vig. At this time I am leaning towards voting for hmmhmmcamo.

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

Players with less than 10 posts:

Baxter Renegade 2
Transplant99 2
Oling_Roachinen 3
activeStick 5
CofR 6
agulati 6
Aeneas 8

With all the craziness and accusation that get thrown around on day 1, I wouldn't be too concerned with 5 or more post guys just yet, myself. They've been here, they've said a few things.

I say we focus on the bottom three first, as these three guys have said next to nothing other than to basically say "I'm here".

Baxter Renegade
Transplant99
Oling_Roachinen

Let's here what you guys have to say!

Especially Olin_Roachinen. Didn't he post quite a bit in the last game?

[CofR]

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

This is Baxter Renegades contribution so far.

Hmm, he's certainly not contributing much.... Can totally see how posting in that style could be a cover for being scum... Much like people's suspicions of CBL

[jayswin]

Oh FFS, hear, not here.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by flameswin

With all the craziness and accusation that get thrown around on day 1, I wouldn't be too concerned with 5 or more post guys just yet, myself. They've been here, they've said a few things.

I say we focus on the bottom three first, as these three guys have said next to nothing other than to basically say "I'm here".

Baxter Renegade
Transplant99
Oling_Roachinen

Let's here what you guys have to say!

Especially Olin_Roachinen. Didn't he post quite a bit in the last game?

Originally Posted by CofR

Hmm, he's certainly not contributing much.... Can totally see how posting in that style could be a cover for being scum... Much like people's suspicions of CBL

I am happy with any of:

Baxter Renegade 2
Transplant99 2
Oling_Roachinen 3

As stated before, they are either scum or useless townies.

[Mazrim]

Vote Count:

With 29 alive, it takes 15 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 10 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (10): flameswin, CofR, agulati, Baxter Renegade, undercoverbrother, activeStick, Delgar, kermitology, hmmhmmcamo, Rathji

Voting:
hmmhmmcamo (6): ineedanother, starseed, Aeneas, devo22, GP_Matt, bizaro86
kermitology (3): strombad, Hockeyguy15, DropIt
ineedanother (2): Street Pharmacist, transplant99
Crazy Bacon Legs (1): Oling_Roachinen
GP_Matt (1): dsavillian
Completely (1): Lego Man
Oling_Roachinen (1): Crazy Bacon Legs
transplant99 (1): GGG
Rathji (1): CaptainCrunch
starseed (1): Completely
Delgar (1): HalifaxDrunk

Deadline is Sunday, May 4th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[Aeneas]

I could get on board voting for Oling...R...

1. Low post count.
2. As Flameswin said, quieter than last game.
3. Most importantly, hard to type user name.

[hmmhmmcamo]

Originally Posted by CofR

Found it kind of odd that hmmhmmcamo said to kill ineedanother, even after ineedanother stated he was the vig. At this time I am leaning towards voting for hmmhmmcamo.

Again, I though ineedanother's role reveal was the mark of a panicking Mafia member who had a few votes thrown his way. There were a few posters that came to his defence right away to me that looked like his Mafia buddies trying to steer the ship.

It was Rathji who got us into this mess, and he really hasn't had to defend himself to much. He was pushing hard before the role reveal, and then again after.

Street Pharmacist was in there voting right away too. I don't think he's defended himself yet.

Then Timbo jumped in, and we all know how that went.

It's interesting that Transplant99 jumped in right after me and voted for ineedanother with only his 2nd post of the game.

[hmmhmmcamo]

I think Transplant99's vote looks suspicious the more I think about it.

If he's Mafia, he would have known that ineedanother wasn't part of his team, and when it looked like the ineedanother vote was going to explode, he quietly jumped in.

He's who I would be leaning towards if we're going after inactive posters.

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

I think Transplant99's vote looks suspicious the more I think about it.

If he's Mafia, he would have known that ineedanother wasn't part of his team, and when it looked like the ineedanother vote was going to explode, he quietly jumped in.

He's who I would be leaning towards if we're going after inactive posters.

Yeah, that's fair, and as UCB said, if he is Town, we're not losing a contributer.