Quote:
Originally Posted by dissentowner
All is not lost, we still have the numbers. As for someone telling us they passed the spore on, if they are infected why would they do that? Their end game goal will now be different. If they were not infected and told us how could we trust that they are being honest? Things are gonna get dicey, that's for sure.
|
This was Diss' first post of Day 2. It stands out to me because we had already talked in depth about spore reveal scenarios on day 1. I'm not sure why he wanted to clarify this stuff again?
Quote:
Originally Posted by dissentowner
So do we start taking a harder look at how the voting went there? You would have to think at least one scum voted for Activestick. Maybe had the others vote elsewhere so they are not all grouped together? Still damn hard at this stage to get a read though.
|
A few minutes after that first post he asks if we want to look at the first vote now. He does no analysis of the first vote ever, and I believe this is his only mention of it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by dissentowner
I can't see why we would not lynch GS knowing she carries the spore. It prevents the passing of it for a whole day and buys us some time. If we don't she will continue to claim she was never turned and if she did that is another person manipulating and voting with the scum. We could investigate Oling but what is the point? I feel he is either a host or an unturned passenger, I believe the latter. If he is a host it will be a waste because the GA will get a false reading right? I say we lynch GS and investigate someone else, my recommendation there would be Timbo as the way he is playing is throwing up some serious red flags for me.
|
Diss then has this post, but it's flawed logic. The flaw is when he says if we don't lynch her she will continue to claim she was never turned. He says we can investigate Oling but what's the point? He never talks about investigating Girly, which would either kill her or clear her of being infected. He then suggests we investigate Timbo, but what would be the point of that since none of us suspect Timbo of being infected??
Quote:
Originally Posted by dissentowner
I see zero logic in not voting for GirlySports
Vote:GirlySports
|
He votes for Girly and says there is no logic in not voting for her. That isn't true, we talked about the different logic for a long time and never once did we come to the conclusion that there was no logic in voting for someone else. It came down to what you thought was more likely, but even if you thought Girly was a host/infected there was still logic to leaving her alive to investigate instead of lynching her.
Quote:
Originally Posted by dissentowner
Because she is the best known target for this lynch. We know she has the spore, she could be a host, she is probably turned given the way she posted. Even if she hasn't turned we get a spore free night as a worst case scenario. If we lynch someone else and they end up being a passenger which odds are they will be and we leave GS in play that is a huge win for the scum.
|
Again he is ignoring the fact that we can investigate her and she will be killed if she is turned. GGG calls this statement false because the agent can investigate her if we don't lynch her but Diss never comments on that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by dissentowner
So we still will never know if GS actually had the spore? Assuming she did that now gives us a spore free day. What about Oling now, where is he? We need to work hard to figure out a host, won't be easy.
|
This is Diss' first post from today. Again he asks the question we have already discussed for how long the day before? He also ends with a similar comment to the previous day. It's weird to me how similar this post and his first post from the previous day are. Ask a question that has already been answered, make a comment about how hard the game is.
He accused me of pointing the spotlight everywhere but on me, but looking at his posts it's almost like he is doing the same thing. It's like he wants to get us back onto topics we have already covered, maybe that's to keep the scent off the hosts? I'm leaning towards Diss being a host at the moment.