I use Johnson Incorporated, they are the cheapest I have ever seen. When I renewed my car insurance, I was getting raped by AMA, and I called at least a dozen places and Meloch Monnex was one of them. They could not even touch the rate that was given to me by Johnson.
I had insured a 2009 Corolla (brand new), full theft, fire, collision, 2 mill liability, and that underinsured motorist protection thingie for $950 a year.
I have never even heard of a company able to match what they offered me.
On the plus side... you pay insurance, might as well get free Air Miles