Best Calgary Flames Draft Picks - Round 24

[Bingo]

1. MacInnis 32%
2. Nieuwendyk 35%
3. Gaudreau 36%
4. Hull 44%
5. Fleury 42%
6. Vernon 54%
7. Tkachuk 28%
8. Suter 26%
9. Roberts 36%
10. Loob 49%
11. Nilsson 51%
12. Wolf 31%
13. Backlund (run off)
14. Monahan (run off)
15. Makarov (run off)
16. Reinhart 28%
17. Bennett 34%
18. Phaneuf
19. Chouinard 23%
20. Fox 35%
21. Andersson 38%
22. Peplinski 22%
23. Brodie 30%

[Mathgod]

Coronato all the way down at 24. I think in a few years we may look back at this and laugh.

[GioforPM]

Morris was a really good player.

[Bingo]

Originally Posted by Mathgod

Coronato all the way down at 24. I think in a few years we may look back at this and laugh.

Which I think is natural.

The guy has only played 112 NHL games and hasn't earned that position yet.

On his pace he could be top 15 on this list in a few seasons.

[GioforPM]

Originally Posted by Bingo

Which I think is natural.

The guy has only played 112 NHL games and hasn't earned that position yet.

On his pace he could be top 15 on this list in a few seasons.

It's hard to rank a guy with two seasons versus players who performed well over a career (I know we've ranked Parekh way up there with no track record at all).

[Mathgod]

Originally Posted by Bingo

Which I think is natural.

The guy has only played 112 NHL games and hasn't earned that position yet.

On his pace he could be top 15 on this list in a few seasons.

Yes but I think it's fair to predict how a player's career may unfold, and rank him based on that. Otherwise guys who haven't played a whole career (or not played at all) are at a huge disadvantage.

We seemed willing to do it for Parekh and Wolf, but not for Coronato. I'm not sure why.

[Reggie Dunlop]

Plett was a Calder winner, if that counts.

[Bingo]

Originally Posted by Mathgod

Yes but I think it's fair to predict how a player's career may unfold, and rank him based on that. Otherwise guys who haven't played a whole career (or not played at all) are at a huge disadvantage.

We seemed willing to do it for Parekh and Wolf, but not for Coronato. I'm not sure why.

Absolutely.

You can vote how you wish, but clearly others aren't voting that way or he'd be higher.