Calgarypuck Mafia Game Thread

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

DropIt let me ask you this. I made post #540 outlining where my head was at after looking at GGG's posts, and then you came back with a defense in post #542 except I hadn't even made a case against you?

In post #540 you literally said you thought Scorn or myself were Oiler fans trying to gain favour.

Dissentowner and Fuzz we know are town. I lean towards Puxlut and agulati being town. GGG and Bonded voted for agulati, would they have all 3 vote for the same person day 1? That seems risky. That leaves me to look at DropIt and Scornfire as possible Oiler fans trying to gain Flames fan credit with a ban of their own buddy

I think at this time you have laid the foundation down that this is a possibility.

As I said in #542, during day 1 I had the option of killing off Agulati as I was a heavy swing vote when Bonded was actually BEHIND Agulati in the voting. That wouldn't be piling on a buddy to gain favour, it would be actively trying to get a fellow Oiler out. In a game where the Oilers only have 3 it makes no sense from my standpoint to vote Bonded at the time that I did.

[Hockeyguy15]

I wanted the night ban discussion stopped? Why was I the first person to bring it up then? There were other people talking about the bizaro ban before you even showed up and I never shut them down.

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

GGG “forgets” the vote on Bonded, now his “incorrect vote” comment. Two rather large accidents from a generally thorough poster.

I would also expect some speculation on why they banned bizaro last night, but if you already know why I guess it could be easy to gloss over. Hopefully I’ll have some time to look over his posts here but I’ve got a sick kid and I’m still trying to get used to juggling parenting and this game. Playing was much easier when I didn’t have a 2 year old.

[DropIt]

It was brought up. Not discussed. It was mentioned as much by Mrk.

Originally Posted by mrkajz44

I think the night kill of Bizaro has been completely overlooked so far. I'm glad DropIt brings it up (even though it puts on the focus on me) as it seems the Oilers just got a free ban and no one is really analyzing why it happened. If nothing of any further consequence happens today, I'm concerned the kill of Bizaro will be completely overlooked with information from two new bans available for discussion. Would really like some further opinions on the bizaro ban now - its really helpful down the road to see early theories on items as you can sometimes see people knowing too much in early days, but it is only caught through hindsight. By no one talking about the Bizaro kill, we lose that advantage.

Specifically you mentioned that you would like to look into it further later on and I dont see any case in which you did so

[DropIt]

Also I am on my phone and working outdoors so please excuse any glaring typos

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by DropIt

Also I am on my phone and working outdoors so please excuse any glaring typos

Gross. Thoughts and prayers.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by DropIt

It was brought up. Not discussed. It was mentioned as much by Mrk.



Specifically you mentioned that you would like to look into it further later on and I dont see any case in which you did so

Post #404 GGG quotes this bizaro post.

Originally Posted by bizaro86

I think right now my best thoughts are one of scornfire/agulati are newish oiler fans. The piling on winnipegfan and the defensiveness after (more so scornfire) suggest that to me.

For the veterans - GGG is playing exactly the same game he always does. If he's an oiler fan he's really good. Sebc is inscrutable as always. Last time he got lynched quick for that, I'd like to see how it plays out a bit.

Hg and mrkajz both seem a bit off from their usual styles. I think it seems like one of them may be an oiler fan as well.

Id be inclined to jump on any of those 4, and if we don't have someone at 5 by this time tomorrow I'll jump on whomever of them has the most votes to make sure we get a lynch.

Post #405 agulati gives his take on the kill.
Post #407 devo comments on it.
Post #426 mrkajz talks about it.
Post #428 you talk about.
Post #436 dissentowner talks bout it.

And no that day I didn't speculate on why bizaro was killed, but I have speculated on them since.

[DropIt]

Without going back through the whole thread has it been addressed why WPG voted for GGG on day 2, pulled out when that picked up steam and invited, only to set him up with a self kill? I know it was discussed but can someone direct me to post # of WPGs explanation? Or where we have cleared him?

This isn't a redirection attempt either. Keep grilling me HG

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Post #404 GGG quotes this bizaro post.



Post #405 agulati gives his take on the kill.
Post #407 devo comments on it.
Post #426 mrkajz talks about it.
Post #428 you talk about.
Post #436 dissentowner talks bout it.

And no that day I didn't speculate on why bizaro was killed, but I have speculated on them since.

426 you're right. 405 and 407 had some speculation but nothing more. Either way it still seems like it was really not looked at much considering potential tip offd

[Hockeyguy15]

Why are we the only 2 people posting?

[Scornfire]

/looks around, Hello

[DropIt]

I wish diss, Biz and 3G dodnt have to get booted if only for what they brought to the game.

MRK and WPG, I'd specifically like go hear more from you. WPG for reasons I posted and I've noticed MRK has had a ton of latch on posts. Agreeing with a lot of content but not creating much... he seems to agree with almost everyone else's theories. Maybe trying to cling on to people after losing your mafia friends

That's my initial feeling of course, I dont have time to pick through this thread after this particular time

[devo22]

might as well throw a vote out there at this point. I'll go mrkajz44 for now, primarily based on voting history and gut feeling.

[devo22]

vote: mrkajz44

[Hockeyguy15]

vote: mrkajz44

[Hockeyguy15]

I'm not sold on this yet, but we can't not have a ban today.

No more votes, 4 is hammer.

[DropIt]

I wish diss, Biz and 3G dodnt have to get booted if only for what they brought to the game.

MRK and WPG, I'd specifically like go hear more from you. WPG for reasons I posted and I've noticed MRK has had a ton of latch on posts. Agreeing with a lot of content but not creating much... he seems to agree with almost everyone else's theories. Maybe trying to cling on to people after losing your mafia friends

That's my initial feeling of course, I dont have time to pick through this thread after this particular time

[devo22]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I'm not sold on this yet, but we can't not have a ban today.

No more votes, 4 is hammer.

deadline is tomorrow though (thought it was today, but Olings post says 7th), so there's still time.

[Hockeyguy15]

Ha, I totally lost a day!

[Hockeyguy15]

Remove vote: mrkajz44

[Hockeyguy15]

Maybe that explains why no one was here coming down to crunch time.