CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[hmmhmmcamo]

-----Dead Post-----

Lessons learned:

-Get an easier name to spell.

-Refrain from using the phrase “that’s nonsense” when disagreeing with an opinion that you have no factual evidence to disagree with.

-It’s probably best to just s.t.f.u.

I’d also like to apologize to ineedanother for being a part of the whole nightmare that resulted in his role reveal, and then poor Timbo getting blasted in the face. That was a pretty crazy couple of hours.

Good luck everyone!

[CofR]

Originally Posted by DropIt

I dont think that attention came off him nearly enough for him to slip through the cracks without red flags. He sits atop my list now, quite the eye opening development after day one.

True, his lack of activity is pretty suspicious. I just can't get over the way Hd and Delgar argued yesterday... Not a stretch to think that HD could have killed Delgar over that.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by devo22

uh, rough night. And "weird" targets IMO, if that makes sense ... not the guys I expected to be targeted. Will have to go back and read their posts carefully.

for now, agulati tops my list of suspects ... might have been an honest mistake for all we know, but "wasting a night kill" just next to "lynch"? IMO that rings all kinds of alarm bells. Plus I still have transplant99 high on my list. Originally I voted for him purely for inactivity and unvoted after he checked in, but his posts leading up to the end of day 1 still seem a bit fishy to me. Generally I have been amazed with the inactive players ... call them out and surprise surprise - suddenly they're here. Just something that we have to remember IMO.

I think this is a very good point.

It makes you wonder if they have been notified.......

[Hockeyguy15]

Still no reply from agulati. He has been posting a lot in this thread today until he had that slip up, now he is pretty quiet.

[kermitology]

So Baxter Renegade and transplant99 have both been called out for lack of activity and then popped up suddenly.

* agulati for his slip up
* the two above for call out activity
* who else has been pretty inactive so far? Looks like Oling_Roachinen as well, a bit Aenas and CBL.

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Still no reply from agulati. He has been posting a lot in this thread today until he had that slip up, now he is pretty quiet.

To be fair, it hasn't been that long, and things do come up during the day.

Or maybe he's run off with his Mafia Allies and they're on the phone to the Cappo in Italy.

[Aeneas]

Two solid kills by the mafia. By that I mean two players who seem on top of things/intelligent. If I were mafia, I would want those guys dead.

However I am a townsperson and as such I will vote with the possible slip up:

VOTE: Agulati

Not only did he slip up, he has one of those user names I have trouble remembering! I am just not smart...so no reason to nightkill me mafia, not smart at all.

[kermitology]

Right now I'm torn between agulati, transplant99 and Baxter Renegade.

agulati, anything to say regarding your slips of the tongue?

[dsavillian]

the "Let our "mod" also get his hands red." line is really sticking out for me.


Is it even remotely possible that a mafia would post that here by mistake?


I went back through agulati's posts and he made a few that were very much of the "rah-rah, go players! Die mafia scum!" type cheerleading posts. That is usually an indicator IMO, but not 100% accurate in a vacuum.


vote agulati

[CaptainCrunch]

Yeah DSavillian, I keep going back to read that, I was wondering if he had a Mafia super secret forum open on one screen and this one on another screen, and zigged instead of zagged and couldn't edit or delete it.

Or he could have eaten paint chips as a kid

[Aeneas]

Originally Posted by kermitology

Aw man.. I looked on my phone and only saw Delgar had been nightkilled, and thought that maybe one of the mafia had been roleblocked.

Dammit.

Just going to throw some muck about for fun.
This post right after Mazrim posts the night kills reeks of mafia to me.

Still voting agulati for now, but willing to switch. Also have my eye on Olingroachminsomething because of the user name.

[kermitology]

It's tapatalk.. It hid GP_Matt's death from me

[devo22]

Originally Posted by dsavillian

the "Let our "mod" also get his hands red." line is really sticking out for me.

yup ... I didn't even see that at first because I was so focused on the "we should only then lynch him. No point wasting a night kill" part. Maybe a convincing rebuttal might still chance my feelings, but every time I read that post I grow more and more suspicious.

vote: agulati

[agulati]

The previous mafia game I played, the impression I had was that most of the lynches happened during the “real-time” night. I usually have a habit of trying to minimize repeating words in my posts. That is why I ended up using “(real time)night” kill instead of lynch in the next sentence. A mistake on my part.
On Day 1, prior to people voting off hmmhmmcamo, I had a post saying I have to go through the entire history prior to casting my vote. If I was mafia, at that time I could have easily made a post stating I completely agree and also vote him out, and been one of the crowd. I wanted to ensure that we were going in the right direction with our vote.

I was not keen with ineedanother using his vigilante kill on that day as well. If I was mafia I would have wanted him to use his vigilante kill since it would most probably waste it since the probability is quite low of using it correctly on day 1. I wanted him to hold up on it, to get a clearer picture of who could be the suspicious crowd.

[devo22]

Originally Posted by kermitology

It's tapatalk.. It hid GP_Matt's death from me

Photoshop level: expert

honestly though, I quickly checked Tapatalk and I see everything just fine.

[CaptainCrunch]

If there's an investigator, the smart move would be to investigate Agulati as a night move, if he survives.

That way we can know what kind of bumble he made. Was it a townie bumble or was it a mafia bumble.

Still not changing my vote yet though.

[agulati]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

Or he could have eaten paint chips as a kid

But they were all sorts of colors. Lemon, vanilla, chocolate. Funny that they didn't taste the way I thought they would.

[kermitology]

Good lord that looks like crap.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/lhz0o5hils...2012.46.27.png

[undercoverbrother]

As you know I have been pushing for Transplant99, but I am willing to vote with the rest of my townies.

I am having trouble believing that his post about night killing was an accident.

vote: Agulati

[agulati]

Ok guys I have to head to work. I might drop in to lurk/post during my shift.