CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by starseed

Mazrim posts links to the different events in the first post.

Thanks man, I'm old and I didn't see it

[Hockeyguy15]

For the record I only have 8 fingers and 2 thumbs.

[Hockeyguy15]

It's hard not to notice agulati coming in the thread and not saying anything.

[kermitology]

Despite my dislike for HG I think he's just got a bit of proverbial verbal diarrhea going on. He's just so suspicious of everyone.

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

Man this game makes you jumpy.

Right now, I'm really looking at Agulati (Slip up) Rathji (history) Transplant (activity), HG (Feels like he was really trying to point 8 million fingers)

I'd be comfortable taking this list, and maybe adding Halifax Drunk to it for the "might have night killed Delgar" factor, and letting ineedanother (the only confirmed townie) pick from it.

It gives us a logical base to go from, and then we know it's not the mafia leading the charge.

[agulati]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

It's hard not to notice agulati coming in the thread and not saying anything.

HG15, I have always been more of a lurker on this forum. I have made my defense. If more questions come up, I will answer them when I see them.

Or if my opinion changes or I want to add/refute some other point, I will post then. What is the point of posting just for the sake of posting?

[agulati]

Originally Posted by kermitology

Despite my dislike for HG I think he's just got a bit of proverbial verbal diarrhea going on. He's just so suspicious of everyone.

He did that last game as well. Drives up the paranoia. Not sure if that necessarily means he is the mafia though. He could be the mafia's best unintentional ally.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by agulati

But I would rather wait for Mazrim to weigh in. If transplant doesn't post more or Mazrim doesn't mod-kill him, we should only then lynch him. No point wasting a night kill, if we can get him taken care off by Mazrim.

Let our "mod" also get his hands red. :P

Originally Posted by agulati

Haha brainfart. Most of our lynches happen at night hence I said night kill.

This doesn't add up.

You specifically say we should only lynch him, and you specifically said night kill. If it was a brainfart I would assume you wouldn't have mentioned the lynch and just said night kill.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by agulati

He did that last game as well. Drives up the paranoia. Not sure if that necessarily means he is the mafia though. He could be the mafia's best unintentional ally.

No I didn't. I was gone early last game.

Vote: agulati

[Hockeyguy15]

whoops.

Vote: agulati

[Kjesse]

DEATH POST (Pre-approved by Mazrim)

Hey all, sorry I didn't get to post my analysis before the axe dropped on my head. I was away on the weekend. Here's some tips, the first one had to go:

1. Edited out as per Mazrim.
2. Liars are always Mafia.
3. Calm down. Chaos helps mafia.
4. You can still win this.

Best of luck! This game is more difficult for the town with 2 mafia groups!

Thanks Mazrim for all your hard work!

I'm going to make an edit as I'm only allowed one post: As of posting this, I do not know who mafia is. I'm not giving any hints, just general tips. I thought #1 was general advice but Mazrim didn't this so, that's fine. Don't read too much into this.

[CofR]

I'm really suspicious of HD based on his back and forth with Delgar in the last day.

[strombad]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Well let's hear the proposal?

Same as last time with a few minor additions.

His contribution has been useless, and while I'm admittedly reaching here, he seemed very content on letting us go after townspeople. Never offering any sort of contribution other that "Your theory is weak" when his name came up.

Plus, I've been going after him pretty hard, and let's be honest, if he were town at least a FEW mafia might've jumped on board, you would think right?

Will post more later if needed, but I think we can't go wrong here. I've just got that FEELING.

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by Delgar

DEATH POST (Pre-approved by Mazrim)

Hey all, sorry I didn't get to post my analysis before the axe dropped on my head. I was away on the weekend. Here's some tips, the first one had to go:

1. Edited out as per Mazrim.
2. Liars are always Mafia.
3. Calm down. Chaos helps mafia.
4. You can still win this.

Best of luck! This game is more difficult for the town with 2 mafia groups!

Thanks Mazrim for all your hard work!

Oh man... Now I'm going to wonder what Delgar had to say in post 1 for the rest of the game. Although his "Liars are always mafia" is a good point. Sort of seems like that might apply to agulati based on today's posting.

[Hockeyguy15]

Matt also said vote off the liars, FYI.

[Mazrim]

Nobody is currently in immediate danger of being replaced, but those with less than 10 posts right now should try to get more involved if possible.

I don't want to pressure anyone to post more than they can (real life gets in the way sometimes), but one good content post per day goes a long way to making the game more enjoyable for everyone.

[DropIt]

Wow, I was sure that Transplant wasn't going to last the night. I would have likely voted for him if I wasn't sure that the mafia wasn't going to take care of him for us.

I dont think that attention came off him nearly enough for him to slip through the cracks without red flags. He sits atop my list now, quite the eye opening development after day one.

[kermitology]

So, who appeared to have been caught in a lie?

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by bizaro86

Oh man... Now I'm going to wonder what Delgar had to say in post 1 for the rest of the game. Although his "Liars are always mafia" is a good point. Sort of seems like that might apply to agulati based on today's posting.

So, my post makes a bit less sense now that Delgar has edited. I guess I won't tear out my hair trying to figure out what he knew.

[devo22]

uh, rough night. And "weird" targets IMO, if that makes sense ... not the guys I expected to be targeted. Will have to go back and read their posts carefully.

for now, agulati tops my list of suspects ... might have been an honest mistake for all we know, but "wasting a night kill" just next to "lynch"? IMO that rings all kinds of alarm bells. Plus I still have transplant99 high on my list. Originally I voted for him purely for inactivity and unvoted after he checked in, but his posts leading up to the end of day 1 still seem a bit fishy to me. Generally I have been amazed with the inactive players ... call them out and surprise surprise - suddenly they're here. Just something that we have to remember IMO.