Quote:
Originally Posted by Ashasx
I'd be fine with Barkov at 4, and he probably won't bolt to the KHL since he grew up in Finland.
But he is a poor skater and that worries me at the NHL level. I think he is a clear step below MacKinnon/Drouin/Jones.
|
He gets a rep for his 'poor skating' because it is compared to MacKinnon's. If MacKinnon was playing in the NHL this year, he would be amongst the fastest skaters in the league. There is NOTHING wrong with Barkov's skating - he is average at WORST. He will be fine
It will really be interesting to see if he or MacKinnon end up having the better career. There are both huge pros and cons when comparing the two head-to-head. Barkov is still one of the youngest players in the draft, competing (and EXCELLING) against men already and I think close to or breaking some records for someone his age in Finland... not to mention he is a slick playmaker with excellent vision and super two-way play already.
I am wavering towards MacKinnon myself - just that speed and that motor - but if the Flames pick Barkov if MacKinnon is still on the board, I won't be upset either. Can you imagine having 2 POSSIBLY elite 6'3-6'5 centers on the top two lines? Considering the Flames have invested in Gaudreau and Baertschi - both under the average in the NHL, that makes it kind of formidable.
Either way, if the Flames finish in the bottom 4, I just hope they pick from the 4, including Jones or Drouin. 2 possible elite centers, 1 possible elite winger/center (I believe this is actually Drouin's first year NOT playing center) and an elite defencemen... this team just needs to get elite prospects, period.
I will lose confidence if they go off the board and take Shinkaruk, and to a lesser degree, Monahan or Lindholm.
Hypothetically, say the Flames end up having the first two over-all picks (lottery, trading up, whatever) - do you pick someone like Jones and MacKinnon/Barkov? Do you go for the MacKinnon/Drouin 'proven chemistry' combo? Do you go for the best 2 centers in the draft for depth? Would be an interesting predicament.