CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[Timbo]

Well the hammer cant fall until 10pm tonight (stupid time) I plan to be hammered at 10pm tonight.
I have the hammer vote on Oling as it stands now.

Drury do we still fish or do we cut bait?

[Hockeyguy15]

Just about to head out for the night, but I wanted to let you guys know I have the Eternals invite and they want to give me that Ninja kill they offered Drury earlier. I am keeping the invite till the deadline, so hopefully it doesn't get offered to Oling.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Oh yeah, definitely hang onto that invite. We remember the last time the Eternals gave out a kill. That didn't work out so good for you, did it? Poor Girlysports.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Take it, kill me Hockeyguy15.

I'm mafia, no issues remember? And Eternal kills work on mafia, we saw that with Girlysports. Heck, even if I live we can blame it on me being Godfather.

Oh, unless I show town and then what happens? Drury18 will jump on Diss, Timbo will follow.

Then it's 2v1 heading into the night.

Hopefully some other power comes along so it's not a 1v1 loss but that's not a concern because I'm mafia, remember?

------Dead Post-------

Thanks Maz. You rock.
Good luck guys.

[Drury18]

The hammer sucks for me too as I'm gone tonight as well.

i'm not sure what's left. Watching how Oling is unsure of Diss and willing to jump on something else doesn't give me great confidence. Having his try to manipulate me and control me pretty much sealed his fate for me. You don't gain my trust and help by screwing me over and then giving me ultimatums. Also sounds like a certain invite I got... If he was town, I also figured he would at least have the time to post something to prove a theory with someone else, instead he just keeps taking shots at the town. Few hours have passed, I had time to read the entire thread, figured he would have at least a good case against someone. Instead he goes hard for Diss, says he's unsure then when I mention another name, jumps on them within minutes. Vote stays on Diss though. His case against Diss seems pretty weak too. If there was a Twilight, I would have told Diss to give powers to Pux over me, I figured I Was going instead of her. Finding out he visited her wasn't a surprise for me nor do I see it as an issue.

Oling, the Ninja for HG15 is no good right now. Ninja is a night kill. He couldn't kill you right away anyway. If you were paying attention, I said that earlier.

[Oling_Roachinen]

When are you gone? I would like to post in about an hour some stuff but admittedly nothing ground breaking.

Mostly my case is that diss visit puxlut and came up with a weird reason on how I must of investigated when really it makes a lot of sense that the confirmed townie would be killed.

However, there were 3 unknowns. Girly, who came up with a power that made her too risky to lynch, Aeneas who used his real power and diss who came up with a reason to target townies not once but twice. He also lasted longer than wood despite being unrevealed, why wasn't the mafia afraid he was the cop? Or had some other power.

Also while I did jump on hockey guy, like I said I had already called him and diss as partners in my first post today. I didn't jump on him because of something you said, I jumped on him before you said anything.

[Drury18]

I've gotta be gone by 6 at the latest. Will have my phone but not sure about the internet as the place usually has crap signal any other time I've been there. It's like the freaking Saddledome, you walk around crossing your fingers if something works or not.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Here's the thing when timbo voted for me he knew he had me. 3 votes, hammer.

But he also suggested that me and timbo are working together. Why didn't he consider that timbo would just unvote and vote with me at 9:59. He didn't actually believe we were working together.

That's about all I got. No

[Oling_Roachinen]

My ultimatum to you was also to get across why I was going to take my invite without revealing it to early. Probably stupid but the logic makes sense if you look at it from me being a townie perspective.

[Drury18]

I guess that's where we have to disagree. Ultimatums don't make sense ever. It's kinda insulting to think the only way you think you can convince me of something is to pull that. I've yet to be unreasonable in this game, I've yet to hammer anyone before letting them speak so to think that's the way you have to convince me is a pretty poor excuse.

[Oling_Roachinen]

What are you talking about when you mean ultimatum exactly so we are on the same page? Again, I wasn actually telling you why you had to take the power, I wanted to explain why I had to take the invite. I know I am town and I know things we're going bad so I had no choice. I just didn't want to tell the mafia about my invite until I had to.

[Timbo]

I play a game,a game called why.Please play along.
Why Dissentowner is not Scum
Aeneas post 3886
Aeneas post 3888
Girly post 3894
Girly post 3908

Two confirmed scum trying to set him up. Two! This was 11 days ago in real life time. No way they are playing end game here. No way!

Why is Drury not Scum
Not that he saved my ass but he has a spreadsheet. And his spreadsheet is truthful.

Why is Timbo not Scum

My post of IDing Aeneas and Girly and the opposing power theory. I was right. Again a Two!
Also I believe in myself and my bucket.
starseeds eternal kill did not work

Why is Oling not Scum
He has been outspoken and opinionated.
He has tracking capabilities. We have found Formulate with cop abilities and Aeneas with watcher abilities.

Hockeyguy15
His sword/power thats all I got.

Why is Dissentowner scum?
Possibly poisoned GGG
Possibly killed Puxlut

Why is Drury Scum
Making me his Joe Schmoe?

Why is Oling Scum
Horrible accusations and major monologues against proven town.
Strawman accusations.
Many dead townies have him most wanted
Gaming the game with metagaming (this one is thin admittedly)
Possible bulletproof capabilities.

Why is HG15 scum
Played under the radar majorly IMO
Might have lucked out with starseeds stupid gambit.

I have not come up with anything definitive here but maybe we can come to a conclusion.

At this point Dissentowner holds a good position IMO due to the Aeneas and Girly gang up.

[Timbo]

At this point in the game I am going with Oling and HG15.
Drury/Diss /Myself as good guys.

The question remaining is there 4 Scum or only 3?
and
The fact that the ratio of townie deaths to scum might hold true to only 3.
I am not dismissing that there possibly was 3 Mafia 1 SK 2 Cult leaders. This game and all of its twists and turns could be testament to that.

Right now I am keeping my vote on Oling. I hate that the fate of the town is on my shoulders but someone has to make a decision.
If Drury has his second shot at divine intervention he can use it if he feels different.
Or he can ask me to unvote. Otherwise... Oling I'm sorry if you are town ,really sorry I just think you painted yourself into a corner.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Timbo

At this point Dissentowner holds a good position IMO due to the Aeneas and Girly gang up.

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Vote Dissentowner

That's 6 votes for Diss, don't hammer him yet.

Powers that could very well be anti-town and going after Rathji for having anti-town powers, then Rathji posted his mega post which sealed it for me.

Originally Posted by Mazrim

Vote Count:

With 12 alive, it takes 7 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 4 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (2): Drury18, Aeneas

Voted:
dissentowner (6): GirlySports, GGG, starseed, Timbo, Hockeyguy15
squiggs96 (2): Oling_Roachinen, Rathji
Puxlut (1):
Aeneas (1): Puxlut
Oling_Roachinen (1): squiggs96
starseed (1): dissentowner

The deadline is Tuesday, October 28th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

Careful with that logic Timbo. Those were the votes for diss at the time. Aeneas didn't bring up Dissentowner until the people moved away. The vote was failing for Diss when Aeneas jumped and he used it as a way to make others the targets.

What about these posts (and the couple in between):

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Vote: girlysports

I still think out of my most suspicious players she tops my list. I am also weary of Squiggs, and Rathji. I still think eliminating a night is more beneficial to scum than to the town. There is no benefit to skipping the day as we saw but eliminating all town night actions? Sounds scummy to me. Not entirely sure though so I will go with GS again.

Last on the Girlysports bandwagon

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Uggg. So if we believe you that would give the scum two night kills in a row? Jesus...

Unvote

But first off it after the reveal.

Originally Posted by Timbo

At this point in the game I am going with Oling and HG15.

So, what's stopping us from voting HG15 first? Me, you and Drury18? Heck even Diss can hop on board.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

So, what's stopping us from voting HG15 first? Me, you and Drury18? Heck even Diss can hop on board.

I won't vacillate now unless I get word from Drury. Epic win or epic loss lets see what the river holds.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Timbo

Why is Dissentowner scum?
Possibly poisoned GGG
Possibly killed Puxlut
Was not killed despite still having the possibility of being the cop (instead the mafia killed Wood)
Was the last to reveal his power
Still has not been killed despite his power being very scary for the mafia
Last on the Girlysports bandwagon but the first off
About as many bad accusations as everyone else

Added my thoughts.

[Mazrim]

Vote Count:

With 5 alive, it takes 3 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 2 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (1): Drury18

Voted:
Oling_Roachinen (3): dissentowner, Hockeyguy15, Timbo
dissentowner (2): Oling_Roachinen

The deadline is Tuesday, November 11th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time. Hammer cannot be dropped before Friday, November 7th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Timbo

I won't vacillate now unless I get word from Drury. Epic win or epic loss lets see what the river holds.

Let's not use words that I have to look up on a Friday night here.

Timbo, you lied about the cop. The only good lie in this game I believe as you made the mafia think there was a cop even after formulate died. I think it was very smart.

So, why do you think that Aeneas, Girlysports and I guess myself (but in actuality the real other mafia members) did not kill him when he was the last unrevealed power at the time (with Aeneas and Girlysports)? Instead they killed Wood, a townie that had no powers left.

Seems to me they knew he wasn't cop, seems to me they would have been working with Diss. On that day they went against each other, there was so much mess. Wood had already said in the Twilight the previous day, right before dieing, that his targets were Aeneas, Girlysports and Dissentowner. They had to distance themselves. They needed an excuse to say "I can't be working with Girlysports, see I voted for her here."

Originally Posted by Drury18

Twilight Day 6

Wood - Says he's constantly on Squiggs96 because of numbers. If there is a 4 person mafia, he has to be included. Starting to look like there might not be a mafia now. Prefers to target Girly, Aeneas and Diss before Squiggs. Appreciates the protection, but doesn't understand why Squiggs would protect him over ECF.

[Oling_Roachinen]

I wonder what the chances are Wood is bashing his head against the door saying "I told you my list right before they killed me, I'm right on 2/2 why not make it 3/3."

Haha :P