CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Drury18

It looks like the non-voters through the entirety of Day 1 are:

hmmhmmcamo
RatherDashing

Ok, so we know RD's story. hmmhmmcamo, want to tell us why you are just sitting back and never voting?

[Kjesse]

Unvote

Vote: RatherDashing

[Drury18]

To add to that (as I was searching posts in the thread and ended up finding this while trying to see if he voted) hmmhmmcamo has also suggested two things:

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

Someone uses a random number generator and a camera phone to video themself... post it to YouTube for all to see and determine if it's legit. easy peasy.

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

What about if we just don’t kill anyone on day one?

Based on the limited/zero knowledge we actually have right now, we’re most likely to pick off a town regardless of who we choose.

So why not keep our numbers higher and see what the first night brings us?

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Drury18

To add to that (as I was searching posts in the thread and ended up finding this while trying to see if he voted) hmmhmmcamo has also suggested two things:

Yeah, that seems pretty damn fishy to me. Guys posts that and then disappears like a fart in the wind.

[East Coast Flame]

I agree with everyone else. One of GP or RD needs to go, as it would tell us the same thing and we might as well keep the one who is actually posting.

Unvote

Vote: RatherDashing

[Kjesse]

Let me post my reasons for going to RatherDashing but not GP_Matt:

-GP_Matt has denied knowing RD's role/alignment
-GP_Matt has posted enough that over the next few game days we'll find out how sincere is really is being-- he's said enough to potentially hang himself
-The voting intentions for squiggs has been soft so far, I don't see support developing there (at least yet)
-RD hasn't contributed one iota to this game. That by itself is reason enough given the time that has passed. We know nothing about him.

[dissentowner]

Hey guys, before we hit the hammer on RD we should get GP's vote for him in. I suppose if they are both scum they might be willing to sacrifice one for the cause but he said he would be willing to cast that vote and with the suspicion surrounding him and RD I want to make sure he doesn't just say he will and then lie in the weeds.

[Kjesse]

I didn't see Wood's vote until now, but yes Wood has voted.

We're at 6 for RD.

Frankly I see no reason waiting, lets see who jumps on the train, that will tell us something eventually. I don't really care if GP_Matt jumps on or not, we have enough input from him at this time.

[GP_Matt]

unvote

Vote: Rather Dashing

[East Coast Flame]

Originally Posted by GP_Matt

unvote

Vote: Rather Dashing

Daaaaaaaaaaamn. That's cold blooded

[GP_Matt]

The only issue with lynching Rather Dashing (aside from the friendship which was waning anyway, he didn't even invite me on his climbing trip) is that he has indicated that he won't be able to post until possibly tonight. By that point he will be lynched and unable to speak. If he is the cop or doctor or something important it would be a shame to kill him before he has a chance to redeem himself.
It might be better to keep him planned for tomorrows lynch instead.

[GP_Matt]

Originally Posted by East Coast Flame

Daaaaaaaaaaamn. That's cold blooded

Christmas is going to be awkward this year.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by GP_Matt

unvote

Vote: Rather Dashing

This bothers me slightly, but it could be a clever ruse while they make a plan?

unvote

vote: ratherdashing

[dissentowner]

Well, I see no reason to go against the masses. It is early.

Unvote
Vote: Rather Dashing

[East Coast Flame]

Originally Posted by GP_Matt

The only issue with lynching Rather Dashing (aside from the friendship which was waning anyway, he didn't even invite me on his climbing trip) is that he has indicated that he won't be able to post until possibly tonight. By that point he will be lynched and unable to speak. If he is the cop or doctor or something important it would be a shame to kill him before he has a chance to redeem himself.
It might be better to keep him planned for tomorrows lynch instead.

Deadline is tonight.

While I think that's fair, we are kind of running out of time.

[Oling_Roachinen]

I think we got 9 votes for RatherDashing. It may make sense to hold up on the voting now and give him a final say rather than going for the hammer.

[GP_Matt]

Originally Posted by East Coast Flame

Deadline is tonight.

While I think that's fair, we are kind of running out of time.

I meant tomorrow in the mafia sense. Lynch someone else today and him tomorrow.

[East Coast Flame]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

I think we got 9 votes for RatherDashing. It may make sense to hold up on the voting now and give him a final say rather than going for the hammer.

So we wait until tonight, and then what? He says something and gives the opportunity for scum to jump off and then we sitting there with our thumb up our asses and aren't able to regroup and vote for someone else before the deadline.

[hmmhmmcamo]

haha fart in the wind. I've been following along but didn't get a chance to get online until last night and at that point we were all waiting for GP Matt to respond. I found it odd that Matt and RD both responded this morning so close together after being mia for so long.

If the consensus is to vote out either Matt or RD, I'd lean towards RD as he mentioned he's out of town for the next few days and won't be able to post much anyway.

Vote: RatherDashing

[devo22]

man, re-reading hmmhmmcamo's posts coupled with his sudden disappearance makes me actually want to vote for the guy, but I guess it's too late for it to gain traction at this point ... but he's the first name on my suspicion list for day 2

if I've counted everything correctly, we are at 9 votes for RD and down to 7 for Matt. I'll go to bed in 2-3 hours - I'll change my vote from Matt to RD at this point unless RD comes forward with something useful until then.