[Trade] Leafs acquire Brandon Carlo (15% retained) for Minten, 1st, 4th

[Erick Estrada]

Originally Posted by Jason14h

How do we get Nylander out of Toronto !

Do the Flames need another winger and one with Leafs stink on him? Any big ticket acquisition fort this team needs to play center.

[Jason14h]

Originally Posted by Erick Estrada

Do the Flames need another winger and one with Leafs stink on him? Any big ticket acquisition fort this team needs to play center.

The thing is the leafs might try to rebiggle which leaves them open to making a huge mistake in a trade

That’s why if you can get nylander in a win now deal from them you go for it

If we could structure a trade around Weegar and a winger you jump all over it IMO

I wouldn’t give up futures but I suspect that won’t be what the Leafs would be looking for

And yes we have a lot of wingers - they just aren’t very good or old / soon to be gone

[Tbull8]

Why would they give up Nylander in a win now? If anything they may deal Danford/Cowan/Future 1sts in an overpay

[cam_calderon]

Willy's been good in the playoffs, when he isn't watching from home because of a headache.

[Gaudreau is a Ninja]

So has this trade even gone down? I don’t see anyone talking about it? Radio or television

[IamNotKenKing]

Originally Posted by Gaudreau is a Ninja

So has this trade even gone down? I don’t see anyone talking about it? Radio or television

Yes, yes it did...

https://www.nhl.com/news/boston-brui...to-maple-leafs

[cam_wmh]

Originally Posted by Gaudreau is a Ninja

So has this trade even gone down? I don’t see anyone talking about it? Radio or television

This is ongoing conversation from last March 2025.

[Gaudreau is a Ninja]

Originally Posted by cam_wmh

This is ongoing conversation from last March 2025.

lol my bad

[Royle9]

LOL that made my day.

[Gaudreau is a Ninja]

Originally Posted by Royle9

LOL that made my day.

Glad I could bring a smile to your face

[activeStick]

Out here in Toronto, fans and the media are starting to slowly turn on Treliving. The chatter here is around:

- Not much blame on Marner given Tre came in a few weeks before. Gets a pass in Marner leaving the Leafs.

- Nobody thought they'd finish higher in the standings since Tre didn't replace Marner, but most figured they'd make the playoffs as a more gritty wild card seed and were hopeful the team would find more success despite losing the offense.

- Most were happy at the time of the Carlo deal, but in hindsight, obviously pretty much unanimously hate it now given how things have turned out. Minten's performance in Boston has surprised everyone and the 1st twists the knife.

- More and more mentions of how Treliving left the Flames and Calgary's current situation.

- Most support a re-tool and some want to tear it down. More and more of the media and fanbase are thinking that Treliving will be let go if the Leafs miss the playoffs.

[Mitch]

Treliving only locked Matthews into a 4 year deal too. With their current trajectory, theres no way he re-signs at the end of that contract.

[Locke]

Originally Posted by Mitch

Treliving only locked Matthews into a 4 year deal too. With their current trajectory, theres no way he re-signs at the end of that contract.

As much as I like to dunk on the Wizard, everything I've read makes me believe that the 4-year deal for Matthews was entirely the idea of the Matthews camp. He was never going to sign for longer no matter what Treliving did.

[SuperMatt18]

Yeah he's never signed long term deals - that wasn't changing this time around.

And TBH outside of last deadline he hasn't made too many major moves but the mistakes Treliving has made in Toronto, are the same mistakes he made here, he continually spends too many assets on non-premium pieces.

Laughton for Grebenkin + 1st
Carlo for Minten, 1st
Edmunson for 3rd + 5th
Lybushkin for 3rd +_6th

2 1sts
2 3rds
Minten
Grebenkin
5th
6th

And all he has to show for that right now are Laughton and Carlo.

If he were to package that all up last year and offer a team 2 1sts, Minten, and Grebenkin he could have probably acquired a star level player.

But he continually struggles to close the big deals, but then spends all those assets on players that don't provide any real positive impact.

Combine that with letting Marner walk, and Matthews injuries really making him a player not nearly as effective as he once was, and now you have a team that is lacking depth offensively, still isn't strong defensively, and has no assets or cap space to try to fix the problem.

[Yeah_Baby]

Originally Posted by Gaudreau is a Ninja

So has this trade even gone down? I don’t see anyone talking about it? Radio or television

lol

[VilleN]

Originally Posted by Locke

As much as I like to dunk on the Wizard, everything I've read makes me believe that the 4-year deal for Matthews was entirely the idea of the Matthews camp. He was never going to sign for longer no matter what Treliving did.

I agree. Matthews only signs shorter term deals to maximize earnings. Pretty smart move, although it carries some risk. Matthews doesn't seem like a guy who cares much about team performance or winning though, seems more like he's concerned with dollars than anything else.

[Vinny01]

Minten on pace for 43pts

[Calgary4LIfe]

Originally Posted by Vinny01

Minten on pace for 43pts

I can imagine Treliving's jaw wide-open in horror.

[robertsfanatic]

the pick is only top 5 protected????? oh man, this might get really ugly.

[FireGilbert]

Caught the end of the Leafs Kraken game just in time to see multiple horrible give aways hand Seattle a two goal lead and then a minute later Carlo took a stupid penalty.

Treliving was seemingly brought into to change the Leafs from a one dimensional offensive team to a more well rounded playoff style team, yet the Leafs now sit 3rd worst in the league in goals against.