We used a guy that used to be with Foothills before they went under and has now started his own business:
https://www.kenlyr.com
He's done a two story addition for us, and another one story addition of a boot room. He also did some work for other family to add to their garage (shown in his portfolio).
Pros:
- He's never left any issues unresolved and keeps showing up even after the job is "done".
- He's fairly honest about schedule, some places were hopelessly optimistic
- He was under his quote by a decent amount every time
Cons:
- Pricing will be high compared to others, but again, he starts from a spot with room to limit debilitating surprises. Our house is 115 years old, so this was helpful to say the least
- He's a one man show on the project management front, if he's sick or on vacation, things will slow down