Flames player fan poll (August 2023)

[Always Earned Never Given]

- Jonathan Huberdeau 8
- Nazem Kadri 5
- Jacob Markstrom 6
- Rasmus Andersson 8
- Mackenzie Weegar 8
- Lanny McDonald 10
- Theo Fleury 5
- Johnny Gaudreau 5
- Matthew Tkachuk 5
- Matt Stajan 10 for his GWG vs Van
- Martin " the terminator/ it was in "Gelinas 12
- Players that were on the ice in 2004 for "THE SHIFT" 15

[Lanny_McDonald]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 8
- Nazem Kadri - 2
- Jacob Markstrom - 1
- Rasmus Andersson - 8
- Mackenzie Weegar - 8
- Lanny McDonald - 11
- Theo Fleury - 0
- Johnny Gaudreau - 9
- Matthew Tkachuk - 8
- Elias Lindholm - 8

Bonus Management Round

- Craig Conroy - 6
- Brad Treliving - 0
- Brian Burke - 2
- Jay Feaster - 6
- Darryl Sutter - 2
- Craig Button - 0
- Doug Risebrough - 4
- Cliff Fletcher - 8

[ForeverFlameFan]

- Jonathan Huberdeau --> 5, need to see some consistency. Too early to tell.
- Nazem Kadri --> 5, too early to tell x2. Easily a 8-10 if his GAF meter is always working.
- Jacob Markstrom --> 2, just never been a fan of him.
- Rasmus Andersson --> 8 - Solid stud in the making and can see him a Flame for life
- Mackenzie Weegar --> 10 - favorite player on the Flames right now
- Lanny McDonald --> 10, iconic Flame
- Theo Fleury --> 8, despite everything going on with him he's a great Flame.
- Johnny Gaudreau --> 7, still like the player but dropped because not a Flame.
- Matthew Tkachuk --> 8, same reasoning as Gaudreau
- Chosen Player: Connor McDavid - 5, would be a 10 if he wasn't an Oiler.

Iginla - 15, breaks the scale. Anything involving Iginla is a huge plus. There will never be a player in a Flames sweater that will surpass this guy for me.

[RyZ]

- Jonathan Huberdeau 7
- Nazem Kadri 6
- Jacob Markstrom 7
- Rasmus Andersson 8
- Mackenzie Weegar 7
- Lanny McDonald 9
- Theo Fleury 8
- Johnny Gaudreau 2
- Matthew Tkachuk 5

[TrentCrimmIndependent]

Originally Posted by FireItUp

There are only 2 reasons why Flames fans aren't giving Theo a decent rating...

1) You never really liked him as a player.
2) You usually vote either NDP or Liberal and dislike those who have different political views.

Judging by your comment...we know why you gave him a 0.

Yeah, I'm gonna go with unhinged lunatic post-career.

Tough and skilled SOB during his career, which is why people liked him *then*.

It's not a simple matter of just disagreeing about politics. Guy has lost his grip on reality. There are plenty of right wingers that look completely sane and rational in comparison to present day Theo.

Also
"this post is terrible"

[tvp2003]

Originally Posted by Cali Panthers Fan

Honest question, is someone going to tally up the average score for each player at the end of this?

It wasn’t the original plan but it seems like a sensible thing to do.

I was more curious about doing the poll again at the end of the year to see if/how the numbers had shifted. I’m pretty sure if you did this poll in August of 2022 a lot of numbers would be different.

[Icon]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 7
- Nazem Kadri - 5
- Jacob Markstrom - 3
- Rasmus Andersson - 8
- Mackenzie Weegar - 8
- Lanny McDonald - 10
- Theo Fleury - 5
- Johnny Gaudreau - 3
- Matthew Tkachuk - 7
- HONZ - 10

[IceBergYYC]

- Jonathan Huberdeau 7
- Nazem Kadri 5
- Jacob Markstrom 7
- Rasmus Andersson 9
- Mackenzie Weegar 8
- Lanny McDonald 10 (as a player and as a man)
- Theo Fleury 8 (as a player, like a 4 as a man)
- Johnny Gaudreau 2
- Matthew Tkachuk 4
- Dustin Wolf 10

[hixxes]

All judged on their time as players with the Flames

- Jonathan Huberdeau 3
- Nazem Kadri 1
- Jacob Markstrom 5
- Rasmus Andersson 6
- Mackenzie Weegar 6
- Lanny McDonald 10
- Theo Fleury 10
- Johnny Gaudreau 7
- Matthew Tkachuk 8
- Al MacInnis 10

[Pepper2489]

- Jonathan Huberdeau 7
- Nazem Kadri 6
- Jacob Markstrom 5
- Rasmus Andersson 7
- Mackenzie Weegar 7
- Lanny McDonald 9
- Theo Fleury 9
- Johnny Gaudreau 2
- Matthew Tkachuk 4
-Iginla 9
-Backlund 5

[tvp2003]

Unofficial results for August 2023:

- Jonathan Huberdeau 6.57
- Nazem Kadri 5.14
- Jacob Markstrom 5.36
- Rasmus Andersson 7.86
- Mackenzie Weegar 7.86
- Lanny McDonald 8.84
- Theo Fleury 5.31
- Johnny Gaudreau 6.33
- Matthew Tkachuk 6.64

Sample size was 51. I excluded any votes (just for that player, not the entire ballot) that did not have a number, had more than one number, or a number outside of 1 to 10 (Gaudreau escaped a couple of “0” votes as a result).

Most obscure write in answer was BeltlineFan who picked Lynn Loyns (and gave home an 8!).

We’ll see if I remember to administer this poll again at the end of the season, will maybe add a few players as well. Thanks for participating.

[GioforPM]

Calling what Fleury thinks and does "different political opinions" is like calling a Hannibal Lecter a guy with "different dietary preferences".

[wired]

- Jonathan Huberdeau-7.5
- Nazem Kadri- 7
- Jacob Markstrom- 6.5
- Rasmus Andersson- 8.5
- Mackenzie Weegar- 9
- Lanny McDonald- 9
- Theo Fleury-6.5
- Johnny Gaudreau- 5
- Matthew Tkachuk- 5
- ___Stéphane Yelle- 8.5________


My take as a fan of this team

[14Roman14]

Jonathan Huberdeau 9
- Nazem Kadri 7
- Jacob Markstrom 8
- Rasmus Andersson 8
- Mackenzie Weegar 9
- Lanny McDonald 10
- Theo Fleury 10
- Johnny Gaudreau 3
- Matthew Tkachuk 4
- Rick Tabaracci 10

[N-E-B]

Jonathan Huberdeau 7
- Nazem Kadri 5
- Jacob Markstrom 7
- Rasmus Andersson 9
- Mackenzie Weegar 8
- Lanny McDonald 5
- Theo Fleury 5
- Johnny Gaudreau 0
- Matthew Tkachuk 0

I don’t get how anyone could still be a fan of Gaudreau or Tkachuk.

[TheIronMaiden]

Jonathan Huberdeau 3
- Nazem Kadri 3
- Jacob Markstrom 7
- Rasmus Andersson 9
- Mackenzie Weegar 8
- Lanny McDonald 7
- Theo Fleury 4
- Johnny Gaudreau 0
- Matthew Tkachuk 0
- Sean Monahan - 10

[Redlan]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 8
- Nazem Kadri - 7
- Jacob Markstrom - 6
- Rasmus Andersson - 7
- Mackenzie Weegar - 8
- Lanny McDonald - 10
- Theo Fleury - 9
- Johnny Gaudreau - 6
- Matthew Tkachuk - 4
- Gary Roberts - 10

Considering what Fleury had to overcome with the sexual abuse at the age of 15/16 from Graham James, he gets a free pass on his social media posts. He is a true survivor, a Stanley Cup Champion and was a treat to watch. It is shameful that people are judging him on his social media opinions.

Were is Fleury in Flames Career Leaders (listing top 3 only)? : 2nd in Goals, 3rd in Assists, 2nd in Points, 2nd in Goals Created, 2nd in Even Strength Goals, 3rd in Power Play Goals, 1st in Short Handed Goals, 2nd in Game Winning Goals, 3rd in Shots, and 2nd in Hat Tricks.

[Radio]

- Jonathan Huberdeau...8
- Nazem Kadri...7
- Jacob Markstrom...6
- Rasmus Andersson...8
- Mackenzie Weegar...8.5
- Lanny McDonald...9
- Theo Fleury...8
- Johnny Gaudreau...8
- Matthew Tkachuk...9
- Jarome Iginla...10

[I_H8_Crawford]

- Jonathan Huberdeau - 7
- Nazem Kadri - 6
- Jacob Markstrom - 1
- Rasmus Andersson - 7
- Mackenzie Weegar - 8
- Lanny McDonald - 8
- Theo Fleury - 1
- Johnny Gaudreau - 6
- Matthew Tkachuk - 6
- Hakan Loob - 10

[activeStick]

Awesome to see that former Flame and CP favorite, Sean Monahan is feeling 100%.

https://twitter.com/user/status/1690878565066104832