Quote:
Originally Posted by combustiblefuel
Nothing to see here refers to it really is no different than every other virus. You and I just need to make sure we don't visit out vulnerable family members for a month as the virus take up to 14 days to incubate and if you show symptoms another 12 to 15 days to be clean. Talk to them on the phone for a month or so and be sfe after that your probably good. Of tour worried at putting tour "at risk " family members in danger just wait a month or so to see them.
|
This action you suggest makes it very different than every and any other virus.
In flu season, do you take these actions?
During H1N1, did you take these actions?
During SARS, did you take these actions?
I think the answer to all of these is no, thus this is very, very different.
There is a test in law for an interlocutory injunction. Incredibly overly simplified, the key part of the test is what is the better wrong decision, in regard to irreparable harm.
Here:
Get rid of the two "correct" decisions in the test. Meaning, shut down saves lives which would have been lost, and no shut down occurs and no lives are lost.
Then analyse the two "wrong" decisons.
Wrong decision one: We overreact and shut down leagues and cities, there is no large spread, and there would not have been one had we not invoked the shut down.
That outcome is good, and any harm is repairable.
Wrong decision two: We do nothing, there is a massive spread, with thousands and thousands of deaths.
That outcome is terrible, and any harm is completely irreparable as people are dead.
The decision is, and should be, easy.