Quote:
Originally Posted by CGY12
Disagree, I think AA has top 6 ability (skill and speed) and will provide them the legit winger they've been looking for to flank McDavid. I've been big on him for the last couple years but I get the narrative of the board when it comes to the Oilers.
|
I was interested in him as well - he checked a box (speed). However, any points he gets have McDavid inflation on them (see Maroon, Chiasson, Neal, Kassian...). AA has speed for sure. He is also apparently a horrible defensive player, and that's also on brand for the Oilers.
He's a RFA with arbitration rights. They will overpay. he will settle into a mediocre player. There's a reason Detroit marketed him over the many other RFAs they have to sign.
I happen to think he won't mesh that well with McDavid. He likes to race down the wing with the puck - that's McDavid's job. He has tunnel vision and doesn't seem to use linemates much. McDavid needs a guy who can din open ice, settle into a spot and finish what McDavid starts. Ennis has a much better chance of sticking on a line with McDavid IMO.
My overall point, however, is that there's only one puck and, if AA gets 20 on a line with McDavid, how's that different than Chiasson getting 20 on a line with McDavid in 2018-19? Or Kassian having 15 this year?