[GT] Surge was discontinued in 2003

[Duffalufagus]

Originally Posted by The Yen Man

Uh, I suggest you watch the actual slow mo replay and think again. He only tagged up after the puck was already brought in by the Canes guy.

He didn’t “bring it in”. He chipped it in and guy in the middle tagged.

[browna]

And let's not let Rittich off the books for a simply putrid 2nd goal.

[dieHARDflameZ]

LOL Sportsnet not even playing the replay long enough to see McGinn supposedly tag up.

[Samonadreau]

Ya it was onside. I didnt understand how nobody could see that.

[Macindoc]

Now the NHL war room is making stuff up to justify its incompetent and/or biased officiating? And they’ve even told Burke to spout a bunch of nonsense? The pre-post Wideman numbers don’t lie. This is not to say that it’s intentional or a conspiracy, but it’s equally true that other teams get the benefit of questionable calls much more than the Flames. And the league knows it or wouldn’t be making stuff up to cover its collective ass.

[GioforPM]

Are they now saying Gauthier didn’t have control of the puck before the tag up? Because he did. He chips in, he’s the only guy with the puck. Just because it wasn’t on his stick 100% of the time doesn’t mean he doesn’t have possession.

[flamingred89]

Wow. That actually is the right call. Good on the posters who went full “12 angry men” and stuck to their guns.

[dino7c]

That isn't a dump in

[GirlySports]

Why are we blaming Janko?

If I saw the puck come out of the zone I'd bolt too.

[TheScorpion]

After looking at those other angles man I think I was wrong. I think it's a good call. Really really close though.

[Duffalufagus]

Originally Posted by Harry Lime

Carolina had control going across the line, meaning that it is an instantaneous call. You can't tag up in this situation.

Not sure what you mean? The puck was not on his stick. He chipped it in.

[Haplo]

Onside/offside depends on if you see the Canes player as in control of the puck or not.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

What the frack are you talking about Burke!!!!

I still think he is wrong because it is pretty obvious that touches his skate as it is coming in. Regardless it is still offside because the Canes player starts the initiation of the puck coming back in before the tag up. It is offside.

[burn_this_city]

Lol Dougie

[foshizzle11]

Originally Posted by AC

https://streamable.com/aybma

I'm at the game so this is the first good look I've had but the Cane that brings it back in doesn't actually touch the puck inside the zone until after the 2nd player tagged up. Looks good to me unfortunately.

When he smacks the puck back in, its a delayed offside but they don't touch it until both players tagged up. That's a good call.

Unfortunately you are right, this was onside. Nuts, I was convinced it was offside.

[N-E-B]

Whether it was a blown call or not it doesn’t change the fact that this should be the last NHL game Janko plays.

[AC]

Originally Posted by The Yen Man

Uh, I suggest you watch the actual slow mo replay and think again. He only tagged up after the puck was already brought in by the Canes guy.

It doesn't matter that he's offside when the puck re-enters the zone, it only matters when a Hurricane touches the puck inside the zone, which occurs after both players had tagged up.

[RM14]

[Manhattanboy]

Whatever. Win streak is now on the line. Flames need to bring everything in the third. Just go for broke.

[Joborule]

Dougie 'ladies man' Hamilton with his shirt off as usual.