Calgarypuck Mafia Game Thread

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by devo22

if GGG knows that he goes down, who would we want to be nightkilled? It's the confirmed townies, but it's also the strong players. So diss and Fuzz, sure. Would if I were GGG and was saddled with someone else but HG15, I'd want him to go down right after them. And finally there's the day 6 lynch. It's not the biggest argument because it was such a hectic last minute lynch again, but the fact still stands that he killed off a user that he thought was town. mrkajz44s last post gives us this:


and the answer, if HG is mafia, is pretty simple - Puxlut threatened to unvote if it was going to be a tie. Then HG would have been gone.

GGG was dead on day 2, he would have had no input on how the game went after his banning.

That quote from mrjakz was at 9:59, I had no time to address it before the 10pm cut off.

I either vote for some one that has done questionable things or someone that has laid low. Do I vote for a conspiracy theory or logic? I'm torn When people throw my name in the mix, I'm not super mad because at least they are looking at all options, trying to dig out the Oiler... instead of just piling on someone for self-preservation.

[devo22]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

I appreciate devo's summary, but I wanted to also look at devo...

and you should. Keep digging. Re-reading the thread is a big task but there's no other way for town to win this game.

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

GGG was dead on day 2, he would have had no input on how the game went after his banning.

yeah, but I'm sure that GGG, if he's resigned to his fate, would tell the last Oiler "I'd go and kill x, y and z" ... especially if the last Oiler is a rather inexperienced player. And I'm sure your name would be high on that list.

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

That quote from mrjakz was at 9:59, I had no time to address it before the 10pm cut off.

yep, and that's why I said it's "not the biggest argument". I really don't like those late minute scrambles, but it is what it is. Still, you did lynch Scorn despite claiming you think he's town.

[Hockeyguy15]

Day 2

Post #401 by puxlut there is a part where she wonders about the bizaro night kill and says he liked her post #355 and maybe there is something the Oilers thought she was onto. Her post said "If you take the three that have been voted for out of the vote count, we would have a 3 way tie". I don't see the point here, she could be trying to look like she is helping.

Interesting to note that when people are bringing things up about GGG he replies to them, trying to defend himself but he does not engage Devo.

Post #425 puxlut gives her list of people with no reasons and will follow up later. She never does.

I've already brought up some things about devo in my other posts, I didn't add it again.

Day 3

Post #528 puxlut gives another list but still gives no reasons for it.

Post #616 at 9:54 puxlut votes mrkajz, doens't give any reasoning until post #622 at 11:01. One of the reasons being he suggested I be investigated by the mod as trying to pull the mod away from GGG. GGG was clearly the one getting banned at that point, so I don't know why this is an arguement for her.

Post #624 puxlut saying how funny it would be if diss was the mod and fuzz was actually an Oiler. Except we would see that on the card flip.

[devo22]

no posts for a few hours, that's disappointing. I'll be around for another hour or so, so if you want to ask me anything else, hit me.

[Hockeyguy15]

I had to leave work, won’t be able to do more posting until later you’ll likely be asleep by then. Sorry, not the ideal way to end it.

Originally Posted by devo22

no posts for a few hours, that's disappointing. I'll be around for another hour or so, so if you want to ask me anything else, hit me.

Just make sure you vote before you go to sleep

It's the 10th hour and all of a sudden HG brings up suspicions about me? This is after I say that he's at the top of my list? Weird. Going to take a little bit and read through his posts and WF's posts while the kidlet is at a friends house.

[devo22]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I had to leave work, won’t be able to do more posting until later you’ll likely be asleep by then. Sorry, not the ideal way to end it.

you know what really grinds my gears? That I really do think you're the Oiler. Not in a 100% kind of fashion, it's rather something like 65%-35% between you and Pux and I'm comfortable enough with my vote. But it kind of pisses me off because, in comparison to the other two that are left, you really were active this last day, you did a lot of re-reading, you put the time in. You don't "deserve" my vote, if you know what I mean. I wish Pux and WF had done the same thing as you did in terms of putting the work in. But at the same time, I do think they are probably town.

if I'm wrong about this and we lose - sorry, Flames fans. I tried!

[devo22]

vote: Hockeyguy15

Was trying to look at posts, but it only shows the last 100 posts so I have to flip through a bazillion posts to see the beginning of HG and WF's posts. It just messes with the continuity of a single persons posts.

WF: If we hadn't of teamed up to vote scorn off, who would have you voted for that day?

[WinnipegFan]

Pux: I was ok letting HG go through. To me it’s you or him.

[WinnipegFan]

Didn’t mean for the last day to be this silent but my family needs me the last two days. I apologize, but it takes priority. I’ll get a vote in still.

I've gotten through the first third of the posts and my head hurts.
I'm putting my money on HG right now. I have to take a break. I'm not doing much tonight, so will be around.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

Just make sure you vote before you go to sleep

It's the 10th hour and all of a sudden HG brings up suspicions about me? This is after I say that he's at the top of my list? Weird. Going to take a little bit and read through his posts and WF's posts while the kidlet is at a friends house.

Sorry for being MIA.

It had nothing to do with you, devo accused me of tunnel vision so I went and reread while trying to not have tunnel vision. Those are the posts that stood out for me.

Having said all that I still feel like devo kept a low profile and never really actively banned anyone and did just enough to stay out of the target. Winnipegfan has 22 more posts than him.

I’ve posted enough about him, I’m on my phone so going back and finding more is tough. I’ll answer any questions you have though.

[Hockeyguy15]

Vote: devo22

[Hockeyguy15]

Hard to believe GGG almost has more posts than devo.

Sorry... got tied up with family stuff I can't actively hunt, but can pop in and read.
This time was incredibly harder. my kid is older and needs more time and I work more than other times I've played this. Sorry I couldn't play as hard as people wanted me to. Good luck Flames. Fingers crossed.

Vote Hockeyguy15

WF you can hammer or there could be some last minute dialogue... but I don't think I will change my vote.