[PGT] Flames 6 Jets 3

[Coach]

Originally Posted by Erick Estrada

Maurice makes it sound like it's the first time he's ever seen an official change his call after consulting with the other official and linesmen. It's likely one official just saw the aftermath and called it a goal while the other saw the interference beforehand and told him to which they changed the call to no goal. That's why the officials get together to consult when one of them sees something the other may not have or had a better view.

Sounded more to me like he thought since they wavered on the initial call, that there was room enough for doubt to make them losing their time out worth them taking an extra look to decide.

The rule does seem to state it will be ruled no goal if the contact is in the crease. It does NOT however say it is to be ruled a goal if contact takes place out of the crease.

I feel like we got burned on this technicality before very recently, no?

[You Need a Thneed]

If I were a Jets fan, I would have been supportive of trying the challenge there, even if you are likely to lose. There’s enough inconsistency in judgements to give it a shot. It’s an important potential goal, and just costs your timeout if you lose.

Based on the rule posted above though, there really is no chance of that being overturned.

[Rollin22x]

Without a review, this doesn't appear intentional. When you have the review I would say it was intentional. Trouba makes contact with DR and doesn't look back at all.
I would think he would glance back to see if it was accidental. He just keeps skating and hopes no one noticed and probably hoping the defensemen beside him causes some second guessing.

[sureLoss]

https://twitter.com/user/status/1065733691266162690

[Enoch Root]

Originally Posted by Scroopy Noopers

Well the second one is which is why I included it. They clipped skates, accidentally.

The refs called no goal due to goalie interference, and no penalty. I posted the rule that fits with that decision, which is what they used. So they deemed Rittich to be “in the crease”. If they hadn’t, they would have called a penalty or called it a good goal. There is a table of situations in the rule book.

They didn't 'clip skates'. Rittich was standing still. Trouba skated by and his skate (accidentally) slew-footed Rittch (for lack of a better word).

[White Out 403]

I thought it was a good coaches challenge. Maurice's comments were basically because the call on the ice was changed it was a reasonable gamble to make. He wasn't upset they did it or making a beef, just providing reason for the challenge

Originally Posted by sureLoss

https://twitter.com/user/status/1065733691266162690

Oh yeah. I'm sure Buff is still quaking in his boots

[Enoch Root]

Originally Posted by Canada 02

excerpt from Rule 69.1
Incidental contact with a goalkeeper will be permitted, and resulting goals allowed, when such contact is initiated outside of the goal crease, provided the attacking player has made a reasonable effort to avoid such contact.

I assume, the ref determined that Trouba did not try to avoid contact

End of discussion. Trouba made no effort to avoid Rittich. And the contact with Rittich's skate resulted in him falling down and being unable to make a save.

[Enoch Root]

Regarding Maurice: absolutely he should challenge there. If I'm a Jets fan and he doesn't, I'm livid. It wasn't likely to get overturned (IMO), but when the refs confer and then change their call, and it's a potential goal that gets you back in the game, you HAVE to challenge. Nothing to lose, everything to gain.

[Erick Estrada]

Originally Posted by White Out 403

I thought it was a good coaches challenge. Maurice's comments were basically because the call on the ice was changed it was a reasonable gamble to make. He wasn't upset they did it or making a beef, just providing reason for the challenge



Oh yeah. I'm sure Buff is still quaking in his boots

If he wasn't so busy picking pucks out of his net last night maybe Buff would have had some energy to take Rittich's challenge. I see at HF last night you call the Flames a "bubble team". What does that make the Jets seeing they are behind the Flames in the standings?

[White Out 403]

Originally Posted by Erick Estrada

...

edit: Actually I'm not going to cross debate between forums. If you want to come argue with me about my posts I make on the Jets section of HF, I invite you to come on over. But there's a reason I don't post certain things here: I am a guest away fan and don't want to crap on the local team to invite fights.

[PegCityFlamesFan]

Originally Posted by Textcritic

The biggest difference being that unlike Winnipeg—which is no good, Calgary is actually very good.

That's been pretty evident these past few seasons, but troll away.

[foshizzle11]

It is such a crap shoot sometimes with these refs and the decisions they make about these kinds of things. I get what Maurice is saying but Rittich doesn’t go down and that puck doesn’t go in if he isn’t touched by the Jets player. Accidental or not, you can’t call that a good goal and I’m glad they didn’t. Blue paint doesn’t matter.

[Erick Estrada]

Originally Posted by White Out 403

edit: Actually I'm not going to cross debate between forums. If you want to come argue with me about my posts I make on the Jets section of HF, I invite you to come on over. But there's a reason I don't post certain things here: I am a guest away fan and don't want to crap on the local team to invite fights.

While I do like to periodically check in on the pulse of opposing fanbases I've always felt it's a little disingenuous to create profiles on opposing fans sites seeing the only reason to really do that is to troll. Not saying you are trolling at CP because there's more here than a just the Flames talk but at HF it's all hockey and I don't feel like arguing with a mob of Jets or Oilers fans.

[djsFlames]

Originally Posted by White Out 403

edit: Actually I'm not going to cross debate between forums. If you want to come argue with me about my posts I make on the Jets section of HF, I invite you to come on over. But there's a reason I don't post certain things here: I am a guest away fan and don't want to crap on the local team to invite fights.

Should start an ATL section for whiteout's rage/hate comments on HF.

The "Jesus Christ!!" Special report.

[Erick Estrada]

Originally Posted by PegCityFlamesFan

That's been pretty evident these past few seasons, but troll away.

Past few? You guys had a great season last year but now your goaltender has come back to earth you're in the same ballpark as the Flames.

[Buff]

Originally Posted by White Out 403

I thought it was a good coaches challenge. Maurice's comments were basically because the call on the ice was changed it was a reasonable gamble to make. He wasn't upset they did it or making a beef, just providing reason for the challenge



Oh yeah. I'm sure Buff is still quaking in his boots

No, I'm fine.

[Scroopy Noopers]

Originally Posted by White Out 403

Oh yeah. I'm sure Buff is still quaking in his boots

Accurate typo.

Based on what I saw last night, I’m sure he is.

[the2bears]

Originally Posted by White Out 403

Oh yeah. I'm sure Buff is still quaking in his boots

Of course he's not, that's the actual joke.

[Beninho]

Originally Posted by White Out 403

edit: Actually I'm not going to cross debate between forums. If you want to come argue with me about my posts I make on the Jets section of HF, I invite you to come on over. But there's a reason I don't post certain things here: I am a guest away fan and don't want to crap on the local team to invite fights.

It’s kind of ironic that you called the Flames a bubble team when the Jets were a bubble team for the previous 4 years and should’ve made the playoffs the year they got Laine. They perpetually underachieved and finally played to their potential in the playoffs, only to lose to an inferior team in the conference finals. Jets are legit but I just find it funny to use the term bubble team with so much certainty when each year certain teams take big steps forward and other stagnate or regress. As a Jets fan you should know this. Look at the flames top 4 scorers, is that bubble team status to you? And no I’m not gonna make an account on that garbage site to debate you.

[Azure]

Originally Posted by White Out 403

edit: Actually I'm not going to cross debate between forums. If you want to come argue with me about my posts I make on the Jets section of HF, I invite you to come on over. But there's a reason I don't post certain things here: I am a guest away fan and don't want to crap on the local team to invite fights.

Almost every post you make here is an attempt to troll.

Go away.