I'm a huge fan of Sportmask. I have myself a Sport Mask Mage RS and loving it, only thing bad about this is that it doesn't come with the sweat bands that other mask's come with. It's quite an old mask but it's my favorite one to wear for Ice.
The other mask I have is the Bauer 930 with the Certified Cage that NHL goalies wear. Both mask are not suitable for shinny but since I play with beginner's I've been pretty safe thus far.
I am also debating on whether I should get another Mage RS or go with the 960's as they are good for Shinny but man are they expensive.