CP Mafia 4 - The Unknown Host - Game Over!

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by mrkajz44

A question for those who have moved off Starseed recently (Pux, Party and now Timbo). What has changed your mind? I guess I'm asking because apart from his mega-post, nothing much has changed in my mind for Starseed.

I've already stated already that I think the massive posts talking about everyone is a good way to hide as there is so much information, its easy to get lost in the wall of text. I'm still a bit puzzled why he left Pux off the list, and he didn't address that in his answer to me - just seems like something odd to do, though I suppose I understand it given Pux's claim.

It's always tough when people unvote without much context, so that's why I'm asking. I guess I'm trying to pick out what changed between their votes and unvotes and I'm not seeing much personally.

Why bother putting her on the list, she is as town as it gets.

[Oling_Roachinen]

We got a different definition of confident is all.

Originally Posted by Peanut

I'm also pretty confused about the Seb crusade you went on with Squiggs. I think it's widely acknowledged that Seb was basically confirmed town after the Mazrim exchange.

That...that was the whole point!

Paraphrasing here but accurate enough:

Squiggs96:"The Government Agent should investigate Oling_Roachinen because outside of Puxlut, who can't be turned, he was the most confirmed town by the rest of the town."
Me: "What about SebC? Why did you not consider him confirmed town?"
Squiggs96: "Because I didn't."
Me:"Why?"
Squiggs96: "Because I didn't."
Me:"Why?"
Squiggs96: "Because I didn't."
Me:"Why?"

[Oling_Roachinen]

unvote
Vote: Devo22

And if Devo22's a Host, Peanut's my next target.

[Peanut]

yeah because Devo and I are obviously thick as thieves.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Peanut

yeah because Devo and I are obviously thick as thieves.

But out of all the times you could have brought up your concerns about me and the Squiggs96 argument and me vehemently not wanting to be investigated by the Government Agent it came after I started going for Devo22.

If Devo22's not Host, then I will know that it had nothing to do with protecting Devo22. If he is though, it would be hard to overlook.

[GirlySports]

Vote Count

It takes 8 votes to hammer, 5 to deadline lynch

Hasn't Voted (3): devo22, Puxlut, Timbo

Party Elephant (4): bizaro86, starseed, squiggs96, GGG
starseed (2): mrkajz44, dissentowner
mrkajz44 (2): Hockeyguy15, Party Elephant
squiggs96 (1): SebC
Oling_Roachinen (1): Peanut
devo22 (1): Oling_Roachinen


The deadline is Friday, June 19th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[starseed]

unvote
Vote: devo22

Devo - what are your thoughts of the mrkaj deadline saves?

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

unvote
Vote: Devo22

It'd be hilarious if devo could have hammered and instead gets voted out.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by mrkajz44

A question for those who have moved off Starseed recently (Pux, Party and now Timbo). What has changed your mind? I guess I'm asking because apart from his mega-post, nothing much has changed in my mind for Starseed.

I've already stated already that I think the massive posts talking about everyone is a good way to hide as there is so much information, its easy to get lost in the wall of text. I'm still a bit puzzled why he left Pux off the list, and he didn't address that in his answer to me - just seems like something odd to do, though I suppose I understand it given Pux's claim.

It's always tough when people unvote without much context, so that's why I'm asking. I guess I'm trying to pick out what changed between their votes and unvotes and I'm not seeing much personally.

I thought there was no point to discuss pux. Also, no one voted for her, otherwise I may have included her as a townie in my spreadsheet.

[squiggs96]

It's just not a game if Oling and I aren't voting for each other. And Peanut's catch on Oling saying he's not even a little confident I'm scum (and only voting for me out of principle) but then I'm in his top 4 was good.

Unvote

Vote Oling_Rochinen

I'm guessing Girly will have a lot of posts until deadline or lynch.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by starseed

I thought there was no point to discuss pux. Also, no one voted for her, otherwise I may have included her as a townie in my spreadsheet.

Fixed

Unvote

Vote Puxlut

[starseed]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Fixed

Unvote

Vote Puxlut

Wtf? Scum board getting too out of hand?

[Peanut]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

But out of all the times you could have brought up your concerns about me and the Squiggs96 argument and me vehemently not wanting to be investigated by the Government Agent it came after I started going for Devo22.

If Devo22's not Host, then I will know that it had nothing to do with protecting Devo22. If he is though, it would be hard to overlook.

No. My concern crystallized when you posted that Squiggs was in your top 4. After you just posted about an hour prior that you had zero confidence he was even scum.

I just thought your debate with Squiggs was annoying, so didn't bother to weigh in. But then when you insisted on voting for him even though you said yourself you didn't think he was scum, and then only a short while later listed him as one of your top suspects, that was too weird for me. The pedantic debate about Seb's town status and your insistence on you being a poor target for the GA to investigate pushed me over the top to switch my vote.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

And Peanut's catch on Oling saying he's not even a little confident I'm scum (and only voting for me out of principle) but then I'm in his top 4 was good.

While Peanut conveniently leaves out the post in between that explains my shift from voting for you for principle and voting for you because I don't trust you.

"Thanks Squiggs96, my vote isn't locked on you for not discussing then. However, I just can't see how you missed SebC gaining that town cred, you yourself commented on it. It doesn't make sense to leave him off your list."

There's never been any secret as to why I was voting for you. You couldn't or wouldn't explain why you left SebC off your list when talking about who the Government Agent should investigate. If it was simply a town "accident" (let's call it), it was a bad one because SebC, as everyone has pointed out, was pretty much confirmed town.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by starseed

Wtf? Scum board getting too out of hand?

Oh. I'm paying attention.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by starseed

Wtf? Scum board getting too out of hand?

I have no idea. I'm not in it. Can you paraphrase for us.

I just wanted you to have to include her on your sheet.

Unvote

Vote Party Elephant

[Peanut]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

While Peanut conveniently leaves out the post in between that explains my shift from voting for you for principle and voting for you because I don't trust you.

"Thanks Squiggs96, my vote isn't locked on you for not discussing then. However, I just can't see how you missed SebC gaining that town cred, you yourself commented on it. It doesn't make sense to leave him off your list."

.

I didn't conveniently leave that out. To me, that post does not close the gap between "I have very little confidence you're even scum" to "you're now in my top 4".

[starseed]

Lol. I'm not going to update those stats. It was a snapshot of an early mid point of the game.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Peanut

The pedantic debate about Seb's town status and your insistence on you being a poor target for the GA to investigate pushed me over the top to switch my vote.

It's not pedantic.

"Hey guys the Host probably gave the spore to the most confirmed townie between us but since Puxlut can't be turned the only option left is Oling. Oling should be investigated tonight"

"What about SebC?"

"...."

You've said it yourself Peanut, SebC was confirmed town. So why did Squiggs96 not include him as an option? There's no answer for it. As I know I wasn't turned, and now know I didn't receive the spore and someone was turned (yes, the Host are not just going to pass it back and forth), it looked like Squiggs96 may have been trying to prevent SebC from getting checked, maybe.

Even then, if you're so afraid I didn't want to be investigated, is the argument not then that I am turned? Not Host.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by starseed

Devo has scum tells, but seems to in the background. If we need to do a late run, he isn't on my town list.

I game for a run on devo. He's my other suspect when I reread everything at the start of day 4.