CP Mafia 4 - The Unknown Host - Game Over!

[SebC]

If Timbo's was right, then this is right.

Hasn't Voted:

mrkajz44 (5): , Timbo, Hockeyguy15, devo22, Starseed, SebC
Starseed (6): Peanut, mrkajz44, Party Elephant, squiggs96, Puxlut, dissentowner
Party Elephant (3): bizaro86 , , GGG
squiggs96 (1): Oling_Roachinen

The deadline is Friday, June 12th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.
__________________

[Timbo]

Party Elephant only has two.

[GGG]

Any reasons as to why SebC?

I'm moving to MrKajz as well. The Lego /Starseed vote is too conveneant. Would far rather move back to Party though.

unvote
vote mrkajz

That is 6 to 6

[GGG]

Can someone make a Starseed case that's better than Lego lurked and got replaced.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by GGG

Was hoping Squiggs would have answered this but I think this statement feels like he knows the outcome. He also just generally believes Mrkajz's statement without saying why.

Why does town Squiggs do this? He believes mrkajz
Why does scum squigs do this. We have two townies as front runners and he is looking for town cred with the unvote if we lynch mr Kajz and setting up the second lynch for tomorrow if we lynch Starseed. And getting Starseed today while he's getting his bearings is a win for scum before he is fully engaged.

Just got back from dinner. Sorry for the delay.

I genuinely believe mrkajz's death post. I don't feel his words were manufactured. I felt he was hoping that what he left behind would help the town. ECF did this. I'm sure a smart mafia member could/will make a post to save themselves. I don't feel this is the case right now. If I'm wrong, I'll accept the blame on that. I will not be going after mrkajz on day 5, no matter what comes of any card flip tonight.

I'm not trying to pass any blame right now. I'm making what I feel is the best decision for the town, and that is for me voting starseed over mrkajz. If I look stupid because of it, I'd rather take a swing and miss, rather than watch the pitch go by me. I could build in many excuses, such as I followed a "confirmed townie" in Pux's vote, but I'm not. I choose to change my vote because I think it's right. If I was scum I could have let this whole day (Friday, not game day) go by without a post. I'm not in danger of being voted out, at least as of now, and for sure at the beginning of Friday. I chose to enter into multiple debates, explore theories and continue to post. I'm hoping I uncover information and help the town win. If my methods prove to get me lynched, hurt the town, or put heat on me, that's a risk I was willing to take. I want to be involved in the game and help the town win. If this is the wrong tactic, then I missed, but I'm glad I took the shot.

[Party Elephant]

Originally Posted by GGG

Can someone make a Starseed case that's better than Lego lurked and got replaced.

I already have, but I'll refresh it.

[GirlySports]

Vote Count

Starseed (6): Peanut, mrkajz44, Party Elephant, squiggs96, Puxlut, dissentowner
mrkajz44 (6): Timbo, Hockeyguy15, devo22, Starseed, SebC, GGG
Party Elephant (1): bizaro86
squiggs96 (1): Oling_Roachinen


The deadline is Friday, June 12th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[SebC]

Originally Posted by GGG

Any reasons as to why SebC?

Again, I prefer not to disclose as the rationale will likely apply to future votes and I'd rather not become predictable (and thus manipulatable), but perhaps you can consider it positive that I am making your plays ahead of you.

[Timbo]

Puxlut gets two votes?

[Party Elephant]

Originally Posted by starseed

PE, I was basing my vote on your voting off of mrkaj and onto the known townie,

Originally Posted by Party Elephant

You're getting your details wrong. I pulled off of hockeyguy, not mrkajz.

Originally Posted by starseed

Its possible, I will go to bed and read over that again tomorrow.

Originally Posted by Party Elephant

That's probably a good idea. It's also possible that the earth is round.

This exchange right here. starseed uses a blatantly incorrect statement about who I voted for in the past round. When confronted about it he doesn't even correct himself, just says it's "possible". It's one thing to use your opinion as basis for your vote, but to make a factually incorrect claim and not even fix it is either scum or brutally lazy town.

[GirlySports]

Originally Posted by Timbo

Puxlut gets two votes?

Fixed.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Party Elephant

This exchange right here. starseed uses a blatantly incorrect statement about who I voted for in the past round. When confronted about it he doesn't even correct himself, just says it's "possible". It's one thing to use your opinion as basis for your vote, but to make a factually incorrect claim and not even fix it is either scum or brutally lazy town.

Or drunk town!

Before work this morning I started to sort it out, and it was still a move in defense of mrkaj.

Originally Posted by starseed

So if I have this right, vote 3 saw PE vote HG15 until mrkazj44 had momentum, then PE switched to ECF.

I was also suspecting HG15 at the time. However, it is a great scum play to target a player that will get no traction only to be able to have the flexibility to switch votes in defense of another scum player.

I will look into the movement on vote 3 again when I am not busy today.

[Peanut]

Originally Posted by GGG

Can someone make a Starseed case that's better than Lego lurked and got replaced.

That's really the foundation of my suspicions. But not only that he lurked, there was a decent amount of discussion yester-game-day about how Lego was a likely scum. That, coupled with the switch out (why would Lego bother switching out if he was just town? It makes more sense that he's mafia and couldn't keep up with the time commitment), made me convinced to vote for him this day.

starseed hasn't done anything concrete that confirms he's scum for me. I'm basing my vote off of Lego's history.

[starseed]

30 minutes to avoid a no lynch scenario.

[starseed]

Actually, nevermind. It goes to sudden death.

[GGG]

We get an hour extension to move votes on a tie.

[starseed]

Only for one extra hour.

[Timbo]

I have no real reason to move over to starseed other than Legoman's low posting and subsequent replacement, which to be honest gives all of us an icky feeling. I was hoping to let him play for a bit and then assess from there.

I have not seen enough evidence and Legoman left a small sample size to dissect.

How about we ninja hammer HG15? LOL sorry I couldn't resist.

[SebC]

squiggs96 seems to be here though

[SebC]

nm read that wrong