CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[Rathji]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Except if I was scum I would not be so bold as to drive the attention at you, that would be foolish on my part. Look at the arrogance in your post. Nobody will touch me because my power is obviously light and I don't need to disclose my powers even though everybody else did, and only a mafia driven mob will lynch me! This is a total scum post. Make anybody afraid to cast a vote your way because that would most certainly make them look mafia right? It is a good plan, but I am not buying it.

I am confident that the town who wants to win already knows that there are 4-5 better targets than the guy who has done what I have.

Call it arrogance if you want, but I know that the town is smart enough collectively that they are not buying your theory, or else someone, anyone, would have given some indication that you were making sense. Without any town buying into it, the mafia (if you are or are not a member) won't budge in a move against me in voting. It would clearly point themselves out to everyone.

This is really my last post on this matter, unless you bring up some new reasoning. You keep drawing me back into it with baiting me with claims of poor town play, letting my ego fuel this distraction. Given what you do for a living and your training that I know you get, it actually makes a ton of sense that you have chosen this tactic.

[Rathji]

Just to clarify, if someone else has questions about my motives, remaining powers, use of my previous powers, I will be happy to address them.

I am just done playing dissentowner s game

[dissentowner]

Fair enough, I will leave it alone for now. However nobody is buying your what's best for the town stuff when you are voting for someone who has fully disclosed his powers and also has a night doctor ability that would be rather conviently gone if I was lynched tonight and could not use it. That is why I said if the town wants to lynch me, fine, but give me an extra night to protect somebody from the scum. As soon as I disclosed I was given one shot doctor you decided I was the best target for lynching. Funny how that worked.

[GGG]

Oling,

Why did you let Rathji use his one shot day kill on formulate if you suspected him to be the bulletproof mafia godfather based on your tracking results.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

So you are saying you cannot be lynched ever? I call B.S. Nobody would ever be given that power that is town.

So Diss I don't think we should be following your advice on how powers are handed out this game. Your track record of knowing how they work and are given out isn't great.

[GGG]

My preferences for lynch are Aeneas first, then Oling.

Aneas has done nothing the last 3 game days. No opinions, no reads, no participation. We have had to drag out reads from him all game.

For me Squiggs is more town. I would like Olings question answered on why he can post anything about his post restriction.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by GGG

So Diss I don't think we should be following your advice on how powers are handed out this game. Your track record of knowing how they work and are given out isn't great.

ya, I was wrong about that for sure.

[Timbo]

Quite the slugfest between Rathji and Dissentowner. It reminds me of the Flintstones fights that Fred and Barney would watch where two opponents in the ring would stand toe to toe and bash each other over the skulls with wooden bats.

I'm still struggling with Rathji's save the day power being scummy.

I find GirlySports power to be more Mafia oriented.
Lynch Mafia, mafia gets a double kill. All baddies do that, you kill one of them they kill 2 of us! It is so out of skew and anti town. What if we had lynched GS early in the game? Its a tool for mafia to get a jump ahead in the event of a GS/mafia lynch.
Most townie powers have positive ,and negative if used incorrectly, this one just leans more negative the only positive is an extra possible investigation for the town. That is not enough of a positive IMO.

So how do we play this? IMO "We like you Girly, we will kill you last"
No doctor on GS! I think doing this is a waste because
a. She is scum
b. Her death is an inevitability as we cannot save her enough to win ,mafia have a huge ace up their sleeve with this.

That is how I'm leaning for what its worth.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by GGG

My preferences for lynch are Aeneas first, then Oling.

Aneas has done nothing the last 3 game days. No opinions, no reads, no participation. We have had to drag out reads from him all game.

For me Squiggs is more town. I would like Olings question answered on why he can post anything about his post restriction.

So by doing that we take the stance that Aeneas did not visit Oling night two
and is just claiming to have because of revealed circumstances?
Aeneas did make the post(I believe/must research for proof) inquiring why he got info on me before my bucket reveal.
Why would Mafia vista mafia?
Im not defending him here I just am trying to work this out.

[dissentowner]

Ok, well given my absolutely crappy record with powers in this game I am just taking the follow along route and I will get off Rathji's back. Maybe do the opposite of what I suggest? lol. This game has thrown me for a loop. Anyhow I will listen to others and shut my mouth.

Unvote

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Ok, well given my absolutely crappy record with powers in this game I am just taking the follow along route and I will get off Rathji's back. Maybe do the opposite of what I suggest? lol. This game has thrown me for a loop. Anyhow I will listen to others and shut my mouth.

Unvote

Heres the thing we do have the time, we must use it wisely.

[Timbo]

So what I think is...

Mafia/town has day saver or night repeat so Girly or Rathji
Mafia/town has investigate powers Aeneas or Oling

Could it be that we have two scum in our sight?

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

There was nothing stopping him from revealing his power, just his post restrictions.

If Squiggs96 gave the doctor to Dissentowner, he needs to tell us why Diss when there are confirmed townies. If he tried to save Starseed and Puxlut, let us know so we can consider.

Right now he target Puxlut last night, he already knew that the poison and kill didn't work, why did he think the fire had a chance? Why did he leave my tracking unprotected? And why hasn't he revealed all his night actions?

Pika has revealed all powers and actions. Chu's favourite hockey player is Jamie Benn.

I never gave the doctor is diss. If you've followed this game you will know that I used it on wood (of which I've caught flack from numerous people for using it there and not on ECF), and that I'm not a fan of diss. Pika has explained why he used it on GGG multiple times, so if you want to continue to beat a dead horse, go for it. I thought it might work. How is that so hard to understand? Pika's wondering if your helmet is on too tight and it's restricting air and/or blood flow.

Why are you the only one who deserves protection? I told you I used it on you one night and you didn't even acknowledge that I existed, and now I have to use it every night on you? Pika needs you to get over yourself. I have no idea if you are town or not. I hope you are, but it's not like you are on everyone's confirmed list, nor are you holding and status near what wood did.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by GGG

For me Squiggs is more town. I would like Olings question answered on why he can't post anything about his post restriction.

This will be Pika's last post on the subject, but everything you need to know is in your last sentence above.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Actually it might work out good if I get lynched, flip town, and then maybe people will pay attention to the obvious. Remember how we were told we were being lead around by scum?

I brought this up as well, said we should investigate the top posters (ranked by number of posts), and was accused of trying to deflect away from the unknowns/lower ranked posters. True, this was by one of the top posters, but an accusation nonetheless. Pika was also told that the messages have never meant anything, but I'm not going to ignore them. I don't think they mean nothing, and if I can find a pattern or trail, I'll look into it.

Pika is interested in your theory from a little while ago when you thought Puxlut and starseed could both be mafia. Let me be clear, that you never explicitly stated they were mafia, but I thought it was an interesting theory.

[Timbo]

Okay I got lost here a bit.
By post restrictions do you mean Squiggs has them or the player who was Jamie Benn in CP mafia 1?

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Timbo

Okay I got lost here a bit.
By post restrictions do you mean Squiggs has them or the player who was Jamie Benn in CP mafia 1?

Squiggs as been posting like Pikachu all game and it has something to do with his ability.

Squigss, what is the consequence of you telling us how your power works.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Timbo

So by doing that we take the stance that Aeneas did not visit Oling night two
and is just claiming to have because of revealed circumstances?
Aeneas did make the post(I believe/must research for proof) inquiring why he got info on me before my bucket reveal.
Why would Mafia vista mafia?
Im not defending him here I just am trying to work this out.

I take the stance that Aeneas is being truthful about his alignment but not his power.

Aeneas,

Why didn't you watch ECF the nights he was going to die. Essentially the goal of the watcher power is to catch someone who is going to die and report the killer. Which means you should have been watching ECF and then once he died Wood or perhaps one of the potential cops.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by GGG

I take the stance that Aeneas is being truthful about his alignment but not his power.

Aeneas,

Why didn't you watch ECF the nights he was going to die. Essentially the goal of the watcher power is to catch someone who is going to die and report the killer. Which means you should have been watching ECF and then once he died Wood or perhaps one of the potential cops.

Truthful about his power but not his alignment.

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by GGG

Truthful about his power but not his alignment.

I see what you are getting at. So if Aeneas flips scum is Oling town in your books? Or was this set up by mafia as an alibi?

BTW I went into the old CP mafia 1 scum thread earlier today to refresh myself on some of the scum abilities and I saw your star test. Man I almost sprayed coffee all over the monitor I laughed so hard.