CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika's now wondering if the Drury stopping Timbo's lynch was a mafia play, very well disguised as a town play. If not, I'd lean towards starseed, based on what I thought very early in the game.

Unfortunately, if Timbo flips scum, it only means Drury is an idiot. I did strongly believe he is town and that his powers were town. Timbo was someone I had on my suspected town list from the beginning and at the time the lynch was happening, I didn't have anything to change my mind about that. I felt that the GGG/Timbo exchange was GGG acting as mafia to frame up a townie and that Timbo was the townie, GGG was the scum.

However, the fact that Timbo did specifically ask me if he should accept the invite and Wood and myself both said no and we had questions about the powers, I'm not too pleased. Wood and I were VERY clear about the answer should be no and he accepted anyway. I'm not happy about this at all.

[Oling_Roachinen]

If it's town, come out and say so. If town knows there is a mafia member, tell now, let us lynch and we finally catch a break.

Cryptic posts that haven't been right shouldn't be used as evidence that one of those 4 are mafia.

[GGG]

Squiggs outside of your free doctor power what other powers have you earned. Feel free to decline to answer if it's in our best interests.

[GGG]

One question for the town:

Is it time to go around and disclose our powers and night actions for each night?

[squiggs96]

Let's take a look at all the messages:

1. Start of game
2. Hello loyal townsfolk! Beware the Eternals. Membership is not free.
3. Hello Townsfolk! The gift of Eternal powers are a contrived deceit.
4. The Eternals are close to defeat, The Guardians will prevail.
5. One more day and the Guardian victory will be complete
6. There is scum among the Guardians.

Pika can't remember everything, but aren't the eternal powers the ones that aren't working? ECF's powers didn't go through, even though Pika attempted to help him on night 2. From #4 Pika saw that the Eternals were close to defeat. If Puxlut doesn't join the Eternals, then Chu thinks the guardians may have won. Pika's not the best at deciphering these clues, but it's at least worth a look and/or discussion.

[GirlySports]

Originally Posted by Drury18

Why Wood?

Although I have to admit, I wondered if he had a second bullet in his shotgun that he was keeping to himself. Can't blame him if he did.

I think that confirmed townies are targets as well because they have 0% chance of being lynched thus increasing the chance of a mafia member of getting lynched. They want to keep us confused.

Originally Posted by GGG

One question for the town:

Is it time to go around and disclose our powers and night actions for each night?

This won't surprise you but going along with my answer to Drury above, absolutely not. Known townies disclosing known actions are sitting ducks.

[Aeneas]

Is this a bad time to ask if i should accept my "invitation"?

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by squiggs96

Pika can't remember everything, but aren't the eternal powers the ones that aren't working? ECF's powers didn't go through, even though Pika attempted to help him on night 2. From #4 Pika saw that the Eternals were close to defeat. If Puxlut doesn't join the Eternals, then Chu thinks the guardians may have won. Pika's not the best at deciphering these clues, but it's at least worth a look and/or discussion.

Yeah, the Eternals power didn't work according to your power on ECF and GGG being town. GGG is confirmed town at this point, if he isn't Mazrim is cruel and we already lost so we need to assume town.

So you used your power on ECF, his poison did not work on GGG. You now used your power on Puxlut? I suppose we can test to see if her power works, if we aren't afraid of the risks, but it would be the first sign of Eternal powers working.

[squiggs96]

Originally Posted by GGG

Squiggs outside of your free doctor power what other powers have you earned. Feel free to decline to answer if it's in our best interests.

Chu only received the one night doctor power, which I used on wood. I've been hoping for new powers, but haven't received anything. I tried to see if it had anything to do with who I used it on. Pika used it on ECF on night two, and received it in a PM from Mazrim right before the start of day 3. I couldn't even use it on him again in order to see if I'd get another power.

Pika has yet to be contacted by either the guardians or the eternals. Am I the only one left?

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Timbo, explain how you knew the cop to me please.

Cause right now it's beginning to look like we don't have one or (s)he's super secret agent cop.

I'm thinking formulate was our only cop, so if that's who you thought was cop why didn't you say anything?

Well I was going to wait until the morning but I guess I will say what I need to say now.

When I said I knew who the cop was I was mistaken.
I thought the cop was Oling_Roachinen. I had bucketed him on night 2 and I received a PM showing his investigation of Drury
I thought this information as interesting and valuable. But it was when Oling made a post hinting that it was possible Mafia investigated people and he stated do not read anything into it that Drury did not do anything on night 2, that I saw the message he was trying to say. (I was partially right as it seems.)

I saw this as a sign and I kept this to myself yet when pressured and on the verge of a lynch I stated I knew who the cop was (I thought I did)
Later when Oling posted he was the tracker and formulate flipped as Serial killer/ cop I was knocked to the floor. Yet when pressured I thought it would be better that everyone believe there still was a cop. (And there still may be)
I did not like the inquiries to get me to reveal. Not one bit!
My bucket is considered as "light cop"
We lost a "Role Cop"
Then formulate flipped as cop but serial killer.
I came to the conclusion we don't have a cop. But I was not going to let that information go public.
The Guardians sent me an invite with the offer of one of three powers.
1. Day cop
2. Roleblocker
3. Doctor

I ended up accepting under the condition that I could use the power I was given against Guardians.

I was accepted into the Guardians however the power I received is only a one shot power. I was deceived. Nowhere was it stated this was a one-shot power if I had known this I would have declined.

I have a one shot doctor power. I did not use it last night as this is a power (if it works) that we need and I need to be sure on whom to use it on.
My night action I put my bucket to Dissentowner and got nothing. (This is not evidence for or against him being scum)
The post saying there is scum in the Guardians with me being the latest to join is a well placed set up IMO and one I fell for from the dangling carrot of power the promised.
That's all I got because its the truth.

F()CK the eternals!
That is all I have to say.
Useless piece of ##### mother f()cker can eat my f()cking a$$.
f()ck f()ck f()ck!
So much for that plan.
And now no more skanky turtle sex with my fruit smelling b!tch.
I miss Peach

[Aeneas]

Timbo you believe whoever is sending the invites tried to set you up?

Sort of edit: holy s... Puxlut!

[Aeneas]

Originally Posted by Aeneas

Is this a bad time to ask if i should accept my "invitation"?

Nevermind, this has expired of course. Lost a half day there in my head I suppose, with Ottawa etc.

So, i guess I am cursed....

[Timbo]

Originally Posted by Aeneas

Timbo you believe whoever is sending the invites tried to set you up?

Sort of edit: holy s... Puxlut!

Yes because the powers promised and what I received was only a fraction of what was implied. That is why I am saying a dangling carrot.

[Drury18]

When did it expire? Mazrim updated the list at 10:30pm tonight and you aren't listed as being in any group:

3. Drury18 - Palutena
5. dissentowner - Sonic
6. starseed - King Dedede - Member of The Guardians
8. squiggs96 - Pikachu
10. stazzy33 Hockeyguy15 - Link
12. Rathji - Ness - Member of the Guardians
13. Timbo - Game & Watch - Member of the Guardians
15. GGG - Little Mac - Member of the Guardians
17. Baxter Renegade Aeneas - Villager
18. GirlySports - Yoshi
20. Oling_Roachinen - Captain Falcon
22. Puxlut - Bowser - Member of the Eternals

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Timbo

Well I was going to wait until the morning but I guess I will say what I need to say now.

When I said I knew who the cop was I was mistaken.
I thought the cop was Oling_Roachinen. I had bucketed him on night 2 and I received a PM showing his investigation of Drury
I thought this information as interesting and valuable. But it was when Oling made a post hinting that it was possible Mafia investigated people and he stated do not read anything into it that Drury did not do anything on night 2, that I saw the message he was trying to say. (I was partially right as it seems.)

I saw this as a sign and I kept this to myself yet when pressured and on the verge of a lynch I stated I knew who the cop was (I thought I did)
Later when Oling posted he was the tracker and formulate flipped as Serial killer/ cop I was knocked to the floor. Yet when pressured I thought it would be better that everyone believe there still was a cop. (And there still may be)
I did not like the inquiries to get me to reveal. Not one bit!
My bucket is considered as "light cop"
We lost a "Role Cop"
Then formulate flipped as cop but serial killer.
I came to the conclusion we don't have a cop. But I was not going to let that information go public.
The Guardians sent me an invite with the offer of one of three powers.
1. Day cop
2. Roleblocker
3. Doctor

I ended up accepting under the condition that I could use the power I was given against Guardians.

I was accepted into the Guardians however the power I received is only a one shot power. I was deceived. Nowhere was it stated this was a one-shot power if I had known this I would have declined.

I have a one shot doctor power. I did not use it last night as this is a power (if it works) that we need and I need to be sure on whom to use it on.
My night action I put my bucket to Dissentowner and got nothing. (This is not evidence for or against him being scum)
The post saying there is scum in the Guardians with me being the latest to join is a well placed set up IMO and one I fell for from the dangling carrot of power the promised.
That's all I got because its the truth.

Making the mafia think there is a cop makes sense, so I can understand that plan.

I am a bit confused though because at one point the plan was to let Wood pick the target, you confirm it wasn't the cop, and then have Rathji shoot the person. This was before formulate was revealed, so what if Wood would have picked the cop (we didn't know formulate was cop at this point, had to assume cop was town) to kill and Rathji able to go through with it? We would have been screwed. That's a huge gamble.

[Aeneas]

Originally Posted by Timbo

Yes because the powers promised and what I received was only a fraction of what was implied. That is why I am saying a dangling carrot.

Be happy, at least you were offered a power!

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Drury18

When did it expire? Mazrim updated the list at 10:30pm tonight and you aren't listed as being in any group:

3. Drury18 - Palutena
5. dissentowner - Sonic
6. starseed - King Dedede - Member of The Guardians
8. squiggs96 - Pikachu
10. stazzy33 Hockeyguy15 - Link
12. Rathji - Ness - Member of the Guardians
13. Timbo - Game & Watch - Member of the Guardians
15. GGG - Little Mac - Member of the Guardians
17. Baxter Renegade Aeneas - Villager
18. GirlySports - Yoshi
20. Oling_Roachinen - Captain Falcon
22. Puxlut - Bowser - Member of the Eternals

Timbo is?

[Hockeyguy15]

So can we finally stop accepting invites? With Timbo being lied to, and I assume Puxluts kill didn't work with that rant. Also squiggs I haven't been contacted either.

[Aeneas]

Originally Posted by Drury18

When did it expire? Mazrim updated the list at 10:30pm tonight and you aren't listed as being in any group:

3. Drury18 - Palutena
5. dissentowner - Sonic
6. starseed - King Dedede - Member of The Guardians
8. squiggs96 - Pikachu
10. stazzy33 Hockeyguy15 - Link
12. Rathji - Ness - Member of the Guardians
13. Timbo - Game & Watch - Member of the Guardians
15. GGG - Little Mac - Member of the Guardians
17. Baxter Renegade Aeneas - Villager
18. GirlySports - Yoshi
20. Oling_Roachinen - Captain Falcon
22. Puxlut - Bowser - Member of the Eternals

I never answered them, so I suppose it expired after 24 hours.