CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

Originally Posted by GGG

Drury did pux ever post in twilight?

I did. Was using my iPad and my computer for one. iPad and phone at the inlaws for one. And for the first one (when I was at the kids soccer) just the phone. That was the first night pux wasn't on.

[Wood]

Originally Posted by starseed

What would be the point otherwise?

Kill formulate, if he's town reverse and have a confirmed townie. I didn't know it was confirmed if Rathji would get his power back

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by starseed

And for the record, we did not discuss whatever the investigate from the dead comment was beforehand :P

Yeah, so what did that mean? why the cryptics? Terrible execution. If you are town, that whole thing nearly cost us the game if not for hockeyguy15.

There's no reason, ever, to intentionally confuse the town. Period.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Wood

Kill formulate, if he's town reverse and have a confirmed townie. I didn't know it was confirmed if Rathji would get his power back

Oh, I guess I assumed that Rathji could re-kill.

Originally Posted by starseed

And for the record, we did not discuss whatever the investigate from the dead comment was beforehand :P

I tried to explain it to you before Starseed, my idea (it just came to me during Twilight) that not that we investigate the dead, but a thought that killed players could post FROM the dead. But I never got around to asking Mazrim if that was allowed. Twilight seemed like a bit of a free for all.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Yeah, so what did that mean? why the cryptics? Terrible execution. If you are town, that whole thing nearly cost us the game if not for hockeyguy15.

There's no reason, ever, to intentionally confuse the town. Period.

It was not something that we discussed we would say. It was probably just in the moment roleplaying/adding flavour.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

I tried to explain it to you before Starseed, my idea (it just came to me during Twilight) that not that we investigate the dead, but a thought that killed players could post FROM the dead. But I never got around to asking Mazrim if that was allowed. Twilight seemed like a bit of a free for all.

I don't think that Mazrim would allow that, but I was confused on this.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

I tried to explain it to you before Starseed, my idea (it just came to me during Twilight) that not that we investigate the dead, but a thought that killed players could post FROM the dead. But I never got around to asking Mazrim if that was allowed. Twilight seemed like a bit of a free for all.

Exactly what I thought. It seemed stage to post as a fake dead player (anyone could change their name to delgar) and say so-and-so is mafia.

Again, no reason to confuse or mislead the town like that. And Starseed's trying to cover of that only lead me on what was probably a wild goose hunt.

[GGG]

Starseed do you have yesterday's vote sequence handy. I would like to look at the vote run on you and the the switch to Timbo. If you don't have it handy I will dig it out.

[starseed]

Well, whatever. Time to move on.

If formulate comes up dry, and with many people revealing, I might start to lean towards the idea that we are trying to fight the cult leaders somehow. This is a much more confusing game.

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Again, no reason to confuse or mislead the town like that. And Starseed's trying to cover of that only lead me on what was probably a wild goose hunt.

You would know. You're the king of twisting things to make your theories fit.

[Wood]

Puxlut was always mentioning how she thought I was town, there was no need for starseed to as well. So Oling can stop harping on about that

Town IMO are me, starseed, puxlut, Timbo, Drury, GGG and HG (once he proves this ability). Let's kill formulate, see what happens and reverse if he flips town. If he flips town, he's revived and we can add another townie to the list. Rathji most likely is town as well, regardless of what happens with his kill

The remaining players are Oling, mrkajz, girly, Aeneas, squiggs and dissentowner. I'm positive at the very least 3 of those 6 are mafia

[starseed]

Originally Posted by GGG

Starseed do you have yesterday's vote sequence handy. I would like to look at the vote run on you and the the switch to Timbo. If you don't have it handy I will dig it out.

I do not. I only updated my spreadsheet up to post 1500, and I am now 3000kms away from my desktop.

[Hockeyguy15]

Confirmed, I have to rewind before a lynch, not after.

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

You would know. You're the king of twisting things to make your theories fit.

I didn't twist anything.

Starseed lied multiple times, it looks like some of the time it was to cover for your mistakes.

You can't lie in this game if you don't want suspicion cast on you. Sometimes there is a reason for it, most of the time it's cause you are mafia.

[Drury18]

Originally Posted by GGG

Drury did pux ever post in twilight?

It's been answered, but yes

Day 1, I've got nothing.

Day 2, she posted a one word "Faction?" comment. Couple posts later as MOT #2 she posted that they would know what faction killed Devo22.

Day 3, she posted "Wow", asking if the two mafia kills were a one time only thing (I believe this is what her question of "It was a one time only thing" was referring to, I can't see what else it might be relevant to), asking me why she is suspect, suggesting the doctor protect me, suggesting that if the cop and doctor are reading the twilight thread we should decide who to use the powers on, asking how twilight is going to help us and saying she is completely stumped

That's all the posting history I have as Puxlut acting as Puxlut in the twilight threads.

[starseed]

We were trying to execute a plan we thought was best for the town. At the very least, it worked well to help get us to 2700+ posts, with a lot of post history and feel for the characters in this game. Even if it didn't work as intended, the aftermath isn't really that terrible.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by starseed

We were trying to execute a plan we thought was best for the town. At the very least, it worked well to help get us to 2700+ posts, with a lot of post history and feel for the characters in this game. Even if it didn't work as intended, the aftermath isn't really that terrible.

Really? Your twilight was a key factor in helping lynch nothing but town so far but the aftermath is not that terrible huh...

[starseed]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Really? Your twilight was a key factor in helping lynch nothing but town so far but the aftermath is not that terrible huh...

RD, GP_Matt and Hmmhmmcamo are on us now?

[starseed]

Originally Posted by starseed

RD, GP_Matt and Hmmhmmcamo are on us now?

GP was a day kill, there was no 3rd lynch.