CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

I'm not sure I'm much help... Even my power is lame.

And if I do reveal what it is, I'm going to look shady as hell.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Timbo

dissentowner I have a very interesting question for you.

You were online and post just as the hammer came down on hmmhmmcamo
your last post was 8:33 pm post 1679

I did not see you in the twilight how come?

Because I got distracted by a three year old having a meltdown and totally forgot about the twilight although I was there for the last five minutes. I did not sign into anything though as I immediately started reading from post #1 on trying to catch up as fast as possible before it closed.

[Wood]

vote: GGG

I think its worth it

He's either lying, and in that case he dies, or he's telling the truth about his lynchproof power and he'll survive and we wont need to waste our time worrying about him anymore

We get to the MOT thread, learn about a faction who killed devo, see what happens at night. We need info if were going to get anywhere

This hasn't been going the towns way at all, we need to make some big moves before were too behind. I'm starting to agree with puxluts post from earlier and think there isn't even a Mafia, its hard to keep sight on the goal when we don't know what it is. These groups are throwing me off

[mrkajz44]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

And if I do reveal what it is, I'm going to look shady as hell.

Keeping the conversation going, extracting and providing more information and posting suspicions are far more valuable to us than any sort of power. Especially in this game as powers don't seem to be doing what is expected or intended.

[Wood]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

And if I do reveal what it is, I'm going to look shady as hell.

Don't reveal anything, whatever your power is its going to help in some way

[dissentowner]

Ok, had a few pages to read there and some thoughts.
1. Again, how do we know the MOT are really trying to help us? Did I miss something that states they were a tool for the town? Two of the people they have said we should target have flipped town guys.

2. GGG is making absolutely no sense which raises suspicion huge but then again so did GP_Matt and he flipped town. That does not mean I think GGG is town, he has been pretty scummy all throughout this thing and his explanations don't add up. However I do not trust the MOT at all and the fact he is on their list is a plus on the good side to me. It almost seems to me like the MOT are looking at posters we have some serious suspicion of that they know are town and trying to get us to go that extra length to lynch one of our own.
I am really starting to think the MOT are not on our side guys.

[mrkajz44]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

I'm not sure I'm much help... Even my power is lame.

Originally Posted by mrkajz44

Keeping the conversation going, extracting and providing more information and posting suspicions are far more valuable to us than any sort of power. Especially in this game as powers don't seem to be doing what is expected or intended.

Oops - I meant to quote this post from Puxlut, not the one I did in my last post.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by Wood

vote: GGG

I think its worth it

He's either lying, and in that case he dies, or he's telling the truth about his lynchproof power and he'll survive and we wont need to waste our time worrying about him anymore

We get to the MOT thread, learn about a faction who killed devo, see what happens at night. We need info if were going to get anywhere

This hasn't been going the towns way at all, we need to make some big moves before were too behind. I'm starting to agree with puxluts post from earlier and think there isn't even a Mafia, its hard to keep sight on the goal when we don't know what it is. These groups are throwing me off

I can't get behind a GGG lynch, not yet anyway. I think something is up and he is lying, but on the off chance he is telling the truth we can't waste our lynches. Assuming ECF is town, he lost his kill ability (if he even had one) and we also used your kill ability so all we have left is the lynches.

We can't drop the hammer until 10pm tomorrow so maybe something will change my mind before then, but as of right now I think we should lynch someone that hasn't claimed lynchproof.

Originally Posted by Wood

Don't reveal anything, whatever your power is its going to help in some way

But like you said, we will need to make some big moves. What happens if we get another 2 town kill night?

[East Coast Flame]

I am convinced that there are two people in this game that are the leaders of the eternals and the leader of the guardians and their job is to find each other out and have the other killed.

Maybe this is what the darkness is and there is no mafia? Say they each have a night kill and the rest are all town.

[mrkajz44]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

But like you said, we will need to make some big moves. What happens if we get another 2 town kill night?

I think the more pressing question at this point, is why there was only one kill. From mafiascum:

Bodyguard only protects from a single kill. If multiple people try to kill the Bodyguard's target, both the Bodyguard and the protected player will die.

I guess we are assuming Delgar protected ECF and died in that manner, but why was there only one kill? Delgar couldn't protect against two kills, unless Mazrim's Bodyguard role doesn't make the mafiascum website (possible, but I think somewhat unlikely).

Went back and check out who first said that Delgar took two bullets and it was starseed:

Originally Posted by starseed

Havent caught up reading, just a couple quick thoughts.

The star beside my name is because I am logged in when I enter that site because I was mafia last game.

Delgar - I am sorry!! It was a bad call, but you bought us some time. Only one townie kill because you likely took 2 bullets to save the doctor.

I am not sure if it is time for me to costanza it, or keep looking into oling.

The bolded statement reads very much like a fact statement, yet we really have no idea why one kill and starseed explanation is quite unlikely based on the description of bodyguard from mafiascum.

This puts Starseed high on my radar all of a sudden.

[Wood]

Originally Posted by Puxlut

But like you said, we will need to make some big moves. What happens if we get another 2 town kill night?

What if we kill a Mafia member? Morales up

Day 3s not to the time to worry too much, we don't need anymore town* giving up. Last game the town was a mess most of the game but it all came together in the end. We'll get more info as days go on, they can't keep us blind forever

[East Coast Flame]

My save could have worked

[East Coast Flame]

I think what happens tonight will tell us more about how many kills there are. Maybe there only is one kill? Maybe the first night someone had a one shot kill ability and used it?

[mrkajz44]

Originally Posted by East Coast Flame

My save could have worked

Exactly, to me this is a much more plausible reason for one kill, but starseed just jumped on the "Delgar must have taken two bullets" train. Just seems out of place.

[Wood]

Originally Posted by East Coast Flame

My save could have worked

I think this is most likely

It is odd what starseed said though, and I have a gut feeling he's mafia. I still can't really justify it but I think I'm going to end up being right about starseed and girly

[GGG]

I am being completely truthful. Sorry about causing this chaos.

On the redirection thing it didn't say mine got redirected. It just returned a report with what ecf did.

Maybe the guardian powers don't work right either and just work randomly. Even confirmed with maz what he sent me was correct?

[Hockeyguy15]

GGG did you ask any questions before accepting the Guardian invite?

[Wood]

unvote

I don't know what to do about GGG