CP Mafia 3 - Super Smash Mafia - GAME OVER - Darkness Win!

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by GGG

Getting cold feet? You have been trying to hammer gp_matt for days. And now you want to here from hmmmmmmmmmmm.

No, but if he wants to pony up info why would I not hear it? Nobody is perfect, I could be wrong about Matt but you did not see me pull my vote did you?

[hmmhmmcamo]

leaving work for real now...back in a bit

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

What do you want to hear? If it's my time to go I'll reveal what my power is and what my night action was last night. Then I get voted out, my card flips town, and you can then use that info moving forward and know it's legit.

I get that I haven't been contributing a lot previously, but maybe it's time to let go of the"he's staying silent and praying for the hammer to drop on Matt" stuff. It's not really relevant anymore.

Don't tell me we waited to hear that.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

When is the deadline again for day 2?

Wednesday I believe.

[Mazrim]

Vote Count:

With 19 alive, it takes 10 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 7 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (3): Baxter Renegade, East Coast Flame, GirlySports

Voted:
GP_Matt (8): Oling_Roachinen, squiggs96, dissentowner, hmmhmmcamo, Wood, Puxlut, Drury18
hmmhmmcamo (8): Rathji, starseed, Timbo, Hockeyguy15, mrkajz44, formulate, Delgar, GP_Matt
Baxter Renegade Aeneas (1): GGG

The deadline is Wednesday, October 8th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[East Coast Flame]

Originally Posted by GGG

It doesn't make sense to have two people reveal if they don't need to.

A quick question for you while we wait is why did you reveal with only 7 votes on you as opposed to waiting longer?

Going to bat for hmmmmm today?

Didnt think anyone believe me if I was facing the hammer.

If GP just dropped that he was the cop right now (for example), would anyone believe him? I know I wouldn't

[Drury18]

So...are we serving dinner with this performance or is it a fend for yourself sort of thing?

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Delgar

So.... I'm going to stop responding to Oling and perhaps he should me. His suspicions of me are well documented and my more recent suspicions of his are as well. All that's happening is the thread is getting crowded with us bickering, which doesn't help the town.

PS Oling -- nothing personal on my attacks. I re-read them and had I time to think about them more would not have posted as such. But I'm still starting to think you could be scum. Voting history is going to be the story of this game.

Delgar, ignoring the extra variables, there's 4 situations:

1. I'm mafia, you're town: In that case, for whatever reason, I am trying to put a target on your back but you should still be happy to answer the questions I have for you. You're town, you got nothing to hide. I'm the person you want to keep talking in hopes I slip up or am discovered to be scum.

2. I'm town, you're town: We are both suspicious of each other and that sucks. But we should be communicating and answering each others questions. I believe I have a very fair question with regards to how you decided to pick Bowser to vote. As far as I'm aware, and correct me if I'm wrong, you came to the conclusion it had to be a Nintendo creation so that ruled out Pac-man and Sonic. Explain or correct the logic for me. The worst case scenario is we keep voting each other and when one of us get revealed the other gets lynched for their persistent questioning.

3. I'm town, you're mafia: Here it makes a bit more sense to me why you wouldn't want to have to continue to discuss things as you might get caught in an inconsistency you can't explain.

4. I'm mafia, you're mafia: In that case we're planning this in our secret thread anyways.

I'm not ruling out two, but if you aren't going to address my questions (and vice versa) then we're both hurting the town.

I don't care that you voted Puxlut, I'm just concerned how you arrived at the conclusion because I don't follow it.

And I've been persistent on mrkajz44 as well but he attempted to answer my questions and if GP_Matt does reveal town I will probably have him on my town list.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

No, but if he wants to pony up info why would I not hear it? Nobody is perfect, I could be wrong about Matt but you did not see me pull my vote did you?

Everybody revealing their powers is generally bad for the town until endgame to detect lies. So we should only be forcing reveals if we are ready to lynch. Not sure what else he could give us at this point.

[East Coast Flame]

Well, I'm off for the night, so if you want me to use the hammer it will have to wait for morning. Be smart about this everyone - don't need to rush.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by GGG

Everybody revealing their powers is generally bad for the town until endgame to detect lies. So we should only be forcing reveals if we are ready to lynch. Not sure what else he could give us at this point.

I thought he was going to post his thoughts when he got home. He is on the bubble along with Matt so if we are giving Matt time to post his thoughts why would I not give him the same opportunity?

[Mazrim]

Baxter Renegade has been replaced by Aeneas.

[starseed]

Unvote

Vote: Aeneas

[Timbo]

And the beat goes on

[Drury18]

Well this does support Baxter's numerous excuses of not being around.

[GGG]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

I thought he was going to post his thoughts when he got home. He is on the bubble along with Matt so if we are giving Matt time to post his thoughts why would I not give him the same opportunity?

Fair enough, I thought you were asking him to reveal his role.

[Kjesse]

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Delgar, ignoring the extra variables, there's 4 situations:

1. I'm mafia, you're town: In that case, for whatever reason, I am trying to put a target on your back but you should still be happy to answer the questions I have for you. You're town, you got nothing to hide. I'm the person you want to keep talking in hopes I slip up or am discovered to be scum.

2. I'm town, you're town: We are both suspicious of each other and that sucks. But we should be communicating and answering each others questions. I believe I have a very fair question with regards to how you decided to pick Bowser to vote. As far as I'm aware, and correct me if I'm wrong, you came to the conclusion it had to be a Nintendo creation so that ruled out Pac-man and Sonic. Explain or correct the logic for me. The worst case scenario is we keep voting each other and when one of us get revealed the other gets lynched for their persistent questioning.

3. I'm town, you're mafia: Here it makes a bit more sense to me why you wouldn't want to have to continue to discuss things as you might get caught in an inconsistency you can't explain.

4. I'm mafia, you're mafia: In that case we're planning this in our secret thread anyways.

I'm not ruling out two, but if you aren't going to address my questions (and vice versa) then we're both hurting the town.

I don't care that you voted Puxlut, I'm just concerned how you arrived at the conclusion because I don't follow it.

And I've been persistent on mrkajz44 as well but he attempted to answer my questions and if GP_Matt does reveal town I will probably have him on my town list.

OK you've baited me into this with a long post and so I have to respond. I've clipped a bit of it. Here's some logic for you, and frankly it leads to the conclusion you may actually be mafia.
-I know I'm not mafia. I can exclude 3 and 4.
-Are we both town? I suppose 2 is possible but I'm on you for me wanting to re-explain what I have explained in depth...it shows you didn't actually read my posts. Think CaptainCrunch's mistake.
-Your option 1, you're mafia I'm town, is entirely plausible... its you again setting up an invalid argument within the paragraph... I already answered as much as I can. To invalidate the option because of something not true, well, you just make yourself appear more mafia.

I'm sure I won't get support for this yet, but in the future, as cards flip, I think I will.

unvote
vote: Oling_Roachinen

[Oling_Roachinen]

Originally Posted by Delgar

I suppose 2 is possible but I'm on you for me wanting to re-explain what I have explained in depth...it shows you didn't actually read my posts.

If you explained why it had to be Nintendo in one of your posts, yes there's a very good chance I may have not read your posts. Mostly I'm on my phone and with mobile it's easy to miss and ssearch things.

Point me into the right direction?

[GirlySports]

These guys have nothing to say. Just a bunch of stalling and bluffing. I dont think anyone would believe it now anyways. Especially with Delgar changing votes.

Vote: GP_Matt

[starseed]

Hey Aeneas? Is that mafia thread too long to catch up?