CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by strombad

I found this game exponentially more difficult than last game. Partly because I was out of the country for almost a month of it, but also because I found town members played really recklessly, or didn't seem to play at all. Certainly not as cautiously involved as the first game.

I was suspicious of Hockeyguy, flameswin, and activeStick all for completely different reasons, and they were all town.

I think the key to contributing as a town member is involving yourself while being careful not to fire shots at too many people or one person too repetitively. Myself, flameswin, and Hockeyguy all did this and kind of sucked haha. Though we all survived to see the end of the game! So maybe I'm even wrong about that.

Guys who were silent were the most frustrating. Transplant almost cost us the cop, and activestick only became a target to me because of his complete lack of involvement. HD had a great reason for not contributing, but it still made him a big target despite being town. If I had one piece of advice for either side, it would be to contribute.

UCB actually played the perfect town game, which is why it was impossible to pick him out until it became a numbers game.

Great game all, sorry I was useless! Had fun anyway!

I think having 2 different mafia factions also made it harder.

[strombad]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

Can we all agree with was the post of the game?

Only if I can take credit for inspiring it.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by strombad

Only if I can take credit for inspiring it.

typical ass clown, not everything is about you............

[Hockeyguy15]

So Parkers do you regret steering the vote off of transplant and to hmmhmmcamo now? That pretty much would have sunk us if we went for transplant that day.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

So Parkers do you regret steering the vote off of transplant and to hmmhmmcamo now? That pretty much would have sunk us if we went for transplant that day.

I got to be honest, I did a lot of in the moment playing and not too much research.


Here is the Parker thread:

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/gRn2B2KhUCc

[Street Pharmacist]

Great game everyone. I didn't have anyone on my suspicious list turn scum. I fell victim to focusing on the posters really that were most vocal

[GGG]

I had UCB and CC and Starseed before I was nightkilled when Flameswin, Completely and CC hammered early after I asked to wait.

To me the only tell on UCB that was suspicious all game was in insistance on low post guys and that disappeared after I was killed off. UCB played just the perfect level of help. There were a few perfect posts where UCB would sum up the evidence against a few suspects, call for calm, and say he was good voting for any of 1 or 2 guys. Nice pro town behaviour.

I still don't know how the town won. CC's reveal should have been given to completely and a minimum. UCB killing dropit ended it. And why were known townies left alive? If Ineed was killed instead of say Oling the numbers would have much more favoured the mob after the cop reveal.

The gambit I liked that proved disaterous was leaving the doc alive. I figured you could push the vote to baxter the next day but instead Dropit, Completely, and CC all linked themselves together trying to push the baxter vote. Even if Baxter was doublekilled the mob would have been a great position but as I said I was onboard with not killing him and letting the town take care of it.

[GGG]

Also if anyone in any future game says "You can kill me after if I am wrong" I am voting them out for anti town behaviour immediately.

Delgar, Flameswin, Lego, Strombad all used this logic and all agianst townies. To me it is very anti town so next game mafia or town anyone who says it gets my vote.

[devo22]

thanks for setting this up again Mazrim! Don't think I would have enjoyed being a good guy as much as I loved playing the villain

[CaptainCrunch]

Great game everyone, I hope nobody and especially undercover brother took what I said seriously, especially you Lego. For the most part this was a role play exercise for me.

I will say that my reveal was partly strategic and partly ego driven.

I thought that if I revealed, I could talk to Parker openly throw some chaos into the game and get a bunch of night kills and count on some lucky blunders by the town in the day kill.

Plus I was hoping that the minor bit of ADD that the town was suffering would call attention off of Completely and Dropit.

BTW thanks alot UCB for killing Barrow, I thought we could still put this game out of the nets.

But credit to the town, you guys started poorly for the first few games but you really did a great job in the last couple of days.

[saillias]

Originally Posted by GGG

Also if anyone in any future game says "You can kill me after if I am wrong" I am voting them out for anti town behaviour immediately.

Delgar, Flameswin, Lego, Strombad all used this logic and all agianst townies. To me it is very anti town so next game mafia or town anyone who says it gets my vote.

Agreed. You getting night-killed was the main reason I suspected strombad of being mafia.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

Great game everyone, I hope nobody and especially undercover brother took what I said seriously, especially you Lego. For the most part this was a role play exercise for me.

I will say that my reveal was partly strategic and partly ego driven.

I thought that if I revealed, I could talk to Parker openly throw some chaos into the game and get a bunch of night kills and count on some lucky blunders by the town in the day kill.

Plus I was hoping that the minor bit of ADD that the town was suffering would call attention off of Completely and Dropit.

BTW thanks alot UCB for killing Barrow, I thought we could still put this game out of the nets.

But credit to the town, you guys started poorly for the first few games but you really did a great job in the last couple of days.

In hindsight I shouldn't have killed dropit, but I will say it felt soooooo gooood.

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

In hindsight I shouldn't have killed dropit, but I will say it felt soooooo gooood.

that's why I was begging the town for one last night kill, because I knew it was you in Parker, its your style and some of the things you said.

To be honest I had it down to you or HG15.

But to be honest with the town, if you had given me a night kill last night to go after mafia, I would have killed a townie.

Villain move.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

that's why I was begging the town for one last night kill, because I knew it was you in Parker, its your style and some of the things you said.

To be honest I had it down to you or HG15.

But to be honest with the town, if you had given me a night kill last night to go after mafia, I would have killed a townie.

Villain move.

What you talkin 'bout Willis?

[CaptainCrunch]

Oh, and one more time because I just love the graphic



Out of the darkness and into the light

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

What you talkin 'bout Willis?

I think I know you well enough from the boards by now, but as soon as my last hidden Barrow was killed by a Parker member I was pretty sure it was you.

You played a great game by the way.

[Baxter Renegade]

UCB was really on board with me when I was publicly asking Maz about the cop rules. This made me feel he was a trusty townie. He also didn't set himself to private, we could all see when he was browsing the forum/thread... This solidified my beliefs of him being town.

Sneaky, sneaky!

[HalifaxDrunk]

Originally Posted by strombad

HD had a great reason for not contributing, but it still made him a big target despite being town. If I had one piece of advice for either side, it would be to contribute.

I was contributing early on, later I did have my reason for not being active but still posted every Mafia day. I was sure starseed was mafia (damn Delgar cover-up) and stuck to that, it was correct but did limit my posting. I knew if I started posting other ideas I'd change my own mind.

I think this time the game caught me off guard by it's sheer volume of posts. Looking at the first game there were 1,430 total posts (including post game), this thread is already at 2,356. Most of my reading/posting was from work and I was always behind.

I still had a blast and will prob take the next game off but will play again.

[bizaro86]

I can definitely see flameswin's point from last time. When you go out early (after day 2 in my case) it only whet's your appetite for the game.

I will definitely be signing up next time around.

Thanks to Mazrim for setting this up and running it!

[CaptainCrunch]

Yeah I would definitely want to take the next game off and let someone knew come into play. But the bottom line is that some people were looking at the last game for clues, which is crazy as we were all playing different roles.