CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Mazrim]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

There are a lot of players that have gone by the way side in this game.

Flameswin doesn't really post
Strombad same same, in fact the last post he made was May 18, 2014, WTF?

I wasn't keeping track of posting over the long weekend since many people would be busy or out of town. flameswin posted plenty the previous game day anyway.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by Mazrim

I wasn't keeping track of posting over the long weekend since many people would be busy or out of town. flameswin posted plenty the previous game day anyway.

Oh yeah, I forgot that (I wasn't on line at all the long weekend).


I actually wasn't angling towards you with that post, it was more a:

Why are they not posting post, do they have something to hide?


I will say to you that this version is way harder than the last game I played.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by Mazrim

I wasn't keeping track of posting over the long weekend since many people would be busy or out of town. flameswin posted plenty the previous game day anyway.

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

Oh yeah, I forgot that (I wasn't on line at all the long weekend).


I actually wasn't angling towards you with that post, it was more a:

Why are they not posting post, do they have something to hide?


I will say to you that this version is way harder than the last game I played.

I am getting pretty ####ing frustrated.

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

Oh yeah, I forgot that (I wasn't on line at all the long weekend).


I actually wasn't angling towards you with that post, it was more a:

Why are they not posting post, do they have something to hide?


I will say to you that this version is way harder than the last game I played.

I'm kind of just watching this craziness between dissentowner and hockeyguy15 right now. Plus I was super sure CBL was mafia and all my suspicions of others were based of him being mafia, so I'm kind of starting from scratch here.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by flameswin

I'm kind of just watching this craziness between dissentowner and hockeyguy15 right now. Plus I was super sure CBL was mafia and all my suspicions of others were based of him being mafia, so I'm kind of starting from scratch here.

Yeah I thought CBL was mafia as well, but he turns out to be the oddest townie ever.......


I think I might go back and look at this thoughts to see where to go.


Didn't he have a hard on for Baxter?

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by flameswin

I'm kind of just watching this craziness between dissentowner and hockeyguy15 right now. Plus I was super sure CBL was mafia and all my suspicions of others were based of him being mafia, so I'm kind of starting from scratch here.

Ditto.

Crazy Bacon Legs blew my mind. I don't feel worthy of posting thoughts right now...

[Hockeyguy15]

Would be nice if you guys would comment one way or another on what I believe to be the proof that dissentower is the last member of the Parker mafia. So far everyone is just quiet about it, am I right or am I wrong?

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

Yeah I thought CBL was mafia as well, but he turns out to be the oddest townie ever.......


I think I might go back and look at this thoughts to see where to go.


Didn't he have a hard on for Baxter?

Yeah, He wanted to eat my soul and see my children suffer at the hands of Hitler.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Would be nice if you guys would comment one way or another on what I believe to be the proof that dissentower is the last member of the Parker mafia. So far everyone is just quiet about it, am I right or am I wrong?

Hockeyguy, you've brought up some intriguing information regarding Diss... Thats some good sleuthing.

I assumed Transplant was a townie with no role due to the fact he was so inactive... Even after being called out, he didnt really care. A mafia member would likely be more active to avoid lynch and would likely be motivated by his peers. But if I've learned anything from this game, it's that assumptions kill townies...

I'm going to focus on Diss, Lego and Saillias.

I think looking at guys who have been unusually quiet should be looked at also... With the game as it is, scum may be trying to slip by unnoticed.

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Hockeyguy, you've brought up some intriguing information regarding Diss... Thats some good sleuthing.

I assumed Transplant was a townie with no role due to the fact he was so inactive... Even after being called out, he didnt really care. A mafia member would likely be more active to avoid lynch and would likely be motivated by his peers. But if I've learned anything from this game, it's that assumptions kill townies...

I'm going to focus on Diss, Lego and Saillias.

I think looking at guys who have been unusually quiet should be looked at also... With the game as it is, scum may be trying to slip by unnoticed.

Take a hard look at Lego

He's screaming Scum.

He's tried to make two deals now, one to keep him in the game til the end by promising not to vote, and the most recent one to draw the doctor out.

He's randomly targeted

He lied in one case and admitted that he lied in terms of accusing a poster of suspicious posting.

and then he goes fairly quiet.

He hedged his bet heavily on Starseed a known scum

People think I've obsessed on him and I'm refusing to move off of him. There's a reason for it.

He's mob.

[Completely]

I think we need to fix all this ####ting all over each other. These arguments have nothing really positive to bring to the game, as entertaining as they are. We aren't accomplishing a whole lot last time it ended in CBL shooting himself. Now we have battles going on between everyone. Shouldn't we be working as a team? Imagine how easy it'd be for mafia to just sit there and watch this gong show.

Once again, we should be posting our lists of 2-3 people we are suspicious of or even people that we don't like the feel of. That way everyone has an idea where everyone else stands and that we can actually work towards Lynching people with a general majority, rather than another townie to screw up and say something condemning for us to jump on the bandwagon.

We have lynched one mafia, isn't that a tad embarrassing to anyone else? I mean even Parker mafia has killed as many. Baxter had three times as many as we do. I feel as if the new people are in a tough spot, they might have been lurking the thread and have their own opinions but we have no opinions of them besides what their predecessors said and even then its two different people. Different opinions, different strategies.

But we should be looking for what to do as a community, even if there is four mafia left that's still ten townies who can collectively work towards getting things done.

[ineedanother]

Originally Posted by ineedanother

After CofR flipping Parker, all 3 members of their group voted the same for the first 2 votes. Only CofR did not vote the last 3 are there might be more connection. Right now there are still 4 players who voted the same way for the first 2 votes, and they all have voted against every town lynch. The 4 I speak of are HG15, Rathji, flameswin, and Baxter Renegade. I now believe that the last Parker member is one of these 4, or the 2 players that did not cast a vote on day 1, which are dissentowner/transplant and Completely, they both also voted against all other town lynchs. To me this gives us a list of 6 players, with I believe 1 of them being Prker mafia. I know this goes against my last post but I think it is too much coincidence that all known mafia voted the same for the first 2 votes.
Hockeyguy15
Rathji
Flameswin
Baxter Renegade
Dissentowner
Completely

Quoting this post as it seems to have been glossed over amid the dissentowner/Hockeyguy15 argument.
I would like to add that of these 6 only 2 players did not vote for a Parker member when starseed was lynched, and that was Rathji and Dissentowner.

[Baxter Renegade]

Lego has been on my radar for a bit... He really peaked my Spidey Sense on day 5 and escaped a lynching due to CBL managing to swing the popular vote from Lego/Flameswin to me.

Vote: Legoman

That being said, I really like the connection Hockeyguy made regarding Diss being the final member of Parker... Im still looking into it myself, but he seems to be a valid lynch target once Lego is worm food.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Lego has been on my radar for a bit... He really peaked my Spidey Sense on day 5 and escaped a lynching due to CBL managing to swing the popular vote from Lego/Flameswin to me.

Vote: Legoman

That being said, I really like the connection Hockeyguy made regarding Diss being the final member of Parker... Im still looking into it myself, but he seems to be a valid lynch target once Lego is worm food.

So you want to lynch two townies. How did you survive again Mr. Dr?

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

So you want to lynch two townies. How did you survive again Mr. Dr?

I survived due to not being lynched and neither mafia faction targeting me... Why didn't the mafia target me? Likely due to each assuming the other would kill me and each not wanting to waste their night kill.

Nothing against you dude, alls we have to go by is bits and pieces of "evidence" based on behaviors and patterns... You seem to fit the bill.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

I survived due to not being lynched and neither mafia faction targeting me... Why didn't the mafia target me? Likely due to each assuming the other would kill me and each not wanting to waste their night kill.

If I was mob you would have been dead last night. It makes no sense.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

If I was mob you would have been dead last night. It makes no sense.

I already suggested that you and CofR likely left him alive because you knew it would make people suspicious, and then you would be free to try and night kill someone else. You were probably hoping to even the score with a barrow kill and missed.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

If I was mob you would have been dead last night. It makes no sense.

Well 5 mobsters were alive and well during night 5... None of them agreed to waste me... It does make sense when you think about mafia kills being win-win as long as they kill someone not on their roster...

[Hockeyguy15]

Dissentowner you never did say what happened in the 12 hours between you being ok voting Lego and then saying he was town and to not bother.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Dissentowner you never did say what happened in the 12 hours between you being ok voting Lego and then saying he was town and to not bother.

He hinted he was the cop, too risky to vote him out.