CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[HalifaxDrunk]

I didn't sway my vote from Lego Man and still feel strongest that he is Mafia (others are closing in on him though).

Time to lose the little plastic person.

Vote: Lego Man

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

I did not defend starseed, I had 3 others I was more suspicious of than him but stated I was leaning toward him being mafia. Nice try though.

You show up and subtly try and sway the vote away from him, trying to plant the seed of doubt while being non-commital about him so you can use this defence like you are doing now. Instead of giving 1 strong option you throw out multiple names because you don't want to seem to eager in your defence of him (oh and now you also throw out multiple names). The only time anyone from your mafia faction stuck their neck out was when the vote was heading towards transplant/you. Why would 2 of the 4 memebers from your faction go to the visible defense of transplant that early in the game if he wasn't in their group? If transplant/you were actually town why wouldn't they be fine with letting him go?

Originally Posted by dissentowner

My top 3 are as follows

1. saillias- formerly kermitology. Has looked suspicious to me all game, CBL is killed and flips town and he thanks the post, then quits and leaves saillias to try and survive his mess. saillias first post makes sure he states he was town right away, like he was trying to do damage control.

2. Baxter Renegade: If he really is the doctor then how in the hell did he survive the night? That should be a no brainer kill for the mafia

3. Hockeyguy15: He is scrambling now, trying to put attention elsewhere because we are sniffing him out.

Actually I'm not scrambling, oddly enough you seem to be the one scrambling now that I have brought the link of your mafia faction up. Add the fact that you are now alone in your group and you are running scared. The other mafia faction is playing a better game than you since they are hidden and your faction is almost gone. If I was part of your rival faction why would I be this vocal about just one person? If I am really trying to take the heat off myself I should mention multiple people that the others are already questioning (just like you have done). It looks to me like during the night you and CofR just tried to throw a dart and hope it hit a rival mafia member, thinking that if you didn't kill Baxter you would instantly have a scapegoat to sway the vote to so you could by yourself more time to stay hidden. The other mafia group killed CofR and now you are scrambling because you are out in the open and alone.

[DropIt]

I've been on the vote Lego man train for the last 2 days and frankly am shocked he has lasted this long after his antics of calling just about every person here out and then dissapearing once he was called out on it.

Vote Legoman

[undercoverbrother]

Here are some initial thoughts, just off the top of my head:

1. kermitology saillias : I struggle seeing why kermitology would throw his toys out of the cot if he is mafia. I think we can all agree the town is struggling a bit, so if he is mafia why leave a game you are dominating. I had thought he was an aggressive dick mafia, but his quitting has lead me to believe he is town, and just frustrated.

4. Rathji

5. Hockeyguy15

7. Strombad: still wonder why he went crazy for Active stick and then shut up.
8. Flameswin

13. transplant99 dissentowner: Believe him to be town. At first I thought
Transplant99 should go based on lack of participation.

15. Baxter Renegade: Says he is the Doctor, went toe to toe with a townie.

16. Ineedanother: Town, this we know.

17. HalifaxDrunk

18. Lego Man: I will admit he has been the funniest poster in this game. That being said some of his stuff has made be scratch my head. Captain Crunch called him out on a phrasing gaff, much like Activestick was called out, but it never stuck.

19. Undercoverbrother: I am town, but what else would you expect me to write.
25. CaptainCrunch:

29. Completely

30. DropIt

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Actually I'm not scrambling, oddly enough you seem to be the one scrambling now that I have brought the link of your mafia faction up. Add the fact that you are now alone in your group and you are running scared. The other mafia faction is playing a better game than you since they are hidden and your faction is almost gone. If I was part of your rival faction why would I be this vocal about just one person? If I am really trying to take the heat off myself I should mention multiple people that the others are already questioning (just like you have done). It looks to me like during the night you and CofR just tried to throw a dart and hope it hit a rival mafia member, thinking that if you didn't kill Baxter you would instantly have a scapegoat to sway the vote to so you could by yourself more time to stay hidden. The other mafia group killed CofR and now you are scrambling because you are out in the open and alone.

You are scrambling, big time. I can't say what T99 was doing because he didn't really play the game, thus why he was replaced. Now the town has zeroed in on you and you are trying to throw the focus on me instead but it isn't going to work. I am convinced you are the last Barrows mafia and you are the one running by yourself.

[dissentowner]

Unvote
Vote:Hockeyguy15

[Hockeyguy15]

3 Borrow and 1 Parker (you) are left.

Vote for me then everyone, and tomrrow you can vote out dissentowner after I flip town.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

3 Borrow and 1 Parker (you) are left.

Vote for me then everyone, and tomrrow you can vote out dissentowner after I flip town.

Sounds like something a mafia would say to try and save his skin.

[Hockeyguy15]

I 100% believe dissentowner is the last member of the Parker mafia. Kill me, I flip town with no power and then vote dissentowner if you don't believe me.

[saillias]

Not my preferred strategy because it doesn't account for the possibility you're both town who just got into an argument.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Sounds like something a mafia would say to try and save his skin.

Go look at the link I posted between bizaro, starseed, CofR, and transplant/dissentowner. Tell me I am wrong.

Everyone assumes that dissentowner is town because he replaced an inactive member. That is the ONLY reason you guys think he is town.

There is no logical reason bizaro and starseed would have been so vocal about steering the vote off transplant so early, other than he was a member of Parker mafia.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by saillias

Not my preferred strategy because it doesn't account for the possibility you're both town who just got into an argument.

It's not an argument. As I said to UCB, go and look at the link between the 4 of them.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by saillias

Not my preferred strategy because it doesn't account for the possibility you're both town who just got into an argument.

This is the worst case scenario and one I am worried about. I know I am town, I think most of you realize that as well. We have to be sure we get a mafia on this lynch. I will back off and wait for a bit actually, I want to hear from Lego. He has been super quiet.
Unvote

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

It's not an argument. As I said to UCB, go and look at the link between the 4 of them.

There is no link, stop making crap up.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

This is the worst case scenario and one I am worried about. I know I am town, I think most of you realize that as well. We have to be sure we get a mafia on this lynch. I will back off and wait for a bit actually, I want to hear from Lego. He has been super quiet.
Unvote

vote

unvote

vote

unvote

Am I am the one scrambling?

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

vote

unvote

vote

unvote

Am I am the one scrambling?

No, I am trying to make sure I don't vote in the moment unlike you who does not care. For somebody who claims they are town you sure are avoiding the players most suspected of being mafia.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

There is no link, stop making crap up.

I'm not making anything up, it's all there in my quotes.

Bizaro suggests we vote for hmmhmmcamo (flipped town), not activeStick (flipped town) and transplant

starseed agrees with him and votes hmmhmmcamo.

CofR says transplant is a good target, then votes hmmhmmcamo (never voting for transplant).

transplant votes hmmhmmcamo.

Then you take over for transplant when starseed is in trouble and say you think he is mafia but could be wrong and you never vote against him.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

No, I am trying to make sure I don't vote in the moment unlike you who does not care. For somebody who claims they are town you sure are avoiding the players most suspected of being mafia.

Why should I vote for most suspected when clearly you have the biggest link to the 3 known members of Parker mafia?

Should I just follow everyone else and vote for the most suspected, like when we lynched hmmhmmcamo, activeStick, agulati, CBL, or any other lynch that flipped town?

[saillias]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

It's not an argument. As I said to UCB, go and look at the link between the 4 of them.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the post I'm reading doesn't account for Legoman. Legoman put all his eggs into the starseed basket. He did NOT want us to vote him out.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

I 100% believe dissentowner is the last member of the Parker mafia. Kill me, I flip town with no power and then vote dissentowner if you don't believe me.

So you are using the flameswin approach because it has kept him alive. Keep scrambling.