CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Ok, but he could do so pre-lynch? Or he could throw out this data at anytime while alive, outing himself in the process?

I believe that is completely acceptable.

I know we used the "rules of the game" to our advantage last game.

[Mazrim]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Ok, but he could do so pre-lynch? Or he could throw out this data at anytime while alive, outing himself in the process?

It's in the best interest of the town to reveal the information when it benefits the town the most. It's up to them to reveal or not reveal the information, of course.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Ok, but he could do so pre-lynch? Or he could throw out this data at anytime while alive, outing himself in the process?

Sure he could but he would most likely be killed by the mafia right away. I feel sorry for whomever is carrying the burden of that job!

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

You will not I have not voted. I am suspicious of you, and your timing. We have run into lynching our own people before (yes I was on those trains). Starseed was singing like a bird, we it fluff designed to muddy the waters or was it on point and Barrow was getting uncomfortable.


We had time to discuss things more, and Starseed (as the clocked ticked down) would have become more desperate.

I can't see the positive in shutting him up early.

Was it really early though? He said he had thoughts on Baxter and C.C. and everyone, myself included, waited fornhim to post those thoughts and he did. Afterwards there was a long lull in which nobody really moved on their stance.

Also, unless you think he was going to out the rest of his mafia gang I do t know what else we would have seen?

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Can someone post a chart of Parker and Barrow confirmed members as well as confirmed kills by each again? i know one was posted before but i dont have time to search right now... I gotta do some stupid work and make some stupid money to pay stupid bills.

Do you mean this post:

Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen

Obvious and not a much to go on but might make sense to take a look at the Mafia's individuals actions so far instead of just lumping them together. So far we have:

Barrow Mafia kills:
Day 1: Delgar or GP_Matt
Day 2: bizaro86
Day 3: GGG

Parker Mafia kills:
Day 1: Delgar or GP_Matt
Day 2: dsavillian
Day 3: devo22

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by DropIt

Was it really early though? He said he had thoughts on Baxter and C.C. and everyone, myself included, waited fornhim to post those thoughts and he did. Afterwards there was a long lull in which nobody really moved on their stance.

Also, unless you think he was going to out the rest of his mafia gang I do t know what else we would have seen?

And neither do I, cuz he was killed before he could post more.....

[dissentowner]

Also can somebody fill me in on how we know for certain ineedanother is a town member?

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Also can somebody fill me in on how we know for certain ineedanother is a town member?

He is the vigilante.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

He is the vigilante.

Ah, so he revealed his role?

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Also can somebody fill me in on how we know for certain ineedanother is a town member?

He killed Timbo,

Go to the first page of the thread, to link to it.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

He killed Timbo,

Go to the first page of the thread, to link to it.

Wow, that sucks he had to do that on the first day. I have been working backwards through this thread and had not made it that far yet.

[HalifaxDrunk]

Originally Posted by Lego Man

Vote: HalifaxDrunk I am almost certain HD is mafia at this point.

With no proof whatsoever you were "almost certain I was mafia", then never followed that idea when no one else bit.

Originally Posted by Lego Man

Good luck with that!

This is your response to my calling you on it, specifically saying I would out you as Mafia. No defense, just this simple post trying to dismiss my investigation.

In an exchange with CaptainCrunch you fall back on the old faithful passive aggressive retort:

Originally Posted by Lego Man

Have fun with that.

A also agree your plan to just blindly follow ineed's random vote is an attempt to hide in plain sight. Why would you care where your vote goes when you can just accomplish a kill at night with your Mafia buddies.

Vote: Lego Man

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by undercoverbrother

And neither do I, cuz he was killed before he could post more.....

He said had analysis on CaptainCrunch and Baxter and was hoping he could state it before he got lynched. I told him I was happy to wait for him to give the analysis and he did. It didn't seem to change anyone's opinion and I was still convinced he was mafia, which he was.

In a game where he still wins if his mafia wins, there was no way he was going to draw attention to them. That was my train of thought anyways.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by DropIt

He said had analysis on CaptainCrunch and Baxter and was hoping he could state it before he got lynched. I told him I was happy to wait for him to give the analysis and he did. It didn't seem to change anyone's opinion and I was still convinced he was mafia, which he was.

In a game where he still wins if his mafia wins, there was no way he was going to draw attention to them. That was my train of thought anyways.

Information/posts/lies are important in this game, that is all I am saying. We had enough votes to kill him. Perhaps those that jumped off the bandwagon are important, ie: Rathji (although I think Rathji is one of us).


My point is we need to let things play out, your desire to stop that process concerns me.

[dissentowner]

We could look at it this way in regards to Legoman and HD. Most of us have a high suspicion of Lego after he went to bat big time for starseed who ended up flipping mafia. Now he is saying he is sure HD is mafia. So if we lynch Lego and he flips town then maybe that points toward HD being mafia.

[ineedanother]

A few points here. All 3 flipped mafia members voted out hmmhmmcamo and Agulati. This was the before CBL brought up the voting patterns. There were 10 people who voted out both hmmhmmcamo and Agulati, so far 3 are mafia and 2 flipped town. That leaves 5 people left of this group, they are as follows with who they voted for after the second vote.
Hockeyguy15 - activeStick, CofR
Rathji - activeStick, CaptainCrunch
flameswin - activeStick, starseed
Baxter Renegade - activeStick, starseed
CofR - no votes

Other 5 of 10
Bizaro86 - killed night 2 by Barrow
devo22 - transplant99, killed night 3 by Parker
Starseed - activeStick, CaptainCrunch, lynched day 4
Street Pharmacist - transplant99, starseed, killed night 4
Aeneas - no votes, killed night 4

[Baxter Renegade]

UPDATED!

Barrow Mafia kills (Confirmed members = Devo22):
NIGHT 1: Delgar or GP_Matt
NIGHT 2: bizaro86
NIGHT 3: GGG
NIGHT 4: Aeneas or Street Pharmacist

Parker Mafia kills (Confirmed members = Bizaro86, Starseed):
NIGHT 1: Delgar or GP_Matt
NIGHT 2: dsavillian
NIGHT 3: devo22
NIGHT 4: Aeneas or Street Pharmacist

I'm good with lynching Lego, but this updated list should make it easier for all of us to dig up some dirt.

[Lego Man]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

We could look at it this way in regards to Legoman and HD. Most of us have a high suspicion of Lego after he went to bat big time for starseed who ended up flipping mafia. Now he is saying he is sure HD is mafia. So if we lynch Lego and he flips town then maybe that points toward HD being mafia.

No, I said HD was mafia at the beginning on yesterday, and then changed my mind and my vote. I accused HD to see how he would respond, and his response didn't give me the vibe as a mafia playing games.

I've said already this morning whom I am suspicious of, and HD is not on that list. I have to agree with CC in that I haven't been a very useful town member thus far, so don't throw HD under the bus after my flip because of my accusation. That would be unfounded.

Like I said in post 1578, I'm still suspicious of CofR and DropIt, and now a little more of CaptainCrunch - but I could be way off. I'm also suspicious of Completey just because he's too much under the radar and not participating.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

We could look at it this way in regards to Legoman and HD. Most of us have a high suspicion of Lego after he went to bat big time for starseed who ended up flipping mafia. Now he is saying he is sure HD is mafia. So if we lynch Lego and he flips town then maybe that points toward HD being mafia.

He also:

Originally Posted by Lego Man

Unvote: Agulati

You owe me one brah.

But I can't recall where in that train wreck he unvoted, perhaps a perfect cover.

[Rathji]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

We could look at it this way in regards to Legoman and HD. Most of us have a high suspicion of Lego after he went to bat big time for starseed who ended up flipping mafia. Now he is saying he is sure HD is mafia. So if we lynch Lego and he flips town then maybe that points toward HD being mafia.

Having town accuse someone of being mafia and being proven town says nothing about the mafia status of the person he accused. They know as little as you do about that status (assuming you are also town).