CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Rathji]

This has been in my notes for a while, but hadn't made all the connections until now.

This exchange to start Day 2, HG mentions the slipup by agulati, but CC was the first to vote agulati and bizaro86 was quick to pile on

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

What are you talking about with night kills? Only mafia can do night kills.

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

But its another day, sun came up, we bury out dead, seize their property and move on.

Originally Posted by agulati

Very mafia-like statement there CC.

Originally Posted by CaptainCrunch

That Agulati post is making me itch in terms of the night kill, it almost reads like a post in the wrong thread. I'm throwing a vote out there, just to see if there's a confession.



Vote Agulati

Originally Posted by bizaro86

Or maybe a Freudian slip. Definitely moves agulati up the suspects list, imo.

[Rathji]

Vote CaptainCrunch

[Aeneas]

Well done Starseed. Still have no idea whether you are town or not, but not voting for you.

Love the Sword of Damocles line.

[jayswin]

Haha, holy crap. Starseed is dishing it all lol! I don't see how he doesn't flip town at this point, and I'm now pretty damn sure captain is mafia.

Only crappy thing is if he really is just doing a good job and is actually mafia and we don't off him and he's actually directed us away from his buddies?

I think we may be better off still going with him just because all of his spilled info goes a lot further if the seed of doubt that he may be mafia has been removed.

What do others think? Especially you guys not saying much. What is there, like 20 players left? C'mon.

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by starseed

Alright, I decided not to create a more extensive list, as I think it is in the best interests of the doctor/cop/RB'er to have greater numbers to hide amongst. So I will instead further research and layout my suspicions for my top suspects. (I was hoping you #######s would do the work when I was gone, but you instead decided to let the sword of damocles hang over me for the whole day)

CC:

• Starting the agulati train, then bailing when it was assured, while stating that he still suspected agulati (perhaps to prevent more jumpoffs?). This would at least take him off of CBL's list of people who always voted for the lynch.
• Potential connection to completely. Could be reason why he targeted LegoMan starting before agulati hammer:
• From the beginning of the thread, CC hints to mafia that they need a truce, such as: more hints to other mafia?: More discussing reasons for mafia kills:
• Then there was the bizarre exchange with legoman.
• I just dont buy the "Im surprised I am alive" type of posts:
• Yesterday and today he was in with completely to try and rush the hammer

Completely would be implicated with a CC mafia flip I would think.





He also echoed CC's points on agulati. A lot of his other posts dont have much substance.


(I am going to post this now, as I see more posts coming in, and I am paranoid that hammer is going to fall before I submit this... baxter thoughts, plus thoughts on game psychology to come)

I would agree that CC does come across incriminating when you put his posts back-to-back like that, there does seem to be a few oddly spoken posts in and out of those quoted..

I'm not sure that I would agree with the Completely theory based on one, thinly veiled post to incriminate the tow of them together, but I could see where your thoughts on CC comes from.

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by flameswin

Haha, holy crap. Starseed is dishing it all lol! I don't see how he doesn't flip town at this point, and I'm now pretty damn sure captain is mafia.

Only crappy thing is if he really is just doing a good job and is actually mafia and we don't off him and he's actually directed us away from his buddies?

I think we may be better off still going with him just because all of his spilled info goes a lot further if the seed of doubt that he may be mafia has been removed.

What do others think? Especially you guys not saying much. What is there, like 20 players left? C'mon.

I'm still leaning towards my assessment earlier of starseed and think he may be mafia still and doing a very good job of talking his way out of it. However if he does get voted, then his cardflip turns out to be huge and gives us our first good lead going one way or the other. CC or Lego really.

[Crazy Bacon Legs]

Starseed is convincing, that's for sure.

I'm sticking to my guns. I am keeping my vote for him.

That said, there is certainly a possibility that some of the people he mentioned are from the other mafia group.

Again, if the hammer comes down soon and I die during the night, remember what I wrote.

[CaptainCrunch]

Originally Posted by starseed

Alright, I decided not to create a more extensive list, as I think it is in the best interests of the doctor/cop/RB'er to have greater numbers to hide amongst. So I will instead further research and layout my suspicions for my top suspects. (I was hoping you #######s would do the work when I was gone, but you instead decided to let the sword of damocles hang over me for the whole day)

CC:

• Starting the agulati train, then bailing when it was assured, while stating that he still suspected agulati (perhaps to prevent more jumpoffs?). This would at least take him off of CBL's list of people who always voted for the lynch.

• Pretty weak, look at the post that Agulati dropped, I don't believe I was the first accusation but I was pretty decisive in terms of putting up the vote. I absolutely bailed because I knew that Agulati was going to be lynched and I wanted to call attention to a poster that lied in his accusation and is pretty big on random targeting, a person that I might add has tried to protect you. Three pretty big mafia bullet points to me.

  Originally Posted by starseed

  Potential connection to completely. Could be reason why he targeted LegoMan starting before agulati hammer:

  or again, I posted a guy who basically targets everyone, has lied and is very random in his approach which is something that a mobster would do since they don't care about who they kill as long as its not one of them.

• Originally Posted by starseed

  From the beginning of the thread, CC hints to mafia that they need a truce, such as: more hints to other mafia?: More discussing reasons for mafia kills:

  I think this is pretty weak sauce, part of this game is trying to stay ahead of the mafia and think like the mafia, what I said stands to absolute reason, if I was mafia, I would be certainly trying to make sure that my night kills were most effective and I was trying to find ways to avoid killing other mafia members for as long as possible. but I guess trying to strategize out loud like a mafia would is more of an indicator of guilt then a blatent lie in an accusation and randomly targeting and throwing stuff at as many people as possible to see what sticks is the preferred method[/quote]

• Originally Posted by starseed

  Then there was the bizarre exchange with legoman.

  So in the last game I was gutted for changing my posting style, and in this game I do what I normally do which is banter and post hard and its suspicious.

• Originally Posted by starseed

  I just dont buy the "Im surprised I am alive" type of posts:

  uh ?I was genuinely concerned that I was going to be night killed, I called out two mafia suspects based on posts that were pretty damning. I don't know how to defend myself from this because it stinks like poop throwing.

• Originally Posted by starseed

  Yesterday and today he was in with completely to try and rush the hammer

  Today especially I agree because if and when you flip mob it goes a long way to proving that Lego is in the same group as you based on his protection of you.

Originally Posted by starseed

Completely would be implicated with a CC mafia flip I would think.

Interesting, I could say the same thing about you and Lego with a mafia flip on you.







He also echoed CC's points on agulati. A lot of his other posts dont have much substance.


(I am going to post this now, as I see more posts coming in, and I am paranoid that hammer is going to fall before I submit this... baxter thoughts, plus thoughts on game psychology to come)[/QUOTE]

[DropIt]

unvote

vote: starseed

Feel like Starseed's cardflip needs to happen at this point given everything that has gone on around him. It should open some doors on to how we progress from here.

[Hockeyguy15]

I believe that is hammer...No more posts (flameswin).

[Mazrim]

Vote Count:

With 20 alive, it takes 11 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 7 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (3): CofR, dissentowner, ineedanother

Voting:
starseed (11): HalifaxDrunk, Baxter Renegade, Oling_Roachinen, flameswin, strombad, Crazy Bacon Legs, Street Pharmacist, undercoverbrother, Completely, CaptainCrunch, DropIt
CaptainCrunch (3): starseed, kermitology, Rathji
CofR (2): Hockeyguy15, Lego Man
dissentowner (1): Aeneas

A long, tiring day drew to a close. The fog never quite dissapated, which put quite a few on edge. There was plenty of heated debate that spurred the town to action, and eventually the consensus was that starseed had to die.

Unlike some of the other poor souls that were lynched earlier, starseed was not content to go quietly. There was plenty of shouting and struggling as they brought starseed aside to finish the day off. His final words surprised many, as he shouted "What a waste of time! You've already given this town away, fools. It's too late to change what we started!"

With that said, it was much easier for them to take care of starseed.

starseed, Parker Mafia, lynched Day 4.

The Mafia numbers were beginning to drop, but was he right? Was there enough time to finish the rest off before they took over? Cautious optimism seemed to be the feeling for many as they left the town square into the fog that evening.

It is now Night 4. You may not post in the thread during this time.

If you have night actions, they must be PM'd to me by Thursday, May 15th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time. Please title the PM "Night 4 Action". If everyone submits their night actions before the deadline, I will open the thread as soon as I process all actions.

[Mazrim]

Silence. It was very quiet this early morning. The fog was gone, but it was too quiet. The wind was gone. No animals were stirring. Nothing. It was a very strange occurance around here.

After starseed's demise, many hoped for a quiet night, but that would not be the case again. This time, no Mafia would be hit in the crossfire, but they hit true on the town. A valuable member of the town was discovered have been murdered during the night.

Aeneas, Townsperson, killed Night 4.
Street Pharmacist, Roleblocker, killed Night 4.

The silence was deafening. Why was it so quiet today?

It is now Day 5. With 17 alive, it takes 9 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 6 votes to deadline lynch.

Vote Count:

Hasn’t Voted (17): kermitology, Rathji, Hockeyguy15, strombad, flameswin, CofR, dissentowner, Crazy Bacon Legs, Baxter Renegade, ineedanother, HalifaxDrunk, Lego Man, undercoverbrother, CaptainCrunch, Oling_Roachinen, Completely, DropIt

Voting:

Deadline is Tuesday, May 20th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time. Hammer cannot be dropped before Thursday, May 15th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[kermitology]

Starseed totally fooled me

[Lego Man]

[jayswin]

Me too, just at the end there.

Also, I made a post saying that we will all find out Street Pharmacist is mafia at some point in this game. Well he was definitely something.

[Hockeyguy15]

Well at least we still have the cop and doctor.

[Street Pharmacist]

----Dead post-----

You all suck. But not as bad as I did

[dissentowner]

well crap... We got one of them but they took two of us. Lego was pretty damn adamant starseed was not mob. That being said I suspect CC is more likely mob than anyone given his posts. Kermitology is not exactly inspiring any comfort for me either. I have had some more time to go over posts and my suspicious list has not gotten any easier. The only thing I changed my mind on is Rathji, I have gotten further back through the game and I am convinced he is town. I may be wrong though. Christ, what a mess.

[Oling_Roachinen]

dissentowner, you shouldn't edit posts.

[starseed]

---Dead Post---

What?!? Even I am surprised by that flip. AVENGE ME!!!