CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

CaptainCrunch's vote seals it, no?

I don't think so, Rathji unvoted.


I think we are still one short of the Hammer Time.

[ineedanother]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

CaptainCrunch's vote seals it, no?

Rathji unvoted, so that keeps it at 10

[Rathji]

Originally Posted by Street Pharmacist

CaptainCrunch's vote seals it, no?

no, I unvoted during my meeting so no single person could hammer before I had a chance to think things through.

If I revote, that would be the hammer.

[Street Pharmacist]

Let's hold off for a little bit. I've been pushing to speed things up before, but we seem to be making progress now. I still think we vote starseed, so as to not muddy the waters.

[Hockeyguy15]

Take a look at CofR's posts, tell me if I am wrong for having doubts about him.

His coasting and non-committal posts seem off to me.

[CofR]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

So you think starseed is mafia then?

I do, but I am wary of making a decision too quickly. As a town we have been really fast to lynch people, and it has not worked for us... I am just trying to be more thorough.

It will be telling to see how starseed flips as there will be tons of evidence based on what we learn. At first that was pushing me towards dropping the hammer and lynching him... But our numbers are still dropping at a pretty alarming rate and I want to be more sure before I make a vote to drop the hammer.

[Completely]

Originally Posted by ineedanother

Sorry I haven't been posting much, but I am a serial lurker, and just trying to process everything.
I can drop the hammer whenever, would like to give starseed another chance to help the town if he is a townie.

I serial lurk as well. I'm looking often. Usually inbetween doing other things.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by ineedanother

Sorry I haven't been posting much, but I am a serial lurker, and just trying to process everything.
I can drop the hammer whenever, would like to give starseed another chance to help the town if he is a townie.

I don't know if I should post an in-depth list. I could just end up helping the mafia fill their dossiers and help them zero-in on the cop/doctor. I think only giving clues to the mafia that I strongly suspect is the best thing I could do. If you want an in-depth suspect list, I will work on one.

[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by Completely

I serial lurk as well. I'm looking often. Usually inbetween doing other things.

So in short you bring nothing to the game.


At least we know ineedanother is one of us.


I am starting to think Legoman might be right.

[Rathji]

Going out with the kids for a bit, someone give me a reason to vote for CoR

[Aeneas]

I think CC thought he was dropping the hammer.
An early lynch is not good for the town, so far we have proven that.
Anyone who makes that early lynch a reality has to be held up for suspicion.

[CaptainCrunch]

Maybe but if Starseed does flip Mafia then it opens up a interesting trail of subjects including Don Lego

[dissentowner]

Hey guys, just got in from a long shift, will catch up tonight and be contributing shortly with my thoughts.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by dissentowner

Hey guys, just got in from a long shift, will catch up tonight and be contributing shortly with my thoughts.

Good luck catching up... Mother of god...

I feel we should continue voting for Starseed and hammer him. A mafia member would say anything to save his skin.

[ineedanother]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Good luck catching up... Mother of god...

I feel we should continue voting for Starseed and hammer him. A mafia member would say anything to save his skin.

I would like to hear what dissentowner has to say before we drop the hammer tonight. I know he has a lot of catching up to do, but would not want him to have to wait until the night is over, as he might get night killed before contributing anything.

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Good luck catching up... Mother of god...

I feel we should continue voting for Starseed and hammer him. A mafia member would say anything to save his skin.

I have been following quite a bit already.

[dissentowner]

We need to make sure we get this one right, we have lost too many townies and the scum are winning. I need a bit more time before I post my thoughts here, will be tonight for sure though. Glad to be playing!

[dissentowner]

Originally Posted by starseed

I don't know if I should post an in-depth list. I could just end up helping the mafia fill their dossiers and help them zero-in on the cop/doctor. I think only giving clues to the mafia that I strongly suspect is the best thing I could do. If you want an in-depth suspect list, I will work on one.

Can you do that?

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by ineedanother

I would like to hear what dissentowner has to say before we drop the hammer tonight. I know he has a lot of catching up to do, but would not want him to have to wait until the night is over, as he might get night killed before contributing anything.

Agreed, guaranteed dis is a townie with no role. Transplant's inactivity likely stemmed from no real role and therefore, lack of interest

[DropIt]

Originally Posted by starseed

I don't know if I should post an in-depth list. I could just end up helping the mafia fill their dossiers and help them zero-in on the cop/doctor. I think only giving clues to the mafia that I strongly suspect is the best thing I could do. If you want an in-depth suspect list, I will work on one.

Unless you have a strong suspicion about the cop and/or doctor then I would be interested to know who you suspect to be Mafia and how it may benefit them vs us.

I have a dog in this, seeing as my Legoman theory does include you but will wait for something before changing my vote from lego. We still have time and I dont want to see anyone axed without all angles explored.