CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[Baxter Renegade]

23 left, 16 Townies, 7 evil-doers.

I agree with others that our best bet is to sift throw Bizaro's posts and start looking at those he was trying to protect or take the attention off of. Bizaro was also one of the most active posters here... I believe at least his Mafia group had private discussions ensuring all members keep their post counts high to ensure they avoid an inactive lynching, which has worked somewhat well as no mafia has yet to be lynched.

While I'm unsure about HG's affiliation, I do like what he said here:

At this point I think the biggest red flags for me are transplant, activeStick and SP.

transplant and activeStick have been called out by people that are now dead, as well as bizaro trying to deflect attention off of them.

SP seems to agree with bizaro a lot, and there are a few instances of the two of them posting and disappearing at the same time.

For now, I'm going to go ahead and VOTE: STREET PHARMACIST

Is there a way to specifically view bizaro's posts in this thread?

[Hockeyguy15]

search this thread (under the page numbers) - advanced search

Then you can search by username.

[devo22]

Originally Posted by Baxter Renegade

Is there a way to specifically view bizaro's posts in this thread?

yes. Go to the Off Topic Forum and click the number on the right side of the topic (will be 1,061 after my post). You'll see a popup that lists the users who posted in the thread. Just click on the number on the right side of a user and see all his posts in this thread.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

search this thread (under the page numbers) - advanced search

Then you can search by username.

Originally Posted by devo22

yes. Go to the Off Topic Forum and click the number on the right side of the topic (will be 1,061 after my post). You'll see a popup that lists the users who posted in the thread. Just click on the number on the right side of a user and see all his posts in this thread.

Geez, wish I knew about this earlier... This will make life a bit easier.

[devo22]

really undecided between activeStick and transplant99. Will give it a bit more thought since I don't want to make a mistake three times in a row.

[strombad]

Originally Posted by devo22

really undecided between activeStick and transplant99. Will give it a bit more thought since I don't want to make a mistake three times in a row.

activeStick of course. They seem like two solid choices, but quite frankly, it would make complete sense to go after one and then the other (barring the possibility I'm
wrong and am then next in line of course) so it doesn't entirely matter who you pick first.

[Aeneas]

I like the activestick and transplant99 votes. Street Pharmacist I could get behind also if he was seeming to side with a known mafioso.

[Mazrim]

Vote Count:

With 23 alive, it takes 12 votes on any one player to hammer. It takes 8 votes to deadline lynch.

Hasn’t Voted (13): Hockeyguy15, flameswin, CofR, devo22, transplant99, Crazy Bacon Legs, activeStick, CaptainCrunch, Street Pharmacist, Aeneas, Oling_Roachinen, Completely, DropIt

Voting:
activeStick (6): strombad, Rathji, undercoverbrother, Lego Man, ineedanother, starseed
starseed (2): GGG, HalifaxDrunk
transplant99 (1): kermitology
Street Pharmacist (1): Baxter Renegade

Deadline is Tuesday, May 13th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time. Hammer cannot be dropped before Thursday, May 8th at 10:00 PM Mountain Time.

[activeStick]

Despite strombad's insistence on voting me out, if I get the noose, look to the group of votes after his initial vote for possible Mafia suspects.

If strombad were Mafia, he wouldn't push this hard obviously. This happens to just be a case of poor reasoning by him that will turn out to be incorrect after my card flip.

I don't mind taking the lynch for the town as it will reveal the most when it's proven I am a Townie.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by activeStick

Despite strombad's insistence on voting me out, if I get the noose, look to the group of votes after his initial vote for possible Mafia suspects.

If strombad were Mafia, he wouldn't push this hard obviously. This happens to just be a case of poor reasoning by him that will turn out to be incorrect after my card flip.

I don't mind taking the lynch for the town as it will reveal the most when it's proven I am a Townie.

No comment on why you haven't really said much this time around?

[activeStick]

I touched on this earlier - it's still very early in the game where patterns and alignments are guess work at best. A few others have commented with the same view as well.

I could post weak theories but in my view that doesn't provide any value is actually counter productive for the town.

Like I said, if the group is going to move forward and lynch me today, so be it, but once I flip as town, look to the following people - strombad, Rathji, undercoverbrother, Lego Man, ineedanother, starseed with focus on the ones after strombad.

That's not to say strombad shouldn't get lynched at some point though - he hurts the town because his theories are weak and misleads the people who listen.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by activeStick

Despite strombad's insistence on voting me out, if I get the noose, look to the group of votes after his initial vote for possible Mafia suspects.

If strombad were Mafia, he wouldn't push this hard obviously. This happens to just be a case of poor reasoning by him that will turn out to be incorrect after my card flip.

I don't mind taking the lynch for the town as it will reveal the most when it's proven I am a Townie.

I don't know why, but this sounds like desperation... Desperation masked by the ruse of false camaraderie...

UNVOTE
VOTE: ACTIVESTICK

[starseed]

Originally Posted by activeStick

I touched on this earlier - it's still very early in the game where patterns and alignments are guess work at best. A few others have commented with the same view as well.

I could post weak theories but in my view that doesn't provide any value is actually counter productive for the town.

Like I said, if the group is going to move forward and lynch me today, so be it, but once I flip as town, look to the following people - strombad, Rathji, undercoverbrother, Lego Man, ineedanother, starseed with focus on the ones after strombad.

That's not to say strombad shouldn't get lynched at some point though - he hurts the town because his theories are weak and misleads the people who listen.

Copy and paste, with no real thought to your list?

[activeStick]

Originally Posted by starseed

Copy and paste, with no real thought to your list?

I posted my thoughts already in a prior post.

Mafia will know I'm Town. Any opportunity to lynch a towns person will be welcomed by them. They just need someone who is also Town to suggest it and then pile on.

[Hockeyguy15]

He's talking about the fact you included ineedanother in your list of people to be suspicious of.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

He's talking about the fact you included ineedanother in your list of people to be suspicious of.

Yup, If there is one blatant slip up to be worried about, this is it. Hammer ActiveStick!

[starseed]

However, it could legitimately be a copy and paste issue. We were wrong before in pouncing on weak slip-ups. Nevertheless, I think a stronger defence, or at least a list is needed.

[starseed]

Originally Posted by starseed

However, it could legitimately be a copy and paste issue. We were wrong before in pouncing on weak slip-ups. Nevertheless, I think a stronger defence, or at least a list is needed.

*a real list I mean.

[DropIt]

Vote: Transplant99

going to follow through with my day 2.

Transplant still strikes me as being off and has my alarm bells going. He ducks in and out only really to defend himself and point the finger in someone's direction. Think his time should be about done here and was sure the Mafia would have done something about him by now. Seems odd the me.

[strombad]

Originally Posted by activeStick

I posted my thoughts already in a prior post.

Mafia will know I'm Town. Any opportunity to lynch a towns person will be welcomed by them. They just need someone who is also Town to suggest it and then pile on.

Which is odd, because you'd think it would've gotten more traction before Day 3, considering it's been my prime focus every day.

Also, your whole theory is nonsense. First the big excuse was "I was moving, I'm going to collect my thoughts" now it's "I don't believe in posting theories with such little evidence." Really? How long are you going to ride that train for? It's a game. You suggest the best way for everyone to play is say nothing of any significance at any time?

Either you're mafia, or you're a really poor townie. Either way, even if I have to go out right after you, I'm glad someone as lacklustre in the effort department as you are is gone because of me.