CP Mafia 2 - Town Square Showdown - Game Over

[GGG]

Originally Posted by Delgar

I haven't been on board because I think there are better choices. But it seems to have been decided.

Why havent you stated your opinion then. I believe it was yesterday you posted that you would come back last night with your thoughts. I would like to hear them before we finish off today. You havent voted for anyone.

[GGG]

Sorry Delgar I mispresented you,

You did identify HD as your preference but didnt really expand on the reasoning. The only thing I see is he part of team pile on. If you plan on giving your thoughts before the end of Day1 I would like to hold off lynching until you do.

[GGG]

unvote

Just want to make sure no one jumps the gun before or right after his pre death post. Will jump back in when we all have a chance to read and react to the death post

[hmmhmmcamo]

My card will flip town, and I have no special powers.

I realize several townsfolk will be voted out by each other so I’ll try to not take it personally being the first

This is my first time playing a game like this and the thing that jumps out at me the most is that if you aren’t participating/ contributing, you are hurting the town and helping the mafia, even if you are a towns person.

I really think it’s a bad strategy to just blindly follow ineedanother because he is proven town. It just seems like it will be very easy for the Mafia to blend in with the herd and you won’t be able to pick out any voting patterns.

I know we have next to nothing to go by this early in the game, but I want to add some thoughts on some people I’ve had my eye on (mostly for bragging rights later if I’m right about any of them).

GP_Matt: He was caught lying (post 553) about thanking posts he agreed with instead of posting the same thought again, and was using this as a justification for appearing like he wasn’t contributing very much. When I went to go find the posts he was thanking, I could only find 2 – Rathji’s avatar change, and Aeneus suggesting the hard to spell name voting strategy. Reading Matt’s post you would think there would be several. Could be something, could be nothing.

Transplant99: Hasn’t participated at all, blamed work, but still manages to pop in when he’s called out or to sneak in a vote for ineeanother in the middle of the night. Until he voted for me this afternoon he still had his vote registered for ineedanother, but had posted since ineedanother was proven town.

Rathji: He started and continued to push the ineedanother fiasco based on suspect evidence. That alone will have me watching him a bit closer as the game goes on.

HockeyGuy and Strombad: Something seems fishy with these two. Thier back and forth’s early in the game, accusing and defending each other, then voting for each other, but then both changed their vote to Kermitology and roughly the same time. Keep an eye on these two.

Kermitology: He stood out to me early as someone that was trying to post a lot but wasn’t contributing anything. I have my suspicions that he might be in cahoots with HockeyGuy and Strombad, but nothing solid to base that on right now.

Street Pharmacist: He just seems swarmy.

So that’s it.

I’m anxious for the game to move forward and see how it plays out. It’s going to be an interesting first night!

I’m ready to go now...please make it quick.

[Street Pharmacist]

Swarmy? Puuhhhleass

[Hockeyguy15]

Anyone with any objections now before the lunch goes ahead?

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

Anyone with any objections now before the lunch goes ahead?

Just make sure it's gluten free, please.

[hmmhmmcamo]

[Hockeyguy15]

thanks iPhone.

You know how to correct iPhone but you change lynch to lunch.

[Baxter Renegade]

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

My card will flip town, and I have no special powers.

I realize several townsfolk will be voted out by each other so I’ll try to not take it personally being the first

This is my first time playing a game like this and the thing that jumps out at me the most is that if you aren’t participating/ contributing, you are hurting the town and helping the mafia, even if you are a towns person.

I really think it’s a bad strategy to just blindly follow ineedanother because he is proven town. It just seems like it will be very easy for the Mafia to blend in with the herd and you won’t be able to pick out any voting patterns.

I know we have next to nothing to go by this early in the game, but I want to add some thoughts on some people I’ve had my eye on (mostly for bragging rights later if I’m right about any of them).

GP_Matt: He was caught lying (post 553) about thanking posts he agreed with instead of posting the same thought again, and was using this as a justification for appearing like he wasn’t contributing very much. When I went to go find the posts he was thanking, I could only find 2 – Rathji’s avatar change, and Aeneus suggesting the hard to spell name voting strategy. Reading Matt’s post you would think there would be several. Could be something, could be nothing.

Transplant99: Hasn’t participated at all, blamed work, but still manages to pop in when he’s called out or to sneak in a vote for ineeanother in the middle of the night. Until he voted for me this afternoon he still had his vote registered for ineedanother, but had posted since ineedanother was proven town.

Rathji: He started and continued to push the ineedanother fiasco based on suspect evidence. That alone will have me watching him a bit closer as the game goes on.

HockeyGuy and Strombad: Something seems fishy with these two. Thier back and forth’s early in the game, accusing and defending each other, then voting for each other, but then both changed their vote to Kermitology and roughly the same time. Keep an eye on these two.

Kermitology: He stood out to me early as someone that was trying to post a lot but wasn’t contributing anything. I have my suspicions that he might be in cahoots with HockeyGuy and Strombad, but nothing solid to base that on right now.

Street Pharmacist: He just seems swarmy.

So that’s it.

I’m anxious for the game to move forward and see how it plays out. It’s going to be an interesting first night!

I’m ready to go now...please make it quick.

Sooo... do we still do him? Obviously he could be lying, but I like his moxie.

[bizaro86]

Originally Posted by flameswin

Just make sure it's gluten free, please.

By need or fad diet?

[strombad]

Originally Posted by hmmhmmcamo

HockeyGuy and Strombad: Something seems fishy with these two. Thier back and forth’s early in the game, accusing and defending each other, then voting for each other, but then both changed their vote to Kermitology and roughly the same time. Keep an eye on these two.

To be fair, I'd vote out both HG15 and kermitology in a second given the chance. Unfortunately, nobody has really gotten on board with any of my suggestions, so there's little point in remarking me switching votes.

And I don't believe I've defended HG15 once yet, I'd still be perfectly happy if he went home.

[Hockeyguy15]

Originally Posted by strombad

To be fair, I'd vote out both HG15 and kermitology in a second given the chance. Unfortunately, nobody has really gotten on board with any of my suggestions, so there's little point in remarking me switching votes.

And I don't believe I've defended HG15 once yet, I'd still be perfectly happy if he went home.

You will be disappointed when I flip town, or maybe you won't be.

[Street Pharmacist]

I want to keep Kermitology strictly based on sentimentality. I follow him on Twitter and he's a long time well respected poster who didn't get to play last time and was eager to this time. Having said that, that will get me killed here, so I hope he goes

=/= logic

[GGG]

I think we have to do him in otherwise the value of the last post becomes less and mafiosos will use the last post to shake the group. If he was going to flip mafia his post would be the same as it is now. The value in this post is that we know the thoughts are genuine and like ineedanother becomes a confirmed opinion.

[strombad]

Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15

You will be disappointed when I flip town, or maybe you won't be.

Which is what absolutely every single person, town or mafia, would say.

[Hockeyguy15]

Vote: hmmhmmcamo

Sorry if you're town, we will try and win it for you.

[jayswin]

Originally Posted by bizaro86

By need or fad diet?

I love fads.

[GGG]

vote hmmhmmcamo

[hmmhmmcamo]

My post wasn't an attempt to save my bacon, but to at least try and provide some information that can be used in the future that people know is coming from an honest place.